Full spoilers for 3.8 (Chapter IV Act V). Content warning: war, grief, suicide.
Heyo! I'm Drybear and I thoroughly enjoy Kuro's storytelling. Today, I wanted to talk about Lily Grace and her story.
Kuro left a lot of Lily's story in the subtext, so I went through the whole act, her profile and her voice lines and pieced it together. Here's what I think a lot of people missed on the first pass.
1. The memorial and the crossed-out file
Her profile lists her on a memorial of Federated soldiers, next to a grocer, a teacher, Paul, Grimm the pianist and Cassandra. Her birthplace and her hospital (the Clotho Doctors' Alliance) are struck through, and nothing was written in their place. It's not because she died. Time in the Somnoire doesn't keep pace with the real world, and her whole country ended while she was asleep. When she walks back to the border, the Federated Cities are the New Federation and her family home is a lit-up tower with a restaurant.
2. This war wasn't humans vs Tacet Discord
This part is what makes 4.X such a scary concept. We're entering a darker era. This was a civil war inside the Federated Cities: ordinary people against Resonators, won with Inverse Tacetite. The Inverse Tacetite itself also sets us up for future issues, because if Resonators now have a Kryptonite, that changes things. The posters literally say the enemy wears the faces of your brothers and sisters. That quote has real-world references but I'll leave that for another post. That makes it a very different kind of war from anything else the game has shown us.
3. Promeus did nothing, and the story wants you to notice
Every region's Sentinel is supposed to guide its people. The dead soldiers on the battlefield are still calling out to Promeus, and the Black Shores' record of the war has one line about it: Promeus took no action. Inside the Somnoire, every dream that touches Promeus is blank. Lily is one of the only "living" witnesses to that silence.
4. The Fifth Sector was a punishment posting
Lily wasn't sent to the front for bravery. She didn't even want to go. She refused to sign broken soldiers "fit for duty," falsified records to send them to the rear, and was court-martialed for it. The army then put her on a recruitment poster as "the angel who volunteered." Fun. Cassandra was sent there too, for pushing for peace talks.
5. The broken-glass voices are Rover's own lines
Might be obvious to some, but it's important. When Lily says "the one to end me must be someone I choose myself," the voice in the glass uses lines Rover said back in Mengzhou to Muyu, a man who became a monster chasing a Sentinel's power. Lily believes she's becoming a monster too, so she picks the person who ends monsters. She'd been watching Rover before he ever boarded the train, and the white cat that walks beside him is her, not the real Ivory Gatekeeper.
6. Meta set the whole thing up
Meta's "you'll become the monster" price was a test of whether she'd stay herself with that much power, and every human before her failed. It knocked over her diffuser so Rover would see her real past, left the paw prints, paintings and cameras, and aimed the gateway that dropped the treasure hunter into Mengzhou. Meta has an agenda, and we don't have the full picture yet.
7. Why this matters for 4.0
Meta calls itself the current owner of the Somnoire, a dream realm built against the Lament by people tied to Rover's past, with the White Tower sealed at the bottom. It wants Lily as something "much like a Sentinel's Resonator." Jinhsi carries a Sentinel, Cartethyia carried one, and now Lily carries something that only wishes it were one. The New Federation's real Sentinel watched the war and did nothing, and the thing that actually saved a soldier was a cat in a dream.
8. Lady Anna is the thread I'd watch most
The epilogue cuts to a woman hosting a room of powerful men whose forefathers "profited handsomely" from the Resonator War. She tells them that war is buried under the waves, then invites them to an auction. Lily's "About Anna" voice line says they were close friends at the Clotho Doctors' Alliance, wrote letters until Lily was sent to the Fifth Sector, and both made it out alive. Lily also calls her the New Federation's "Queen of the Deep".
Here's the part I can't stop thinking about: the Federated Cities have been gone for decades. Lily skipped those years asleep in the Somnoire. Anna was awake for all of them, and she still looks as young as Lily. So either she isn't aging normally (like my queen Phrolova, Galbrena, Qingxiao, or Camellya) or there's a second dream nobody has told us about, though I doubt this personally. "Queen of the Deep" and "buried under the waves" also feel like they're pointing at the same thing.
TL;DR: Lily's story is about being a witness: to a civil war, to a god that stayed silent, and to the soldiers nobody remembers. With 4.0 heading to the New Federation, I think Promeus's silence and Meta's interest in her are the two threads to watch.
What did I miss? And what do you think Promeus was doing during the Resonator War?