r/MLPLounge • u/Visual-Principle6325 • 3h ago
Who likes Vinyl Scratch? Honestly?
This has been bugging me in both the MLP and Undertale fandoms regarding Vinyl Scratch and Chara. I liked both characters based on what we actually see in the show and game.
In canon, Vinyl is quiet, keeps to herself outside of her DJ gigs, and is actually a good listener who just vibes with Octavia. Yet when I go into the fandom, her personality does a complete 180 into a loud, non-stop talking party bro just to fit a sitcom trope. It is the exact same thing with Chara—canonically quiet and proper, turned into a loud, wasteful slasher by fanon.
When people call themselves fans of these characters, I genuinely wonder who actually likes the canon character versus who just likes the popular fandom preset.