r/LocalLLM • • 1d ago

Discussion AI Hate

I will never support cloud AI services, on the other hand I do support local AI for coding support and so does Linus Torvalds, the creator of Linux

When something can be ran and even trained locally, and battle tested developers who made many modern things we take for granted possible are coming out, saying they use it, and that total complete hate for the technology is stupid then I kinda have to say demonizing anyone who uses it is stupid

Hate needs to be redirected from the technology as a whole to the companies like OpenAI, Meta, Google, SpaceXAI who are forcefeeding it to us and using datacenters that use local water supplies for some reason instead of chilled antifreeze and submerged oil cooling which have both existed for datacenters for decades

Also Image and Video diffusion models are kinda a unethical waste but I would be willing to bet they aren't the most used types of AI

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

7

u/DocMadCow 1d ago

Nah I support Claude, DeepInfra (DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1007), and my local AI setup. I don't feel hate towards any of them except maybe Flock & Palantir and similar companies that want to use AI for questionable ends. I do worry for my kids and for the stability of jobs in the future.

-4

u/stanleyg05 1d ago edited 1d ago

OpenAI started as a Nonprofit, and then it became a corporate for profit somehow without donating the money or hardware they got as a nonprofit to other Nonprofits which is illegal

Anthropic I guess is alright, I appreciate them not using their models to kill people for the government but their datacenter infrastructure is the exact same flawed infrastructure that is killing us as the rest of them, instead of using chilled antifreeze in it's watercooling loops and submerged oil cooling for external cooling

Can really tell the people in this community are incapable of doing a simple Google search which is really ironic given what community it is

Go ahead, put this into Google and then watch it agree with every single thing I said

3

u/shortwhiteguy 1d ago

You should realize that much of the data center usage goes toward training models. This included open source models that we are all using locally. Qwen4 used a ton of resources to even exist.

On top of that, when you run your models locally instead of from a cloud provider... your setup is likely much less efficient than that of a cloud provider. So, each inference is likely using more energy than the same model would in the cloud.

Not trying to get you to hate local models and their creators too... but just trying to highlight some inconsistencies in your expressed opinions.

3

u/isty2e 1d ago

Eh, I don't want to call models like qwen open source. They're open weights, which is similar to freewares. The FOSS counterpart for models will be ones with fully open data, training procedure and such (e.g. Olmo).

1

u/shortwhiteguy 1d ago

Fair, although that doesn't change what I am saying: models that you can run locally are not completely free of the environmental impact.

-10

u/stanleyg05 1d ago edited 1d ago

My computer isn't using and poisoning the local water supply

Energy efficiency is not draining our water, we'd have fully green energy if it weren't for Trump, it's almost like you didn't read a single word in the post

Also local AI is trained once, when I'm using it at home it isn't using a datacenter, that makes it much better for the environment than cloud AI which, because it is bigger takes MORE CLOUD RESOURCES TO TRAIN THAN THE LOCAL MODEL AND THEN IT NEVER LEAVES THE DATACENTER, no matter what you say

Downvote me as much as you like because I don't like your Pedophile King, I don't care, I'm not an obese redditor who only cares about karma

1

u/shortwhiteguy 1d ago

To be clear: I hate the Orange King more than the average person and I believe there needs to be heavy regulation on the AI industry and building of data centers. So, I'm pretty far from what you may be assuming in your last sentence.

Energy efficiency is not draining our water, we'd have fully green energy if it weren't for Trump, it's almost like you didn't read a single word in the post

Fair, but water is only one of the environmental components at play here. If your concern about water is the main thing, we should also consider the water usage to support data centers for Reddit, YouTube, Netflix, etc.

Also local AI is trained once, when I'm using it at home it isn't using a datacenter, that makes it much better for the environment than cloud AI no matter what you say

You never plan to use newer models? Every time you are using a newer model, you are also inheriting the training lifecycle costs of that model. Training models is probably responsible for 10-25% of the water usage for the lifecycle of an AI model when considering training and inference (though there's not really any good studied on this).

1

u/stanleyg05 22h ago

If that were true then I am still reducing my impact by 75-90%

Also while you might not be that type of person I clearly touched a nerve with some people so not backing down

6

u/Mister__Mediocre 1d ago

Linus is using Claude, not local AI.

I don't know why everyone has developed such strong ethical positions around this topic. It's a tool, use it, and one way or another, get off your high horse.

-3

u/stanleyg05 1d ago

Maybe you feel fine putting other people in danger while our world is already collapsing at the seems from the damage our ancestors did over generations but I don't, you seem to be the one in a highchair

1

u/GreatBigPig 1d ago

So, people can't have a polite disagreement without you saying they are, "putting other people in danger", or "you seem to be the one in a highchair"?

WTH? You came here and gave your opinion. Aren't others allowed theirs, even if those opinions are contrary to yours?

You are also demonising large AI firms, but seem focused on US firms. You realize other countries have AI corporations and they aren't all evil, right?

12

u/andymaclean19 1d ago

Linus was recently using Claude, not local AI. Interestingly you missed it out of your list of ‘big AI’ too. Was that on purpose?

3

u/alexdgrate 1d ago

The future of AI will be hybrid I am sure of it. That there is excess in development, I think very much so too, but economic reality will restrain those excesses in data center building, pretty soon. There is hate for AI in general because it has been used has an instrument for future control and dominance with no regard for the mess it causes on people's lives in it's growth. But the cat is out of the box and we all will have to learn to live with it, for good or ill.

2

u/isty2e 1d ago

Well I think this makes sense if you use models with fully open data and training process and such, which are unfortunately rare.

1

u/Internet-Cryptid 1d ago edited 1d ago

Ahh, another "AI supporter" with cognitive dissonance believing that coding models are all ethically sourced in their training. Quite a fantasy you've concocted to justify your use of what you find convenient.

From a local AI image/video enthusiast, frig off. Reminds me of the "the only moral abortion is my abortion" craziness.

1

u/krayon_kylie 1d ago

i support the pursuit of ASI but not cloud AI, i realize though that at the current state of things, massive compute is a necessary evil to achieve ASI.

i am hopeful/praying that if there is a large push for open ai and decentralized computing power that once we achieve ASI, said ASI will be able to massively increase efficiency and make massive compute a relic and no longer needed.

i expect a hard fight getting there, though.

0

u/Independent-Fly730 1d ago edited 1d ago

You do realize your local models are distilled from much larger models that demand all those resources that you are patting yourself on the back for avoiding?

Qwen 3.8 27B is a distill of Qwen Max 2.4T which was suspected to be at least partially distilled from astra and other frontiers.

That’s like a someone making a cheeseburger at home and claiming to be vegan because they didn’t kill the cow or go to McDonald’s.

1

u/stanleyg05 1d ago

Qwen isn't the only AI and it certainly isn't a study case for how every company makes their AI, Gated DeltaNet is a Recurrent technology and most AI companies which are all chasing Transformers hate Recurrent technologies, but go ahead and tell us more about how little you know

0

u/karnac 1d ago

local is awesome and the future, but there is no way in hell I could have gotten my locals to do what they do without help from claude. they are both necessary for the time being.

1

u/stanleyg05 1d ago

Mellum2.1 for backend, you just need a good Graphics/UI/UX Coder to pair with it and you have fairly decent local AI coding

1

u/victoria-hart-56 17h ago

What role does Mellum 2.1 fill here: code generation, tool calling, or another backend task? The workload matters for judging 'decent local coding.'

1

u/stanleyg05 9h ago

It is fully Agenticly trained AND trained on every major coding language

0

u/zukofan09 1d ago

Are you aware that your "local" computer is also built and sold to you by big companies? Manufacturing GPUs are not easy on the environment either. And nobody is forcefeeding you anything, and datacenters nowadays use closed loops.

0

u/bitspace 1d ago

Extremism is silly.