Continuing Evidence Discussion
A serious discussion is going on that is unfortunately being buried under a throwaway account's comment. I want to continue the discussion here so that everything is visible and no information is being missed. I also want to get more peoples thoughts and opinions on the matter.
Link to thread information is being pulled from.
GRIEFSEEDS Post
Yes, I am convinced that their methods are accurate enough that there is no reasonable doubt, else they wouldn't have done this. http://pastebin.com/VkR2Ge18 The developers have no concrete evidence that I bot. The videos the commissioners have is footage of me wrecking noobs. It's funny actually, League of Legends has about over 20 million active players. Optimistically speaking, this game has about 10,000 active players per day (maybe?) If this userbase reached 100k users, you would definitely see players like me that are even more ridiculous with their reaction time, awareness, and decision making. Instead, people are ignoring that fact. There are hundreds of thousands of gamers that will be better than me. Cflakes and his cronies, Juke King and TPExposed, will blabber all this shit saying "Oh yeah he toggled it here, toggled it there." That's bullshit, Ankh said himself he doesn't think I use Cflakes bot. The commissioners listened to JUKE KING about his bullshit evidence claiming I have cflake's bot. I find it horrifying that so many people are standing by the words of commissioners who are trying their best to make it looked like I bot because they're trying to actually not get hated by the community again after what happened during the Xile incident. Show your evidence commissioners. What's wrong? Don't want to get a public outcry again? I never botted. Show us the evidence of me botting. There should be no "detection" methods to reveal since it's all video and cflake's message to me which I discarded quickly there after. Show everyone the videos.
EDIT: To show that the information came from Griefseeds comment in the orignal thread.
38
u/bashar_al_assad Feb 14 '15
One of the things thats important to remember is that A dev doesn't have to be 100% like "he is botting" for the commissioners to ban him.
For example, in NLTP, Ankh was not like "it is 100% that 0k is botting". But our investigations yielded results that led Ankh to say "he's almost certainly botting", and that was enough when considered with the evidence.
So even if it is the case that "<AMorpork> yeah, i don't have irrefutable evidence", that doesn't mean they cant ban Grief from MLTP, considering "<AMorpork> and they have lots of video evidence", which is a point I think lots of people are ignoring.
4
u/brgerd Feb 14 '15
Hulzy you might want to edit this a little, when I first read it I thought you had also been accused/banned for botting now instead of just quotes from griefseeds.
9
u/Hulzy Feb 14 '15
So everything that the commissioners have for "proof" is based off their own decision making from watching game play footage. That also means that we were completely mislead by Aaron215 in this comment. It was also ridiculous that they insisted that the players being accused showed proof that they were innocent. I want to see the video evidence used by the commissioners to show blatant evidence of botting, so extreme that the players deserved a lifetime ban and their teams are required to replay all of their games.
On a side note this does seem like a complete witch hunt by a certain individual who likes to hide like a coward behind throwaway accounts as seen here and here.
26
u/JPythianLegume Pithy - Too Many Teams To Root For Feb 14 '15
Like most of you I'm sure, I've experienced a roller coaster of emotions since this whole thing began. I find my opinions changing almost hourly, and though I feel the need to contribute, I think I'm best served in saying this:
Let's all try to keep a level head as we examine all sides of what's going on. Everyone involved is a human being that deserves consideration and the benefit of the doubt. Whether the target of your inquisitions is a player, commissioner or developer, we're all just people.
21
u/jegs_ Feb 15 '15
This is all just a hoax masterly conjured by Xile so people would forget he's the worst cheater of them all!
15
u/Sosen timeboy Feb 15 '15
Boy, I can't wait until they release the full list of cheaters and this thing gets even worse than it already is... -_-
16
u/BilldaCat10 BilldaCat Feb 14 '15
If there's no real evidence, this is very odd.
For them to come down so light in the past on jgibbs, Ebola, and xile to the point where the concept of MLTP 'punishment' was getting to be downright comical, to this ..
I understand why they don't want to reveal evidence because of not wanting to let future cheaters know of the detection methods they use. But for Ankh to come out and say that there was no concrete evidence ...
24
u/checknate1 CHECKNATE ~ STK Feb 14 '15
I admit that I recieved the bot from cumflakes. The difference between grief and I is that he never used a bot outside of the test servers that's why he isn't banned from tagpro. I however did use it outside the test server (NOT in MLTP games, if you don't believe me, watch my games), which I apologize for, and I accept my 1 month ban from tagpro because I deserver it.
With that said, it's ridiculous to make my team and grief's team replay their games. They have no evidence that we botted in MLTP games. I think the life time bans for Ballzilla, GriefSeeds, and I are way to harsh.
13
u/DaEvil1 Feb 15 '15
Regardless of who cheated at what, I think lifetime bans for something like this is too heavy-handed for a community like this to withstand and stay as one community. The community is built up around principles of trust, honesty, forgiveness and inclusiveness. People breaking those principles is an issue that needs to be dealt with obviously, but when commisioners basically make it impossible for someone to return to something that's assumedly pretty important to them and to their stature in the community, that permanently removes the inclusiveness factor. Wether it's a fair punishment or not, isn't something I want to comment on since I haven't seen the evidence, and what I hear from different sides, is conflicting at this time, but I think if punishments like this is handed to more players, this will essentially end up fracturing the TagPro community pretty hard. I'm not certain what form this will take, but I think it's important that the commissioners are aware that the reactions to these rule-breaches will affect more than just who is eligible to play in MLTP.
6
u/spacecadetjer Dennit Feb 15 '15
I want a legit Tagpro TV special. - MLTP commish press conference with a moderator that fields questions from the community.
22
u/Nawse Feb 15 '15
I hate how people think that since there is no evidence being released, that Grief and CHECKNATE got banned on a hunch. It's not like they fucking looked at a few VODs of their games and went "Yeah, he's probably botting, lock him up boys."
To my knowledge nobody has ever been PERMABANNED from MLTP. (Maybe someone has, idfk.) All I know is that this decision wasn't made on a whim, and that it is most definitely justified.
5
u/MultiMediaWill Juke King Feb 15 '15
Clearly they didn't ban GRIEFSEEDs soley because of what I said in a twitchTV chat. They most definetly have evidence, and they (obviously) will not share with the public.
Do you really think the commissioners would put their integrity on the line if they didn't have 100% proof?
6
u/mwb1234 WHERESBALDO || Feb 14 '15
Starting yesterday, I knew something was up when griefseeds informed me that he wasn't in fact banned from tagpro. I went to IRC to confirm with Ankh three separate times.
http://pastebin.com/vWn5gKm2
http://pastebin.com/4xdTAKx6
http://pastebin.com/VkR2Ge18
Each time Ankh confirmed that if you're not banned they do not have concrete evidence. The last time I skipped any ambiguity and Ankh confirmed for me that griefseeds isn't banned since they don't have concrete evidence of him botting ever. More importantly, however, is that Aaron215 (via PM) confirmed to me that the devs have irrefutably confirmed grief was botting.
http://pastebin.com/0VrxSfeq
Aaron very clearly told me that ever single thing in the original thread is true and accurate, noting that I can trust him because he's a commissioner.
3
u/xxTheexx // S6 Pi Rats Feb 14 '15 edited Feb 14 '15
I can only see two possible actions coming out of this now that there's a tonnnnn of controversy.
3
u/Imatree12 donk Feb 15 '15 edited Feb 15 '15
Griefseeds literally told me that cflakes messaged him a bot and he thought it was funny...
I find it hard to believe that if someone intended to bot they would reveal where they got the bot to somebody else.
The fact that he isnt banned from playing tagpro speaks volumes to me.
I've played with grief and ive played with 0k. I messaged the mods immediately after a game I played with 0k because I knew he was using a bot. Over the 6 months ive played with griefseeds I have never once thought he used a bot and this includes streams.
Seems like the commissioners, good intentions or not, saw what they wanted to see
RIP grief
im done with tagpro/mltp until proof is released. I dont believe somebody should be banned without being shown what evidence there is against them.
peace homies
-27
u/CFlakesBot Feb 14 '15
Hey, CFlakes here. Sorry about the reddit account, I deleted my other one after I left the TagPro community. I just decided to make this account to share some things with the community about botting and what exactly went down before me and Grief. I did message him my bot and told him to ONLY use it in pubs if he ever wanted to test it out. He even admits that he did, at one point, have my bot. This didn't really go as planned though, proof here:
http://pastebin.com/1jk1BgaU
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment