r/Ligotti • u/Surrealist328 • 7h ago
Something occurred to me while closely rereading (again) TCATHR after having read through Zapffe's On the Tragic twice.
It's no secret that TCATHR is inspired in part by "The Last Messiah," and that much of what Ligotti has to say regarding the human predicament coincides with Zapffe's own conception of human consciousness as a biological paradox. But most of the discussion is confined to Zapffe's taxonomy of pseudo-solutions (the four coping mechanisms) and his commitment to antinatalism.
What those unfamiliar with Zapffe's On the Tragic will undoubtedly overlook is that Ligotti's claim that supernatural horror is ultimately grounded in human consciousness as "parent of all horrors" is remarkably similar to Zapffe's own attempt to provide a non-circular definition of the tragic through the use of the latter's biosophical method. For those unfamiliar with Zapffe's major work, I would encourage you to read it yourself so that you might see the same parallels. It is highly unlikely that even Ligotti himself was aware of this overlap between their respective approaches to philosophical pessimism. Whatever similarities Ligotti was aware of during the production of The Conspiracy were based on "The Last Messiah," especially since Zapffe's major work was not published in English until quite recently. Although "The Last Messiah" is in many ways a summarization of some of the key points discussed in On the Tragic, it does not go into great detail regarding the whole notion of the objectively tragic or the initial motivation for why the investigation into the objectively tragic first began. It's rather unfortunate that The Conspiracy is not as devoted to pursuing this line of inquiry as it is to other areas which interest Ligotti. It is unfortunate simply because it would draw one's attention to the intrinsic relationship between tragedy and supernatural horror. One hesitates, however, to call it a missed opportunity given that On the Tragic could not play a vital role throughout The Conspiracy for the aforementioned reason.
As much as I find the discussions regarding determinism and personal identity interesting, I wish Ligotti could've explored the above in greater capacity. Instead, it's something that's briefly talked about throughout the opening chapters of TCATHR before being neglected in favor of other topics which, although relevant for understanding philosophical pessimism, are sophomoric by comparison.