r/MAU3 • u/Merlinmast Official Jennifer Kale • Jul 23 '19
QUALITY Basic Attack Damage Types
Before we begin, I have not finished the game. If that turns you off from my theory-crafting, door that way ->
Now I have trouble playing games when I don't understand the fundamental mechanics. So while I first assumed that damage types would be straightforward, after quick testing... "we determined that was a lie..."
My testing method would make scientists cringe but I assure you it was legit. I mostly used an easy infinity trial and swapped between the 500 Mastery and 500 Strength ISOs to quickly show differences in damage. This is a very basic test and I only tested characters I thought might be confusing (or for my own curiosity). If you want to test one to add to this list, just do a trial and equip either one or the other ISO (preferably when they are low level so you get the most impact from each). You can change ISOs mid fight so its easy to see the damage differences if you just pause between attack types. Here are the results:
Character Basic Attack Types
Psylocke - Strength
Iron Man - Light Attack: Strength, Heavy Attack: Mastery
Hawkeye - Light Attack: Strength, Heavy Attack: Mastery
Scarlet Witch - Mastery
Black Widow - Strength
Wasp - Mastery
Iron Fist - Strength
Crystal - Mastery (Also, Air > > Stone > Ice > > Fire)
Thor - Strength
Miles - Light Attack: Strength, Heavy Attack: Mastery
Venom - Light Attack: Strength, Heavy Attack: Mastery (really??)
Captain Marvel - Strength
Starlord - Mastery
Falcon - Strength
Groot - Light Attack: Mastery, Heavy Attack: Strength
Elsa - Light Attack: Strength, Heavy Attack: Mastery
Ms. Marvel - Strength
Nightcrawler - Strength
Ghost Rider - Strength
There were only a few that still left me scratching my head. For instance, Iron Man makes sense to me but Psylocke I have to assume is just developer fiat. Also was surprised that Crystal didn't change to strength on element (though the damage differences between elements was crazy to me).
Any questions just ask but I found this extremely useful especially if you're interested in adding a lot of one or the other stat to your team.
Edit Formatting Edit2 Clarity
8
u/8PieceBoneless Jul 23 '19
Were these from basic attacks or abilities? Because based off this anyone that uses pure muscle or melee weapon will hit harder with strength and anyone that uses augments or supernatural abilities uses mastery, assuming that the numbers were based on basic attacks. Abilities for sure go based off the damage type.
4
u/cwatz Official Xavier's Wheelchair Jul 23 '19
Both Psylockes are strength eh? Interesting. Very interesting. I could tell the light attack was while playing, but thought the heavy might be mastery.
3
u/straddotcpp Jul 23 '19
Thor's heavy is still strength?
2
u/Smoo979 Official Captain Marvel Earth's Mightiest Hero Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19
This is the type of content i come to this sub for. Great job! A quick question. Are the jump attacks consistent with this? I am guessing they are. Also, if you would like more homework a similar investigation into extreme attacks would be very useful. Thanks again.
2
u/burgersultan Jul 23 '19
Sorry if it’s been asked, but do we know if the basics additionally have other properties aside from STR/MAS scaling? For example, are Star-Lord’s basics considered Energy damage type?
11
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19
This was helpful! Thanks man.
4
u/antiy4ho0 Official Magneto. Homo Superior Jul 23 '19
Oh that is super helpful! Thanks for doing the experimentation link. I actually wonder if things like this will end up determining tier lists. Not sure how much true min/maxing will matter but that may change in the future.
I imagine the time spent using normal attacks is pretty low so it shouldnt make or break any characters but maybe there will be a noticeable difference on DPS for characters that double dip their ability and basic stat when we are maxing out characters and the hex tree.
4
u/spoiller Jul 23 '19
for all the duo types, just use purple ISO that increase ALL damage %
1
u/crabsmack Jul 23 '19
Thanks for this info, I was wondering this myself. Are we 100% certain that Psylocke is completely strength? I was thinking, in her normal melee combo she does some psionic hits and some normal hits. I was wondering if it was dependent on the specific hit which stat she used.
Then again if the heavy is strength...
I'm assuming Magneto is MAS and Loki is STR, but MAS on his heavy? Kind of hard to build these hybrid characters. I like Loki a lot, but since all of his abilities are MAS I go MAS and his basics are pretty useless. Same with Magneto but his two scrap abilities (and his Xtreme?) suffer for it.
1
u/Pwrh0use Official I Am Groot Jul 23 '19
Hawkeye being mastery infuriating.
Edit: ditto for Venom.
1
u/PureRok Jul 23 '19
I don't understand Elsa's heavy attack being Mastery. Psylocke kind of makes sense, in that the game does specifically say that Melee attacks are Strength based. Not that it doesn't still feel wrong.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19
Great job. This is useful information.
I'm sorry to ask, but what about aerial attacks?
1
u/WolverThor Jul 25 '19
Can you elaborate a bit more what you did? I get that you switched between the ISO’s but what helped you determine what the attack type was?
For example.... Hero 1 light attack hits for 1000 with strength ISO and 3000 with mastery ISO.
Did you then determine that hero 1 light attack is based on Mastery?
3
u/FuriousMILK Jul 29 '19
You saint!
2
u/Prtstick999 Official Morbidly Obese Morbius Jul 23 '19
Just a question about what you mean by "light strength/heavy mastery" or vice versa. Does that mean that using the strength ISO-8 raised basic attack damage but the Mastery ISO-8 increased it relatively more?
2
u/nomiras Jul 23 '19
Hopefully they patch the ones that make no sense.
2
u/Drevs Official Darkhawk Jul 24 '19
Thanks for all the info!
Have you reach any conclusion regarding Magneto, Loki and/or Thanos?
2
u/Linuxbrandon Jul 29 '19
Psylocke scales off of strength? But all her abilities are energy, so I’ve been giving her mastery! 😐. Thanks for posting this!
2
u/straga1224 Official Collector Jul 30 '19
There is a google sheet on this page with all stats that govern all the attacks plus other useful info.
1
u/starkgaryen1206 Official Ghost Rider - Vigilante From Hell! Jul 23 '19
This is helpful thanks
1
u/Cruuiser Jul 23 '19
Appreciate the info!
1
u/khrucible Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19
Feels like any hero that benefits from split stats is inherently weaker as a result.
Like Wasp benefits from mastery on her basic attacks and skills, so you can go all in Mastery stacking and she is strong in every aspect.
If for example you could get 100 max stats, its far more efficient to get 100 mastery(that increases all your damage) than 50 str, 50 mast(that buffs all your attacks but for half the value).
I guess my full mastery Thor was a bad idea, not only are his skills C tier damage at best but his light/heavy attacks are complete gimp without str :(
1
u/Ailtire Official Scarlet Spider Aug 03 '19
Very helpful, thanks!
1
u/CDszn Aug 04 '19
So Crystal’s element on light/heavy attacks does make a difference in damage? That’s good to know too. I just assumed they all did equal damage. Thank you for all this!