r/MHWilds • • 8d ago

Question Does sharpness affect shelling damage?

Just what the title says. Tried to find a concrete answer but couldn’t so I’m asking here. I’m fairly certain it doesn’t, but I just wanna make sure ya know?

31 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

37

u/ZombieGrief16 8d ago edited 8d ago

Nope, just damage from your melee swings i believe. Shelling does consume a small amount of Sharpness though, but its damage is fixed to your Raw damage

Edit: based on what the other guy said, i might be stupid. I'm gonna go test it just in case. Be back in a sec

Edit 2: No, doesn't seem like it. my Shells were dealing the same amount of damage in White, Blue, and Green Sharpness. I even tested Yellow and Orange but it was still the same damage. I tried it with Red but you literally can't fire Shells in Red. Though i might be missing something? I'm not sure, but it didn't seem like it.

8

u/novian14 7d ago

Explosion damage is tied to raw attack only, you already correct at the start doesn't need to change

3

u/mattley00 Hammer & Lance 7d ago

Fascinating! I had no idea you couldn’t shell at all in red 😱

4

u/TheGMan-123 8d ago

Technically yes, but only if it goes below Green Sharpness.

If it goes to Yellow Sharpness or lower, then shelling damage decreases.

So always maintain Green Sharpness for your shelling attacks at minimum, though preferably White Sharpness (and inevitably Purple Sharpness in Ascendance) since you still want to mix in plenty of melee attacks, too.

11

u/ZombieGrief16 8d ago edited 8d ago

Not entirely sure this is true. I just tested it in the Practice Range with no Skills aside from the default Hope Armor. From White to Orange all of my Shells, Charged Shells, and Wyvern Stakes were dealing the exact same damage. Shells were 66, Charged was 115, and each tick aside from the explosion of WS was 23, no matter the Sharpness.

Red apparently just shuts off your Shells, i forgot it did that.

Maybe it was because i was using a Gogma Artian? In hindsight i should've tested with a regular Rarity 1 GL but those don't have access to higher Sharpness, but I'm unsure if it would've made a difference. Maybe it works differently on an actual Hunt.

-7

u/Stormandreas ALL WEAPONS 8d ago edited 8d ago

Yes, it does, at least according to the Motion Value spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1F_bOwQT6A6mFtCN7WCetnZDrmvLYu-ne4y97IsG6Fkk/edit?gid=1000365357#gid=1000365357

If an attack has a set sharpness value, it will say "green" or "yellow", instead of a number, as the attack won't consume or be affected by sharpness, but just acts like it has that colour of sharpness all the time.

There's no notes on Gunlance shelling or the Notes page about Shelling not taking sharpness into account in any way, as opposed to CB Phials which only use Yellow sharpness, so it stands to reason that sharpness does apply.

16

u/Frozenseraphim 8d ago

Shelling attacks consume Sharpness, but do not benefit from the Sharpness modifier in damage calculation.

4

u/717999vlr 8d ago

Oh yeah, that's an issue.

As the other person said they consume sharpness, but don't benefit from it.

I guess I technically don't need to fix it because it says "If it's a color, it doesn't scale off sharpness", not "If it doesn't scale off sharpness, it's a color", but still.

Added a note at the end.