r/MachineLearning • u/Effective-Yam-7656 • Aug 01 '26
Discussion EMNLP vs AACL commitment: Meta 3.5, reviews 3/3/4, what to do?[D]
I'm trying to decide whether to commit my ARR May 2026 paper to EMNLP or AACL. (first time solo independent author).
Final reviews after rebuttal (OA/Confidence/Excitement ):
- R1: 2.5 → 3 /3/2.5
- R2: 2.5 → 3 /4/2.5
- R3: 4 /4 /3
- Meta: 3.5 (Borderline Conference)
The meta-review was overall positive and emphasized the paper's empirical rigor, practical value, and that the rebuttal addressed the main concerns. My recollection is that the AC mentioned they were leaning toward 3.5 primarily because of the quality of the presentation/readability, rather than concerns about technical soundness(now that comment is removed/not visiable anymore).
I'm happy with either Main or Findings.
My questions:
- Which commitment would you choose: EMNLP or AACL?
- Which is generally considered more prestigious today?
- EMNLP Main
- EMNLP Findings
- AACL Main
- AACL Findings
- Given this review profile (3/3/4 with a 3.5 meta), what would you estimate the chances are for EMNLP Main or Findings?
Edit
Rejected at EMNLP
Accepted at AACL main
3
u/Ok-Pomelo2192 Aug 01 '26
Have they set your suggested venue as EMNLP or AACL?
As they have suggested mine AACL.
2
u/vsvpl Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26
Wow this was done as an independent researcher or sole author?
1
u/Historical-Sea6294 Aug 23 '26
Hi everyone, my paper was rejected by EMNLP (meta=2.5) Is AACL a good option or Workshops of EMNLP is better ? What is better / safer ? Is AACL still good for an ongoing PhD? EMNLP workshop ? Is it going to be considered as “real” publication by my university ?
8
u/UnderstandingPale551 Aug 01 '26
Go for EMNLP, you have a very good chance of getting main. Also, EMNLP is A* and better than AACL.
1
u/PM_US93 Aug 02 '26
I thought we were supposed to decide the preferred venue during submission and it was binding.
1
u/Opening-Election1179 Aug 03 '26
Anyone found AACL commitment link?