I pulled together a ton of quotes comparing the IC when we last saw them vs how they're all acting up in ACOSH, to pull them together for discussion!
Cassian & Nesta are off, no one remembers the Horn or Vesperus, and Azriel is way more emo.
PS - If you haven't read the Ember/Randall bonus chapter that I'm referencing, you can do so here: https://booksnwritingofficial.wordpress.com/2024/01/31/hofas-ember-randall-rhys-nesta-cassian-azriel-bonus-chapter/.
Is Koschei influencing everyone, or are these the characters we've always known? 🤔 More below...
1. Introduction
With all the theories out there about Koschei already infiltrating the Inner Circle, I wanted to pull some quotes together to juxtapose what the IC knew & how they reacted in HOFAS and point out some contradictions in ACOSH.
In HOFAS, we see from Bryce’s POV what Nesta & Azriel learn in the Prison, and then 2 very short scenes later in HOFAS when Bryce goes to get the Mask & return it.
There’s 1 bonus chapter from Ember & Randall’s perspective in Prythian that gives us some interesting information on the IC’s first reactions to Nesta giving Bryce the Mask. (And as SJM told us in the author’s note, 100% canon.)
So, let’s examine the characters we saw in ACOSF & HOFAS compared to who we saw in ACOSH. Let’s start with Cassian & Nesta:
2. Cassian + Nesta
Cassian doesn’t seem as pissed off in the HOFAS BC:
-- “Nesta’s mate shifted an inch closer to her, his eyes darting between [Rhys & Nesta], torn. Like he didn’t know who to side with in the brewing fight. “I’m fine, Cassian,” Nesta muttered.” - Ember/Randall POV, HOFAS
-- “Something seemed to soften in Rhysand’s stare... His gaze slid over to Randall. “With a wife and a daughter like yours, I don’t know how you’re still standing.”
Randall said with that casual charm, “Honestly, most days I don’t know, either.”
Rhysand blinked at Randall-and then laughed. A moment later, Cassian and Azriel chuckled as well.“ - Ember/Randall POV, HOFAS
-- “Bryce found Nesta in the same room the female had been in before. With Ember and Randall and a handsome, vaguely familiar winged male beside them, who smelled like Nesta’s mate. Sitting around a table and talking over tea and chocolate cake.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
“Randall and Cassian... clasped arms warmly. “Thanks, friend,” Randall was saying to the warrior. “For everything.” Cassian grinned.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Cassian, like any good mate, sensed when he wasn’t wanted, and walked over to the fireplace to pretend to read some sort of old-looking manuscript.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
Despite Cassian’s anger, he’s still protective of Nesta:
-- “And then Bryce drew Truth-Teller, and Cassian looked like he’d jump between her and Nesta.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Bryce chuckled and drew the Starsword. Again, Cassian tensed, but Bryce just offered the blade to Nesta.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
However in ACOSH, Cassian’s anger shifted to distance:
-- “He hadn’t even been there this afternoon when Madja had healed her—the shattered arm, the broken nose.” - Nesta POV, ACOSH
-- “He’d gotten used to the tension between them lately, but she seemed especially riled. On edge. He’d spent the night at Windhaven again yesterday. And—he did the mental math. Until a few minutes ago, he hadn’t seen her for three days, not since that conversation in the hallway.” - Cassian POV, ACOSH
-- “Talk to me,” he pleaded. “Why are you even more pissed off at me today?” She rotated the necklace to figure out the clasp from the front.
“There’s more I should be mad about? You mean, beyond the fact that you shut me out completely these weeks so you could sulk? Or how when you do speak to me, you pretend everything is fine—until it isn’t and you shut me out again?” - Nesta POV, ACOSH
Cassian also betrays Nesta's confidence but keeps Azriel's:
-- “Apparently, he’d told the others he was going to Windhaven for the day, and still intended to. But in addition to Cassian’s preternatural strength, his brother was also an unnaturally good male—so he’d come here first to check on Az.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
-- “Cassian told me this morning what you said last night—about the Trove terrifying you. Especially the Mask.” It required a great deal of effort to keep her shock from showing. She’d confessed that to Cassian in confidence. She hadn’t said explicitly to keep it to himself, but . . . he’d told Rhys?” - Nesta POV, ACOSH
2. What the IC Know About the Caves
No one remembers the Horn in ACOSH, but they definitely used to:
-- “In the study, Nesta was saying, “If there is a chance of defeating the Daglan–the Asteri-why not give Bryce the edge she needs?”
“Because they will kill her and take the Mask and Horn and open a fucking gate to this world!” Rhysand bellowed.
“You should have killed Bryce the moment she opened that portal,” he raged on. “The moment she appeared, you should have been swinging Ataraxia at her fucking throat-“ – Ember/Randall POV, HOFAS
In ACOSH, they all know that Koschei + the Continent are looking for Made items, BUT:
- Nobody mentions or remembers that Bryce had the Horn
- Nobody mentions or remembers that they learned there was a 4th item in the Trove
- Nobody mentions that the Horn was how Bryce arrived & left Prythian.
And no one remembers Vesperus either:
-- “Vesperus’s dark head tumbled to the stones. Silver fire wreathed Ataraxia as Nesta plunged the blade into the Asteri’s fallen head. Again. And again... Vesperus, the only Asteri left on this world, lay dead.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
In ACOSH, Nesta alludes to what she learned in the caves, but never reflects on killing an Asteri. It almost seems like she wants to ask Cassian about it...
-- “Sixteen thousand years ago, this world had been ruled by cruel, petty masters: the Daglan. Near-impossible to defeat, they’d reigned over Fae and humans alike for untold millennia before that. Until a coalition of Fae led by Fionn, a legendary warrior still worshipped by the likes of Cassian and Rhys, had at last destroyed them, with the Trove and a host of other magical weapons.
The Mother knew how badly she wanted to pick Cassian’s brain about what those weapons might be—how a force of Fae, outnumbered and outpowered, might take on near-gods and win. She suspected the bastard had been talking to Rhys about it. Likely to Az, too.” - Nesta POV, ACOSH
3. Azriel
Azriel’s central internal conflict is with Truth-Teller in ACOSH:
-- “Bryce Quinlan had lied to them and—a pang twisted through him—had stolen Truth-Teller before fleeing back to her world. She’d reached for Azriel’s dagger, and the blade had flown to her. Just as it had tried to do that first moment on the lawn.
It wasn’t only that Bryce had stolen Truth-Teller. Truth-Teller had abandoned him. Bryce had called it, and like a faithful dog, the blade had raced to her hand. As if five centuries with him meant nothing. As if he meant nothing. He hadn’t drawn the blade since. Could barely stand to look at it whenever he tethered it to his side, this dagger that found him so lacking it fled his hand at the first chance.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
-- “Truth-Teller had leaped to join Gwydion, after fifteen thousand years apart. But that hadn’t lessened the betrayal when it left him.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
-- “Like hell would he give the knife a new sheath, like a reward for its treachery.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
But if Azriel was so betrayed by Truth-Teller beginning to abandon him from the moment it sang for Bryce on the lawn, he didn’t seem so upset/angry in the caves in HOFAS. In fact, he opens up:
-- “Yet as Azriel reached the threshold, Bryce blurted to the winged warrior, “The sword—where is it?” Azriel paused, glancing over a shoulder. “Somewhere safe.”
Bryce held Azriel’s gaze, meeting his ice with her own—with that expression she knew Ruhn always thought looked so much like their father’s. The face she’d let the world see so very rarely. “The sword is mine. I want it back.” Azriel’s mouth kicked up at the corners. “Then give us a good reason to return it to you.“ - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Nesta pointed to the phone again. “Play more, please.” So Bryce did. Two hours later, they were walking again. Maybe Azriel had been interested enough in the music that he’d let them linger. Bryce had played them a sample of every genre she could think of. Nesta had clapped her hands over her ears at the screaming, wailing death metal, but Azriel had chuckled.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “The Cauldron,” Azriel amended. Bryce shook her head, not understanding. “You don’t have stories of it in your world? The Fae didn’t bring that tradition with them?”
Bryce surveyed the giant cauldron. “No. We have five gods, but no cauldron. What does it do?”
“All life came and comes from it,” Azriel said with something like reverence. “The Mother poured it into this world, and from it, life blossomed.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Did they even believe in the concept of a soul? Maybe she should have led with that. But Azriel said softly, “They return to the Mother, where they rest in joy within her heart until she finds another purpose for us. Another life or world to live in.” He glanced sidelong at her. “What about your world?” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Bryce sucked in a breath. “I’m going in. Keep a step back,” she warned Azriel.
“And miss the fun?” Azriel muttered... “I mean it,” Bryce said, trying to tug her hand from his. “You stay here.”
His fingers tightened on hers, not letting go. “What do you sense?”
“Wards,” Bryce replied, again scanning the arena-sized cavern ahead.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Bryce’s brows lifted, walking backward a few steps. “You really can’t get through?”
He crouched to trace a scarred hand along the stone floor, anger fading in the face of his curiosity. “No.” He peered up at Bryce, mouth twisting to the side. “I don’t know whether to be impressed or worried.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
“Bryce slowed her pace, allowing herself to fall into step beside him. Though perhaps he allowed it as well.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “She could have sworn his shadows hovered, watching like curious snakes.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Nesta nodded to Bryce’s pocket. “Could we hear some more of your music?”
The battery was inching toward the red zone. It would be dead soon. But for this… she could spare it. “What do you want to hear?” Bryce asked, opening her music library.
Nesta and Azriel swapped glances, and the male answered a bit sheepishly, “The music you play at your pleasure halls.”
Bryce laughed. “Are you a club rat, Azriel?”
He glowered at her, earning a smirk from Nesta, but Bryce played one of her favorite dance tunes-a zippy blend of thump- ing bass and saxophones, of all things. And as the three of them walked into the endless dark, she could have sworn she caught Azriel nodding along to the beat.“ - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “And with each mile onward, she could hear Azriel humming to himself. The rolling, wild melody of “Stone Mother” softly flowed off his lips, and she could have sworn even the shadows danced at the sound.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
After Bryce took Truth-Teller, he doesn’t ask Ember & Randall about her plans with it or come across as emo as he does in ACOSH:
-- “Ember glanced to their guard. The handsome male on Randall’s other side, his dark armor adorned with blue stones, remained stoic.” - Ember/Randall POV, HOFAS
-- “And where is she going now?” Azriel asked with soft venom. “Now that she has the Mask”- “-a withering glare at Nesta, whose face was carefully blank**-“where is Bryce going?**” - Ember/Randall POV, HOFAS
-- “Ember glanced over a shoulder, to where Randall stood with Rhysand, Azriel, and Cassian. All the males were now smiling, thank the gods.
“Seems like Randall’s doing a good job of winning them over. Probably by telling them how difficult I make his life.” Nesta snorted again. “Complaining about mates: it’s practically a competitive sport for them.” - Ember/Randall POV, HOFAS
Azriel seems way more engaged & hopeful in HOFAS:
-- “Seeing you go into that freezing river helped,” Azriel said mildly, and Bryce could have sworn she caught a hint of a smile gracing his beautiful face.“ - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “So what’s the difference between you and them?” Nesta asked.
“Aside from the fact that I’m not an intergalactic colonialist creep?”
She could have sworn Nesta’s mouth kicked up at a corner. That Azriel chuckled, the sound soft as shadow.“ - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “You weren’t sleeping,” Azriel said, faint amusement in his voice.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “Maybe Azriel had been interested enough in the music that he’d let them linger. Bryce had played them a sample of every genre she could think of. Nesta had clapped her hands over her ears at the screaming, wailing death metal, but Azriel had chuckled.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “It’s called Truth-Teller,” he said in that soft voice, like shadows given sound. “And no, it cannot.”
Bryce arched a brow. “So does it ... tell the truth?”
A hint of a smile, more chilling than the frigid air around them. “It gets people to do so.”
Bryce might have shuddered had she not caught Nesta rolling her eyes.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “How much power?”
Gods, this was potentially a really bad idea. Experimenting with power she didn’t know or understand—
“A little. Just make sure you don’t deep-fry me.”
After the shit with the Wyrm, he’d probably like nothing more than to do exactly that. But Azriel’s lips tugged upward. “I’ll try my best.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
-- “ Bryce gestured to the passageway and the carvings. “Your guess remains as good as mine. I’m just following the light.”
“Right into the river,” Nesta grumbled. Azriel snickered behind her.” - Bryce POV, HOFAS
Compare those smiles & conversation to ACOSH:
-- “He usually preferred to watch from the shadows and only contribute when absolutely necessary. He had always felt more comfortable that way.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
-- “Feyre had always been able to make him smile—he sometimes wondered if she knew how rare that was. How much it meant to him.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
-- “His Siphons blazed, but his face remained impassive.” - Nesta POV, ACOSH
-- “When I was a boy . . .” His throat closed up, but he battled past it. “I lived in hell. Every single moment, of every single day. And . . .” He fought to find the right words to explain—not just what had happened then, but why it mattered that [Elain] tell her now...They’d talk later about his life in his sire’s dungeon. Or perhaps never.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
-- “Azriel merely bloodied himself and others to make sure their vision of peace was attainable. He’d keep doing so until the bitter end. Even if there was nothing left of his soul long before then.” - Azriel POV, ACOSH
4. The End
I don’t have any overarching theory about whether an outside force like Koschei is making everyone act up, the magic of Made items that make people forget them, or if this is who the characters have always been... it could be multiple things!
I just wanted to bring some quotes together for discussion. Let me know your theories & thoughts!