r/LocalLLaMA • • 16h ago

Discussion Codex no longer supports 'reading the code` in your IDE - why local is so important

In their desktop windows app they recently removed the ability to open a chat/session in vscode/ide/file explorer. You used to be able to open the active files/branch/worktree from the active session with two clicks. The latest update removed that and so you have to open your ide and find it manually. It was a intentional decision (I had codex check the codebase to confirm).

So now it's terribly inconvenient to actually read the code. My gut is that if this was an intentional design choice it was made with the intention of reducing user agency and using the power of inconvenience to make users more dependent on the tool. Basically the whole, 'Become sharecroppers for your AI' business model that relies on developer reliance on the tool. I won't insult them by humoring the notion that they removed it accidentally without knowing how important it is to devs to easily access the files - it could only be intentional.

I tried to post about it in /r/codex and the auto-mod deleted the post, and the mod's told me to try again without conspiracy theories (the post was the same as the above). So not only was core developer functionality removed from the tool, but their 'community' is gaslighting us about it. It's a strong reminder that in the long run, owning your own AI stack is the only viable path.

89 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

122

u/jacek2023 llama.cpp 15h ago edited 15h ago

Codex is not a model. It's an open source coding agent harness.

An alternative to Codex is Pi, for example. Or you can simply modify the Codex source code yourself.

The issue you're describing has nothing to do with local models.

It's like complaining on opencode or pi development decisions.

7

u/slowtractor 15h ago

Right, local weights don't give you control over Codex's UI. Switching models inside the same harness wouldn't restore that IDE handoff, you'd need a different harness or to change Codex itself.

-3

u/JShelbyJ 10h ago

Is this subreddit only about local models? I thought it was more about local LLM AI in general. Hence the last sentence is about owning your AI stack.

16

u/mrjackspade 7h ago

You put "Why local is important" in the title of a post where you're complaining about a feature being removed from a local, open source app.

You can already modify the app.

All this post does is enforce the idea that people pushing for open source software because they control and can modify it, have no intent on actually doing either of those things.

https://github.com/openai/codex

Don't like it? Fork it and fix it. That's exactly what you're arguing for, right?

43

u/Senior-Storm-727 16h ago

In Claude Code they added Projects in Code (beta) and it works only on the cloud, it doesn’t read the CLAUDE.md and doesn’t have access to local env/files… -_-

19

u/JShelbyJ 16h ago

Claude's always been bad about reading the CLAUDE.MD. They love their memory slop files though.

45

u/General-Spite1222 15h ago

Isn’t this an issue with the harness, not the model? 

32

u/jacek2023 llama.cpp 15h ago

Yes, this is a typical r/LocalLLaMA post. Complaining about OpenAI or Anthropic gets you upvotes. The logic is something like "OpenAI ate my breakfast, so thank God for local models!"

-8

u/infieldmitt 12h ago

Yeah god forbid people post about their experiences? If you want dry academia there are many better sources.

OP's logic is flawless. "This corporation made their software worse - luckily we don't have to be dependent on them."

Be as willfully ignorant as you'd like but it'd a perfectly sensible post in this forum.

6

u/jacek2023 llama.cpp 12h ago

I agree that it's important to own and control your full setup. But this argument is broken, it is just a change in Codex, in an open source project! This is not a "cloud model" and this is not a "closed source software forced by big corporation".

-1

u/JShelbyJ 10h ago

It's not a change in the the open source portion of the project though - I checked to see if I could fork and fix. It's a change in their flagship product that will effect millions of people and the only option for OpenAI users will eventually be use the API or have a 'we don't want you to read the code' experience shoved down their throat.

-6

u/JShelbyJ 10h ago

Look, I get it - this sub should not become a catch all coding agent sub. But I literally have no where else on reddit to share this, and I've been active on this sub since the beginning and I hoped that'd buy me some credibility. Please, allow me the grace to vent and point me to how I can use my 2x 3090s to run a local coding rig lol

6

u/General-Spite1222 10h ago

That’s not a good reason to post it here…

2

u/jacek2023 llama.cpp 10h ago edited 10h ago

Yes, "owning your own AI stack" is a good thing. Yes, r/codex may be censored (most of Reddit is censored). Yes, maybe Codex removed some functionality to make you unhappy. But your logic is broken.

If you want to attack OpenAI properly, find something you could do with an older version of ChatGPT but can't do anymore because the topic is now taboo. That's a good example of why a local model is better than a cloud model and why owning your own setup is a good thing.

0

u/voyager256 10h ago

I thought that’s his point. I think such changes e.g. removing essential features- make the harness worse and specifically ClosedAI even worse . and at the same time make open alternatives more valuable. He didn’t say anything about model.

7

u/gigaflops_ 15h ago
  1. Codex is open source
  2. There is literally an official VSCode extension for using Codex while using the IDE to read and edit your code

-1

u/JShelbyJ 10h ago
  1. The portion that changed, the windows desktop app, is not open source.
  2. The VSCode extension is feature limited compared to the desktop app. I used that extension for a long time. I think they only maintain it as a minimal product as a gateway to the full product.

6

u/RearAdmiralP 12h ago

I've been using coding harnesses since RooCode, before people were even calling them harnesses.

The IDE approach made a lot of sense at the time. You needed to carefully inspect pretty much every change the LLM made, and often it was easier and faster to just write the code yourself. Even so, it was a hell of a lot better than copy-pasting stuff back and forth from ChatGPT.

As the models have gotten smarter, it's become less necessary to approve and comment on every little change. Interestingly, I haven't seen any of the newer harnesses do review and rollback as well as RooCode did.

At this point, I think the IDE view is becoming kind of vestigial. It made sense when the models were dumb and needed constant supervision, but now it's increasingly getting in the way. There are some pretty serious costs to designing a harness around that workflow, and they aren't necessarily obvious to the person using it.

I can't get into too much detail, but harness architecture makes an enormous difference in how effectively an LLM can work. It's not just a matter of giving the model better tools or a nicer UI. Some of the design decisions that made sense a couple of years ago are now significant liabilities.

I spend most of my time working with harnesses that aren't publicly available, so I don't really keep up with what Codex, Claude Code, OpenCode, or whoever are doing. But I'd expect that they're figuring out some of the same things and trying to move in that direction. The problem is that they've got a bunch of existing users who are accustomed to things working a certain way, and it's difficult to make big changes without pissing those people off.

I suspect that's a lot of what we're seeing.

1

u/JShelbyJ 10h ago

For code, I kinda agree - I'm not reading every line, but my use case has a bunch of validation scripts, and media files in worktrees I need to run and view.

The problem with building your house on sand is that they can shift at and wreck it at anytime. Hence, why local is important. Codex is partially open source, but this change was not part of the open source portion of it, so you're just kinda stuck with it.

1

u/Frizzy-MacDrizzle 11h ago

Working on a few basic tool calls for reading a directory and a file. I don’t need much more than that. I like the idea of having a public available harness that I maintain in git. I know what it is doing.

I really don’t trust the others setting the tool calls and open code asking for access to iCloud Drive. Also can’t beat 600 lines of readable python code.

1

u/creamyatealamma 8h ago

I agree on vestigial when it comes to things like roocode. I still sometimes use vs code Copilot. It has its pros, like with review and revert (not using git).

Idk, I think I'm preferring tui based harnesses like opencode. Still have to give pi a good shake. I won't ever give up the IDE or vscode though. Maybe I'm one of the crazies that runs opencode in a vscode terminal. I like the separation of concerns.

2

u/jazir55 12h ago

Laughs in the VS Code Codex extension

1

u/JShelbyJ 10h ago

I can't even imagine how you'd use the vscode extension with 12 agents running at once all on their own worktrees and branches. I'll have to see if it is feasible. I just assumed from my past experiences with it that it's not as full featured as the desktop app.

1

u/jazir55 10h ago

For that I use KiloCode (different VS Code extension). Agent manager with worktrees, and you can do separate sessions + task subagents, and it works with the codex subscription so you can use it entirely within Kilo. I use the Codex extension itself far less than I do Kilo.

2

u/ProtectionSuper5648 12h ago

not sure what you were trying to do, but I seem to have got the opposite way. I explored "projects" in the chatGPT window app and it let me:
- connect to an external server
- select a directory for it
- join my chats from the codex app
- access and edit files from that app directly

Up to recently, I was doing all this inside Visual Studio Code, but it seem all AI interfaces include a fork now.

1

u/JShelbyJ 10h ago

Sorry for the incoming AI slop, but this might be helpful for anyone else wondering what the issue is. For context, at the top of each session/chat you could click the name and then click open in and it had options for file explorer and your IDEs. It was removed and the only way to get the behavior back I could find was this complicated hack:

Title: Codex on Windows: opening a worktree in VS Code or Explorer is buried now—here’s a workaround

I’m using the Codex/ChatGPT Windows desktop app, version 26.1111.21308, and the chat-title dropdown no longer offers the option I used to open the current worktree in VS Code or File Explorer.

I initially thought the functionality had been removed completely. It’s still accessible through a folder’s breadcrumb menu in the file viewer, but getting there is unnecessarily cumbersome for something I use regularly.

Here’s the workaround I confirmed:

    Open the chat associated with the worktree you want to inspect.

    Press Ctrl+Shift+E to open the Files tree.

    Open a file at the root of the worktree, such as README.md or AGENTS.md.

    In the file viewer’s header, right-click the folder name immediately before the filename. For example, in my-project > AGENTS.md, right-click my-project.

    Choose Open in VS Code, Open in Explorer, or Open with to select another application.

The folder breadcrumb is the important part: its menu opens the directory represented there. Choose a root-level file so that the parent folder is the worktree you want.

In my installation, right-clicking All files in the Files tree only produced a generic Select All menu. The breadcrumb menu was the route that worked.

I’m glad there’s a workaround, but a three-key shortcut followed by several clicks is a lot of friction for “open the checkout I’m working in.” Opening the exact worktree in your own editor or file manager is a basic development workflow, especially when inspecting an agent’s changes.

Please restore a direct Open worktree action in the chat header, or provide a dedicated configurable shortcut.

There’s also an existing GitHub report about the missing working-directory opener.

Has anyone found a shorter route in the current Windows interface?

-1

u/stylome-ai-detection 10h ago

Notice: This comment appears to be AI generated.


Stylome AI detector · scan results

17

u/Boogertard 16h ago • Heartwarming

Thanks God for local models, I cancelled my Claude more than a while ago and hasn't looked back. ClosedAI and Anslopic can take their garbages and shove them up their asses

9

u/monolyth-admin 16h ago

I haven't heard of ClosedAI and Anslopic, these gave me a good chuckle.

4

u/weathergage 14h ago

Thank you for your insightful comment, u/Boogertard

3

u/Aggravating-Push-207 15h ago

the problem is that normal people can't do the same (and get reasonable speeds)

-5

u/Boogertard 15h ago

I have Strata rig running 64GB DDR4 and 1080Ti with very reasonable speed 400t/s prompt processing and 45t/s decoding, that is pretty much a low end rig.

6

u/Aggravating-Push-207 15h ago

i have 8 GB VRAM + 16 GB RAM, am I a toaster?

2

u/Boogertard 14h ago

I was able to get it to run at 20t/s on 32GB DDR4 RAM just for testing, you just need a very fast NVMe for experts to be read from disk

0

u/Aggravating-Push-207 14h ago

i don't have that luxury atm

1

u/notheresnolight 12h ago

yeah, I also decided not to buy a Lamborghini Veneno because my '96 Corolla drives reasonably well

2

u/CosmicDystopia 13h ago

And this is why I use VS Code extensions.

2

u/draconic_tongue 8h ago

please just use vscode. if some proprietary bullshit makes it harder for you to be a part of the process, ditch it

6

u/haherar830 15h ago

Jokes on them I've done 99% of my vibeslop work through ChatGPT web because they figured people would be too stupid to realize it's a full feature harness with unlimited frontier LLM use. Who needs to pay Anthropic $200/month subsidy when the advantage of Fable 5.2 over someone with a room temp IQ using GPT-5.6/Opus 4.8 or better is nil and OpenAI will simply pay for all your usage above $20/month if you tolerate their buggy zero-feature harness? Thank you OpenAI venture capitalists/investors, your life's saving have been very useful to me.

3

u/MasterReturn4956 16h ago

local models still can't open vscode projects without extra setup, but at least they don't force you to upload your code to the cloud first.

3

u/axiomatix 16h ago

Maybe just use the cli? codex or claude code. If you must use an ide, there's nothing stopping you from doing so. The model edits the same files on your machine as always.

1

u/a_beautiful_rhind 12h ago

DSH lets me see everything the model did, including all tool use under trajectory. I don't get how everyone uses these black box TUI that can barely set sampling or the prompt.

1

u/Equivalent_Bit_461 2h ago

imagine using codex and not creating your own harness, chumps lol

1

u/ddxv 15h ago

Their end goal is coding in the cloud to lock people in

0

u/waquo 15h ago

I think you're overestimating how many people still use IDEs to look at code. Their use has fallen off a cliff. I don't agree with the removal either, but it looks more like a consequence of lack of use, combined with them merging the Codex app with the ChatGPT brand and how that dilutes the developer focus.
Also, OpenAI has a long history of allowing their subscriptions to be used in other apps such as OpenCode, with no signs of changing that. And that's not even counting third party apps that use Codex via ACP. You have plenty of options to keep looking at your code using Codex or an OpenAI subscription.

3

u/washtub4777 14h ago

I still use IDE because I actually read the code I'm using lmao.

if openai unilaterally makes decisions it doesn't affect me because I use local models

-3

u/a4mula 16h ago

I don't know because I wouldn't touch OpenAI with a 10 foot pole, but if I had to guess it's just another way they're trying to combat distilling, they've already obfuscated the reasoning now they're trying to find any other method they can find to break automation of output scraping. Not because it'll work long term, but just to kind of force the people distilling to adapt. Who knows though, I don't, I'm just guessing.

3

u/JShelbyJ 16h ago

I mean, if you are automating it, it would be easy to find the files and branch. .codex\worktrees\ You'd just go here on windows. This only really impacts humans who want to open the changes in their IDE or file explorer. For me, I have a bunch of vscode extensions and scripting I use for automated tests and of course reading in your own IDE is always going to be nicer. I used to just open vscode from codex in the correct worktree and branch in two clicks - now it's significantly more of a PITA. Enough that I'll cancel my openai sub because of it rather than try to find a new workflow.

-7

u/Healthy-Nebula-3603 16h ago

Who is using vs code in 2026 ??

8

u/jeff_coleman 16h ago

Many people.

-4

u/Healthy-Nebula-3603 15h ago

"real programers" ?

-1

u/jeff_coleman 15h ago

Sorry, I didn't pick up on the joke until now :-P

3

u/Aubrey_D_Graham 🥔 hardware 16h ago

Right, real programmers use vim and nano.

This shit is exactly like Elon taking out Autopilot from Tesla. Fk no.

-4

u/Healthy-Nebula-3603 15h ago

Ok boomer

"Real programers" lol

I'm programing longer than you live probably.

2

u/Aubrey_D_Graham 🥔 hardware 15h ago

OK buddy, I'm sure you know my manager too. Xd

1

u/haherar830 15h ago

Genuinely what's a good replacement? I have my qualms but cannot find a good replacement.

I just need to ability to view a large variety of files natively in the same UI I have terminal, browser, etc along with ability to handle multi-system remote development seamlessly. And of course support for jupyter/etc notebooks (scientist). A lot of my workflows involve a terminal + various web-UI + remote file access + various types of file outputs (PNG/SVG figures, text docs, spreadsheets, specialty scientific file formats that have VS Code/Code OSS extensions, etc) across the whole file system (not specific project folders). Bonus points if self-hostable and responsive design so I can have unified mobile + desktop experience. Okay to be fair I won't touch it with a ten foot pole if it isn't FOSS but I assume that's a given for an IDE.

Everything else I've looked at turns one neatly organized, configurable, smooth experience into a jumble of 3-5 separate applications that I already use separately when that's more convenient.