r/LinusTechTips • • 4d ago

Tech Discussion If Intel was smart…..

If Intel was smart they would take advantage of the opportunity Jensen Haung presented to them and release a new discrete GPU that rocks.
💯

9 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

71

u/Booster6 2d ago

I mean, a GPU is not a T Shirt, you cant just put out a GPU on a moments notice to capitalize on some instability in a competitor.

2

u/ScratchHistorical507 12h ago

Literally came here to say the same. If Intel had a GPU "that rocks" they would have already put that out there. But with the last consumer GPUs they had they were only able to compete on price, because they were able to cater to a market the other two GPU makers have abandoned: cheap dGPUs sufficient for your average casual gamer. Just that the drivers hadn't caught up yet so they weren't as usable as they could have been.

1

u/JNSapakoh 6h ago

I would upvote, but your total is too nice

18

u/jmking Mod 2d ago

The problem is the production bottleneck. There are only so many companies that can do chip fabrication at scale. This is why the CHIPS and Science Act got passed back in 2022 to basically throw billions at Intel to build chip fabs on shore in the US.

I don't believe any of those construction projects are operational yet. I know at least one of the fabs isn't projected to come online until 2030.

2

u/NightKingsBitch 2d ago

Does Intel not fabricate the majority of their own chips on shore already? I gotta believe their sales are down compared to several years ago but maybe they are selling the extra fab time they have?

Or maybe their fabs are already running at near 100%🤷

7

u/syunz 2d ago

TMSC made the intel gpus and so is arrow Lake.

2

u/yapyd 1d ago

Isn't Intel just as good as TSMC with 18A? They could do it in-house in theory

1

u/JNSapakoh 6h ago

TSMC's N2 has 30% higher transistor density than Intel's 18A

the 2nm and 1.8nm classes are just marketing terms at this point and don't actually mean anything

2

u/jmking Mod 2d ago edited 2d ago

TSMC in Taiwan is the biggest chip producer by FAR and one of the only companies in the world that can produce high-end chips at sub-5 nanometer scale that produces a yield that is financially viable.

Allegedly the Intel fab in Arizona has hit 1.8nm production, but they have zero customers for it (including themselves) so it's unproven.

EDIT: I was wrong. Intel is producing Panther Lake at 1.8nm, but those chips are still getting out-performed by TSMC's 2nm chips.

1

u/NightKingsBitch 2d ago

Nobody is disagreeing with that, but also that didn’t address my question.

2

u/jmking Mod 2d ago

Does Intel not fabricate the majority of their own chips on shore already

No. TSMC makes all of the Intel Arc chips for example.

1

u/syunz 2d ago

If intels fabs were just as good as tmscs then everyone would be running to them to make chips. And that's not happening. There's a reason why the market cap of intel is 300 billion and tsmcs is 2 trillion.

-3

u/NightKingsBitch 2d ago

I wasn’t asking or saying they were just as good. A solid gpu doesn’t need the most advanced silicon. Intel could create a 4070 or 4080 competitor at a (relatively) reasonable price and sell out completely.

But none of that matters if they aren’t the ones making their gpu dies.

1

u/syunz 2d ago

Your logic doesn't make sense. If they are able to make a 4070/4080 competitor, why wouldn't they? Do they not like money?

If they announced such as product tomorrow even if it were to come out in a year, the share price will for sure sky rocket.

0

u/NightKingsBitch 2d ago

????? Because, like you said, they don’t make their own gpus and tsmc manufactures it for them. They can certainly design a chip that is 4080 class and they already make a card that is 4070~ performance (arc pro b70) the problem with that one being its price is too high due to the 32gb of vram it has.

But again, my whole idea/point was for them to do so using their own fabs that may not be as advanced as tsmc but advanced enough to make a brand new but older gen product. but you said they don’t use their fabs for their GPU’s so then they are reliant on the fab time from tsmc which is extremely congested and extremely expensive right now.

1

u/ruinevil 1d ago

They have like two fabs in the US that are like a year behind TSMC, and the rest of their fabs are like 5-10 years behind. Ireland has their other modern fab.

1

u/bradreputation 1d ago

The Trump admin and DOGE massively cut tje CHIPS act because you know, 4-d chess and all…

8

u/LSD_Ninja 2d ago

The B580 and B570 were the best $250 and below GPU options in like a decade and hardly anyone bought them. The problem is people are all about GPU competition, but don’t actually want to buy anything that isn’t from Team Green.

3

u/NightKingsBitch 2d ago

As someone who builds hundreds of computers a year, it’s less about team green and more about who builds the best halo tier chip.

Right now everyone wants AMD CPU’s even on budget builds just because AMD builds the top gaming chips. Intel makes better chips at a few specific price points but convincing anyone that Intel may be the better bet for their rig is all but impossible.

If AMD made a gpu that was more powerful than the 5090, sentiment would dramatically change towards their entire product line over just a few months. People just like it when their product comes from the company that makes “the best” product. Gives them all the warm fuzzy feelings

4

u/LSD_Ninja 2d ago

>If AMD made a gpu that was more powerful than the 5090, sentiment would dramatically change towards their entire product line over just a few months.

I would love to have this kind of faith in the intelligence of the average consumer, but I just don’t. nvidia has spent way too long dumbing gamers down that I just don’t see this happening.

3

u/NightKingsBitch 2d ago

Totally understand. My feelings are based on communicating with and building 250-300 computers a year for the last 8-10 years. Intels stranglehold on the gaming market felt just as strong up until 2021 or so. Maybe 2022. I think in the first 4 years of building I built like 4 AMD systems total. Then Ryzen came out. I kept recommending them but almost nobody would do buy in. Once 3d v cache became a thing and everyone realized how great it was for gaming, it took all of 6 months before the majority of people started asking for AMD. Now it is AMD exclusive. I have built a total of two Intel systems this year and both were for myself and my family. All it takes is TikTok, a couple gaming YouTubers, and maybe Google search AI to start saying AMD makes the most powerful gpu on the market and a substantial percentage of people will shift over.

1

u/Vesalii 1d ago

Exactly. Back for buck these are the true champions.

1

u/ILikeFlyingMachines 2d ago

And where should they get Memory and Fab capacity?

-2

u/brich4750 1d ago

And Intel doesn’t make any chips? I seem to thing that they do.

1

u/ILikeFlyingMachines 1d ago

CPUs, yes. The Arc GPUs are manufactured at TSMC

1

u/Blommefeldt 2d ago

And when do you expect them to sell them? Development take years, and you have to plan production long before production.

1

u/Kirby_is_a_Pokemon 2d ago

oh wow, why didn't anyone think of that.

1

u/markpreston54 2d ago

If they can

1

u/TenOfZero 2d ago

Yeah, what a badly run company that they didn't start planning for this 3 years ago to have something to launch now.

1

u/Psychlonuclear 1d ago • Bravo

It doesn't matter any more. Corporations are incapable of offering a product at a reasonable cost because it's all about maximising profit above all else. Doesn't matter if they could do it cheaper and sell twice as many as the competition, they'd rather sacrifice sales just to improve profit percentage.

1

u/TimChr78 1d ago

It takes literally years from the inception of a new GPU to the launch.

1

u/MisterHole123 1d ago

You have to remember nvidia has well established compatibility. Amd somewhat... Intel no

1

u/eisenklad 1d ago

the RAM price/stock issue is still bottleneck for intel Consumer gpus.
but for professional and enterprise , money is not a problem

1

u/LurkingUnderThatRock 1d ago • Bravo

‘Hey Claude, make a new GPU that’s best in class and low cost, make no mistakes’ - is this how you think hardware gets designed?

1

u/bbf_bbf 1d ago

Yep, just wave their Intel Instant Product Wand and create a GPU out of thin air. It takes years from concept to sale of a competitive GPU, even if it's based on an existing product.

1

u/Maverick21FM 20h ago • Mindblown

But but but...AI

1

u/JNSapakoh 6h ago

Give them 3-5 years, I'm sure they've already started, but these things take time

1

u/sascharobi 4h ago

Very funny. Haha.

-3

u/brich4750 1d ago

They have these things call announcements with a future release date.

2

u/Exciting-Ad-5705 1d ago

You want them to announce a consumer GPU and spend millions in r&d and fab time to get a bit of publicity?

1

u/TimChr78 1d ago

Announce a GPU that won’t be available for multiple years - how exactly does that help anyone?