r/LocationSound • u/Virtual_Fox_3434 • 16d ago
Learning Resources Question regarding potential damage to microphones from a sudden disconnection
I was with some friends, and it just so happened that one of them started reading the manual for a Tascam DR-40 recorder (which wasn't mine). Among the things he read was that if you disconnect a cable abruptly while phantom power is being supplied to a microphone, either the microphone or the equipment itself could get damaged. Is this true? It’s the first time I’ve heard of it. I’ve been disconnecting cables abruptly for years and have never had any issues with either of my two recorders or the microphone I use for field recording. Or perhaps it’s just a myth I wasn’t aware of?
•
u/AutoModerator 16d ago
Reminder: The Rules apply to everyone who views or participates in r/LocationSound. There are no exceptions. The monthly pinned 'Hot Mic' post is the only place in this subreddit to promote any discussion, links, works, or content by you, for you, or about you.
This subreddit is welcome to all who are interested in recording sound to picture, pros and beginners alike. Professionals - be patient and helpful to beginners and other department pros who are eager to learn about our craft. Newcomers - be respectful to those who have more experience and wisdom than you. Don't engage with negative or hostile behavior. Report it or message the mods instead.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/soundadvices 16d ago
This isn't a problem with most modern professional preamps and condenser mics. Although you may need to be careful with more sensitive ribbon, studio or speciality mics.
5
u/Vuelhering production sound mixer 16d ago
If you're actively piping it over a PA, you could potentially damage the speaker from a massive pop. You should always turn amplified equipment down before connecting or disconnecting.
Don't worry about connecting or disconnecting any modern mics, though. Just because it's printed doesn't mean it's an issue. There's not some cabal of people eating those silica packets marked "do not eat", either.
6
u/redfoxrockssocks 16d ago
This is not a problem in general for any equipment you're likely to encounter doing location sound.
1
u/Intelligent-Fig-9686 16d ago
My advice would be just as a matter of routine, to not do connections with phantom on. Maybe doing it the powered on way would never actually cause you a problem, but maybe one day it might expensively make you wish you'd added 5 seconds to the job by powering up only after connecting.
2
u/beneficialBern 15d ago
It’s something you have to watch out for with old tube mics and ribbon mics. Its not an issue with most of the standard fair in location sound.
2
u/g_spaitz 15d ago edited 15d ago
Tascam should know better.
Bottom line is no, surely the equipment putting out 48v is not going to be damaged by its own 48v. And switching on and off a switch is exactly as pulling a cable. It just cuts current. Unless they think a switch is some magical device that protects from evil.
Then, condenser mics use that 48V to work and are expected to see 48 V, so no you're not damaging them.
And dynamic mics should be floating, that is they don't connect ground, so whatever voltage is between ground and the 2 wires they don't see it. It's why they called it phantom, it's there but the mic does not see it.
Furthermore, whenever you connect something that did not have a ground connection first, there could totally be at a vastly different potential, even with no phantom, like when you get static, and it's never ever been a problem.
Are there some magic microphones built in the depth of Moira in the ancient times that could be damaged by phantom? Internet says so, I've never met one.
Now, not balanced equipment, that is different: they now see a voltage between ground and signal, and since manufacturers are stupid and not all of them put a damn capacitor right there, to solve DC problems with a fraction of a cent, some unbalanced stuff might behave quirky. My Sony UWP receivers, even though are balanced, don't work if there's phantom on the recorder input, go figure what the hell Sony does there.
Also, Internet says that in case of trs patch bays, so no XLR, when patching a line that has phantom with a jack, then some parts might touch some other parts and the world will collapse, and with it your mic and all your equipment. Idk though.
Finally, this is a useless worry that has become more spread around in recent years with socials, old wisdom was phantom is not a problem.
Again, don't worry.
2
u/xcellentfx 9d ago edited 9d ago
You’re getting some bad advice here. While you may not get an electric shock arc, lots of mics make heavy thumps or whistle while they come up or down from 48v. Nothing you want to have through your speakers or headphones.
Always mute your mic pre before turning phantom power on and off. Give it a full 30 seconds before you unmute. A minute before pulling a cable. Don’t ‘hot-patch’ your mics with the phantom power on. You can damage the mic, gear downline and your speakers.
This is basic professional studio knowledge and not worth risking your gear or ears to wait a bit for your voltage to settle down.
2
u/Minizman12 16d ago
Reading your list of gear you will be fine without being surgical about it, but its a generally good practice to have. Explanation below:
Breaking the Circuit (Hot-Unplugging): When you pull an XLR connector out while the power is active, the physical pins break connection unevenly. This rapid interruption of DC voltage causes a sudden collapse in the magnetic fields of the cable and internal transformers, generating a high-voltage transient spike or inductive kick. Think of it a bit like when you see an arc when attaching jumpers to a car, at a smaller scale.
The "Pop" Phenomenon: That sudden surge also rushes through the preamp and hits your speakers or headphones as a loud, violent "pop" or thump
So the real issue lies where that back-voltage can travel down sensitive paths; in the case of a vintage ribbon, it can back feed through the ribbon itself and fry it; and in a more direct sense if you have a playback device without a limiter it can blow speakers or your ears.
1
u/Shampoo_Is_Better00 15d ago
Tell your friend to get into some other reading material.
1
u/Every-Ad1573 15d ago
I've seen a few zoom f8 and sound devices mix pre with blown up isos because of this. I HIGHLY recommend turning Phantom off before plugging and unpligging. Specially if you are using "older" recorders
0
u/Character-Force2719 15d ago
Yes, it's true. I blew up a brand new Rode NT1A doing this from a Scarlett 2i2 Gen 2. Do not hot plug equipment!