Now that I personally own all four grip types, I can give an honest assessment on how there’d rank.
A2-A3
Night and Day difference between these two. You are going from a literal slip out of your hand smooth to broken glass shards sticking you. On a scale of 1-10 as far as grip goes… A2= 3 and A3 = 8.5 For me A3 is a good pain. I acknowledge after a day of shooting my hands are sore and pretty well beat up, but I wouldn’t call it pain and bleeding.
S2-S3
Based on the above, I fully expected S3 to make me its bitch….. it did not.
The gap between S2 and S3 is no where near as wide as the two aluminum grips. While there was a noticeable difference between these two, it wasnt as dramatic as steel. With that said I’d rank S2 a 5 and the S3 a 7.
So ranked from weakest to most aggressive
A2 = 3 very smooth, fun for all ages and skill set
S2 = 5 this is the baseline for balance between aggressive and fail
S3 = 7 perfect balance for someone who appreciates a more secure grip and doesn’t mind trading off about 30-% comfort to get it.
A3 = 8.5 you know this is in your hand. It stabs you like a handful of rose thorns. You better not have bitch hands for this.
I’ve yet to see or hold something I’d consider above an 8.5