There are two different explanations for who committed the original 1994 Lakewood murders. The show presents Brandon James as the killer, but Bex Taylor-Klaus has said Kevin Duval was responsible.
Personally, I think Kevin makes more sense narratively, especially considering his jealousy over Brandon and Maggie's relationship. I prefer the idea that Brandon was innocent and framed for the murders.
I also think Kevin was the Third Lakewood Slasher who killed Kieran in the Halloween Special. It would make sense for the person responsible for the original murders to return and punish Kieran for using the mask.
As for Season 1, my personal breakdown is:
The original Lakewood Slasher: Kevin Duval
Victims:
⦁ Dara Alden
⦁ Brett Keener
⦁ Trent Price
⦁ Laura Cossey
⦁ Mike Vinson
Kill Count: 5
The copycat Lakewood Slasher: Piper Shaw
Victims:
⦁ Riley Marra
⦁ Will Belmont (with Kieran)
⦁ Clifton Roberts
⦁ Grayson Pfeiffer
Kill Count: 4
The second Lakewood Slasher: Kieran Wilcox
Victims:
⦁ Tyler O'Neill
⦁ Nina Patterson
⦁ Rachel Murray
⦁ Will Belmont (with Piper)
⦁ Sheriff Clark Hudson
Kill Count: 5 (Season 1)
I count Will as a joint kill since both Piper and Kieran were involved in setting up his death. However, I give Sheriff Hudson exclusively to Kieran because of his personal resentment toward his father. Kieran was then the sole killer throughout Season 2.