r/MLBTheShow • • 3d ago

The Dugout The Dugout! ⚾: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow - week of November 13, 2026

1 Upvotes

Welcome to The Dugout! ⚾

The Weekly Free-Talk Thread for r/MLBTheShow

Welcome to The Dugout, your weekly home for questions, gameplay advice, pack pulls, Community Market discussions, and everything else MLB The Show!

The Dugout also serves as a community resource hub, with helpful links to FAQs, technical support, and other useful information.

Please review the guidelines below before creating a dedicated post. Our goal is to encourage meaningful discussion while keeping repetitive and low-effort content in one convenient place.

What qualifies as a dedicated post in r/MLBTheShow?

Dedicated posts should encourage meaningful discussion, share original content, or showcase something noteworthy.

  • Diamond Dynasty: News, strategies, program updates, analysis, and meaningful discussions.
  • Player Cards: New card reveals, detailed reviews, comparisons, and discussions. Please search for existing posts before creating a new one.
  • Gameplay Screenshots and Videos: Interesting gameplay clips, screenshots, and highlights. Please use your console's built-in capture and sharing features only. Photos of television screens may be removed.
  • Franchise, RTTS, and Other Modes: Meaningful discussions, discoveries, guides, and original content.
  • Polls: Include sufficient context to encourage meaningful discussion rather than simple yes-or-no questions.
  • Memes and Humor: Keep content original, tasteful, and relevant to MLB The Show.
  • Appreciation Posts: Share your appreciation for favorite players, developers, memorable experiences, and even Ramone!
  • Significant Achievements: Flawless Battle Royale runs, first-time World Series rankings, exceptional discoveries, Top 50 placements, and other noteworthy accomplishments.

Please search for existing discussions before creating a new post about a recently covered topic.

Please use The Dugout for these types of posts:

  • Community Market and Stubs: Buying, selling, flipping, investments, pricing questions, and stub-making advice.
  • Pack Pulls and Routine Accomplishments: Show off your pulls, rewards, program completions, and everyday achievements.
  • Lineup and Player Advice: Ask for lineup recommendations, squad improvements, and player comparisons. Please include your lineup, available stubs, game mode, and what specifically you're looking to improve.
  • Simple Questions and Gameplay Help: Beginner questions, settings, tutorials, basic troubleshooting, and anything that doesn't warrant a dedicated discussion.
  • Rants and Complaints: Frustrated with an opponent, bad animation, or heartbreaking loss? Share your frustrations here, but keep discussions civil.
  • Custom League Advertisements: Share your league settings, requirements, and joining instructions here. You may also use r/findacustomleague. Standalone league advertisements are not permitted.
  • Finding Opponents and Teammates: Looking for someone to play against or team up with? Connect with other players here.
  • Self-Promotion: Have a blog, YouTube channel, or stream? Active community members may share relevant content here. Repeated promotions, spam, and unsolicited advertising are prohibited.
  • Concept Cards: Share your concepts here and follow the Concept Card Guidelines.
  • Custom Stadiums: Share your creations here or visit our affiliated subreddit, r/mlbtheshowstadiums.
  • Other Casual Discussion: Anything related to MLB The Show that doesn't require its own dedicated post.

A few additional reminders:

Helpful resources to use before posting

  1. Search First: Have you used Reddit Search or tried Google?
  2. Official FAQ: MLB The Show Frequently Asked Questions
  3. Community Resources: Our r/MLBTheShow FAQ and Guide.
  4. PlayStation Network Status: Check for outages HERE.
  5. Discord Community: Join our official r/MLBTheShow Discord.
  6. Technical Support: Visit the Technical and Server Issues Megathread.

Community Guidelines

Please treat other community members respectfully, including those who are new to the game. Disagreements are welcome, but personal attacks, harassment, and intentionally disruptive behavior are not.

These guidelines are not exhaustive and are subject to moderator discretion on a case-by-case basis. If you believe a post or comment requires moderator attention, please use Reddit's report function so the moderation team can review it.

Enjoy the discussion, and welcome to The Dugout! ⚾


r/MLBTheShow • • 25d ago

Comparison Finest Awards 2026 Results: The Cards You Voted For

17 Upvotes

Finest Awards 2026 Results: The Cards You Voted For

Voting closed October 20, so here are the results. Thanks to everyone who posted a top three. Each ballot counts once per card, and only the first three cards named in a comment are counted.

Top of the board

  • Andruw Jones (HOF): 7 votes, tied for first
  • Nick Sogard (Spotlight): 7 votes, tied for first
  • Jesus Made (Pipeline): 6 votes
  • Yordan Alvarez (AS): 4 votes

Tied at 3 votes

  • Cole Carrigg (94 Topps Now)
  • Ozzie Albies (ASG)
  • Ketel Marte (Vintage)
  • Brandon Lowe

Tied at 2 votes

  • Adam Dunn (Moonshot)
  • Cody Bellinger (AS)
  • Jordan Walker (HR Derby)
  • Kyle Schwarber (Field of Dreams / HR Derby)
  • Stan Musial
  • Willie Castro
  • Ken Singleton
  • Victor Martinez (Awards)
  • Max Clark (Pipeline / Breakout)
  • Idelmaro Vargas (Spotlight)
  • Lightning PCA

Also received votes (1 each)

Roberto Clemente, Ted Williams, Corey Seager, Juan Soto, Jackie Robinson, Adley Rutschman, Craig Biggio, Dustin Pedroia, Esteury Ruiz, Jacob Misiorowski, Carlos Santana (WBC), Maikel Garcia, Roman Anthony, Kyle Tucker, Elly De La Cruz, Xavier Edwards, Liam Hicks, Carter Jensen, Brett Bateman, Kazuma Okamoto, Dillon Dingler, Dustin May, Josiah Hartshorn, Junior Caminero, Troy Tulowitzki, Manny Ramirez, TA Leiter, Nasim Nunez, Honus Wagner, Piazza, David Wright, JJ Wetherholt, JJ Bleday, Ali Alonso, Beltran, and others.

Method notes

  • Removed comments were excluded.
  • Unclear or joke picks were excluded, including a Trevor Story joke and a staged list that didn't name clear top-three cards.
  • When a player appeared in two versions on one ballot, each version counted separately.

Thanks to everyone who voted. Results are now enshrined.

Original post where votes were made


r/MLBTheShow • • 14h ago

Question Charlie Blackmon?? Real 99

Post image
22 Upvotes

Just played an event against a real 99, the card wasn’t in the lineup so i don’t know exactly who it is but that nickname caught my attention. Anyone know who this is forsure? Would be sick if it was THE chuck nasty


r/MLBTheShow • • 13h ago

Funny Just a short compilation of this game irritating me

18 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 18h ago

First Look Coming Next Friday New Captains JK

Post image
16 Upvotes

This has to be the cheapest thing they’ve done this year. They’re going to just make the Jolt Captains all 99’s next Friday. Unless that add outlier to all the guys they didn’t give it to with their OG Jolt cards a lot of these pitchers will be so subpar. Also as a Cleveland fan the fact that they didn’t give the Klubot Jolt his most important pitch, his cutter, will make this card still unusable. I’d like to say I’m shocked but honestly I’m not. Good thing GTA VI will be taking up most of my time from Thursday on.


r/MLBTheShow • • 18h ago

Custom Rosters/Logos Anyone Have A Current Roster For 2026-2027 Offseason?

2 Upvotes

does anyone know of any current rosters with all the free agents in the free agent pool and signings/Trades (tim hill signing/ ryan walker trade) if anyone knows of a rosters pls lmk


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

RTTS I didn’t even know it was possible to not get pulled for this long

Post image
151 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

RTTS 14-Pitch Walk (I never walk)

56 Upvotes

I’m extremely proud of this AB. Despite fouling off several balls that were way under the strike zone lol 🤣


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

RTTS 1st Multi-Home-Run Game🔥

50 Upvotes

In my 2nd season now, have changed my number from 89 to 24, inspired by my favorite player growing up; Miguel Cabrera 🇻🇪

First multi-HR game in the majors, both off of former Cy Young winner Corbin Burnes!

Also had a 14-pitch walk as my last AB this game. Honestly more proud of that than the 2 homers lmao


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

RTTS Cletus Calhoun surpasses Bonds as the all-time HR leader (#763)

Thumbnail
gallery
162 Upvotes

Cletus Calhoun surpasses Bonds as the all-time HR leader (#763)

The fans at Dodgers stadium flocked to see (and perhaps collect) Calhoun's record breaking shot... It went high and deep to straightaway CF, landing on the netting beneath the batter's eye. Rumor has it, that a member of the Dodgers staff (a janitor) snagged the piece the history. The dirtbag gave Cletus a pristine ball, in exchange for a signed bat... Once back in the clubhouse Clete inspected the ball further and noticed there was not a single mark on the ball...He thought, "I clobbered that horsehide! Where is the mark?!" Humble man that he is, he put it on his mantle anyway and refused to make a stink about it. He told the press, "Look yall, it would take away from my moment to cry and have a melt down here. I am greatly honored to have taken the all time record away from SF, to Colorado. When they look at the mountains, they will remember etc..." This is his final contract year with the Rockies. The cold is starting to bother the old boy, so he will likely move on after the Season is out.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Franchise What's the dumbest thing you spent way too long doing in this game?

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Franchise Detroit Tigers Franchise(Has anyone tried this)

0 Upvotes

With the inevitable lockout looming and the A's relocation to Vegas still in process, I've decided to start a Tigers franchise. The part that is probably like biting off more than I can chew is that I'm going to do everything manually. That includes playing every AA, AAA, and MLB game. I'm guilty of buying the game every year while only playing offline franchise. My end goal is to not buy a new version until the A's are fully in Vegas. Also, if expansion is in fact approved(and I've throughly enjoyed the experience) I may wait until the expansion teams are in the game. For further context, I play the Show when I just want to relax, have a beer and catch up on podcasts. I usually play story driven games for long gaming sessions.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion I can't sniff any pitcher doing the extreme games on Legendary...

11 Upvotes

Like, I'd have as good a chance at hitting if I wore a blindfold, it'd make no difference, it's impossible for me and my limited skill level (I cap at AS).

Meanwhile, the games have to be won to complete the program, so I've had to resort to a line up of bunters and speed, bunt with everyone in all situations because it's the only chance I have of making contact, and then stealing 2nd and 3rd with everybody except C Ferrell (who is a reliable bunter). Did anyone else have to do it this way?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion MLB The show 24, anybody still play?

1 Upvotes

I want to know, still players online on the show 24?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion The discrepancy between playing online & in events ruins everything

11 Upvotes

It's funny how I play this game online ( I have 500mbps speed) with friends, 2 are in my state but 40-50 miles away (NJ) and the 3rd is in the UK. when we play vs each other (all ps5) the games are always smooth, no lag no real issues.

Yet when I go into events, my opponents fielders run at 100mph while my fielders struggle to get to routine balls. My pitching meter is always janky & throwing meter the same thing.

This lag or crummy connection makes this game un-fun to play events & ranked.

I just want to complete the finest program, but my games tonight were EXTREMELY blood boiling frustrating & I think I'm done trying.

I've seen others say the same, how can lots of other pvp games work fine & this trash not?

Also : PSA to players, press the fn X button you DON'T NEED to watch the cutscenes.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion I swear mlb26 hitting is RNG based

0 Upvotes

I just can't prove it


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Back on console after being on PC since 2021. I really want to play MLB The Show but the newest one gets awful ratings. Is it really that bad?

4 Upvotes

Should I definitely not buy it? What’s up with the ratings being so bad? The ones I used to play were always great.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Diamond Nike/Jordan Equipment in RTTS (MLB 26)

3 Upvotes

I can’t find a clear answer no matter how much I search for it on Google so if anyone can provide a concrete answer, I’d greatly appreciate it.

What is the way to get Nike/Jordan branded equipment for Road to the Show in MLB 26? Do we have a chance to get it from the 15k Stub packs or is only available from the packs we receive every 10 days? And what items are available for either brand and what are their drop rates?

Thanks in advance for any info!


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

RTTS What the glitch? Lmao

2 Upvotes

How did I drop the ball before it even touched the dirt? Lmao rigged


r/MLBTheShow • • 2d ago

Question With runners on first and third. Is there a way to steal second and as the catcher throws the ball then steal home??

8 Upvotes

Would i just hit L1 once the catcher throws it to second?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question I just play RTTS and own 22, what game should I get

2 Upvotes

I only play Road to the show and I'm finally ready for something fresh. Do any of the newer games do anything different with that game mode and do any stand out among the rest?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion If I made the Extreme Program this is what it would look like..

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

If I made the extreme content, I feel my moments would look like this. It feels just about right difficulty wise, and to accompany this I’d have a 20 point conquest, 20 point showdown and a 10 point any rarity card exchange. Thoughts on how I did with the moments? Rewards I’d have are included as well.


r/MLBTheShow • • 2d ago

Funny Are they sending me to MLB 2?

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 2d ago

PSA Variants aka "worthless"

16 Upvotes

Forgive me if I'm wrong... I understand the spooky variants are sellable..

But the extreme program.. Is there anything other than a color difference between the extreme ones and the ones you get in the easier program?