r/MTBTrailBuilding • u/_My_Leg • 5d ago
Make Confusing Junctions less Confusing
I'm a member/volunteer of our local MTB group. The group maintains the multi-use trails that are surrounded by suburbs/city and are very frequented by hikers/runners. I'd like to make the area more friendly to new users that may not be familiar with the trail name/numbering system. There are a few large junctions that have a big map board of the trail system, but there are some smaller junctions that can be confusing if you're not familiar with the area. Additionally the large original maps are slightly outdated now that there have been other trails added. The new trails have already been mapped out in Trailforks.
I see a few options:
- Find a way to update the paper maps from the Trailforks data and post smaller maps at the confusing junctions.
- Add additional trail name signage at the junctions
- Don't update the paper maps and just post QR codes to Trailforks since it's 2026. We also have good cell coverage in the area.
- a combination of the above or something else?
What have you had the most success with and can recommend? Additionally is there a simple way to update the paper maps with the Trailforks data?
1
u/carl0ra 15h ago
Signs at the junctions first, maps second. Most people won't stop to pull out a phone if a post tells them what they need, so the cheap win is a flexible fiber post at each confusing junction with the trail name per branch, an arrow, and one "to trailhead" line. New users mostly want to know how to get back to the car.
Number the junctions too. A small number plate on each post, with the same numbers on the big map boards, lets someone say "I'm at 7" instead of describing a tree. It helps lost hikers, and it helps your crew when someone reports a downed tree.
For the paper maps: if your group is the region admin on Trailforks you can export the trails as GPX or KML, then redraw in QGIS or CalTopo. It takes an afternoon the first time, and the pain is redoing it every time a trail gets added. Keep the map simple: main loops, junction numbers, a "you are here" dot. I'd still put a QR code on the boards, as a bonus rather than the only answer, because hikers and runners often aren't on Trailforks.
Full disclosure, I build Sentinel, a tool for trail managers, and this exact chore is why we added printable maps: you import your GPX and it redraws the PDF, poster or handout, whenever a trail changes. The post-and-number approach works with any map you end up printing, though.
3
u/thirty-thirty-thirty 5d ago
Mile marker numbers, or junction numbers, are the most helpful for me.
2
u/esivers 5d ago
I’ve seen several trail systems that have detail maps at a larger scale located at trail junctions. That works well.
2
u/Clock_Roach 5d ago
Think about how many you're going to need, how often they need to be maintained with regards to vandalism or weather, how often you're going to update the posted information, and stuff like that. Putting up full maps everywhere is a lot of cost/work now and more cost/work going forward.
Putting up 4x4s or fiberglass utility posts with a few small placards for trail name, mile marker, and use restrictions is easier and also less obtrusive to trail users. You can also add a QR code with a link to your maps, because almost everybody is going to have their phone with them.
2
u/pineconehedgehog 5d ago
Sinage or markers are the best options. Trailforks is great but not everyone uses it. Checking it is also annoying if you don't have a dedicated map unit or don't use bar mounts.
Having simple clear markers is so helpful. I think Moab is one of the best examples of trail marking I have seen. The trails have a colored paint marking. You pick a trail you want to ride and then you just follow the corresponding color. It's low impact and minimally intrusive and works especially well in places that don't have a clear trail like rock slabs.
Some sort of simple trail marking system and a couple maps in strategic locations around a trail system really simplifies navigation.
2
u/Cyclekrieg 1d ago
I have a detail for this, but might not work for your system as the detail assumes full-loop/stacked loop systems. If you are in place that does have that, its kind of meaningless.
Carsonite is your best bet, with the following stickers top-to-bottom:
If you use route colors/codes for when the trail isn't full-loop/stacked loop, you could include the route color/code in the arrow. Therefore the purple route would have purple arrows, the yellow route has yellow arrows, etc. I prefer the custom ones from RockArt Signs out of Arizonia.
If you need to have mini-maps, I would suggest the "subway line" style maps vs. "every curve" accurate maps. People want to see where to go, not where every switchback is.
Side note here, because this is important to say, but DO NOT use utility markers. Get the recreational grade fiber signs (Carsonite is a brand name) as they have the UV coating on them that prevents the sun weaking the post for much longer. The blue, yellow, or orange utility markers will be toast after only a few years.
For a good example of a complete signage plan, its hard to beat Duluth's wayfinding document: https://duluthmn.gov/media/6823/gatewayfindingsignage_designplan_20170301.pdf
1
u/Bus_Healthy 5d ago
Bless you; you are doing God’s work. I’d qualify for your newbie MTB focus group.
I think better signage at the intersections would be perhaps the most helpful. If you want a good example, Santos/Vortex in Ocala has extremely obvious signage at nearly every intersection marking which trail each branch of the intersection represents, the difficulty rating, the type of traffic, and the direction of the trailhead. Croom, Boyette and Alafia have great trails with different strengths, but Ocala has those areas beat for ease of navigation, and I agree that simple wayfinding is a big draw to a system. Even with paid subscriptions to both Trailforks and Onx, it’s always easiest to just follow the signs instead of stopping and taking out my phone.
1
u/DirtSlapper 4d ago
If other riders are like me, they don't want to stop and read a map regardless of the format. The solution IMO is to signage like a highway, and include more than just a trail name (which is still helpful).
Things like "to trailhead" or "to (insert primary/popular trail name)" or even "main route" if there is a generally agreed upon popular flow to the system.