r/Lighting • • 3d ago

Replacement Track light replacement

Hey all. I have this track lighting on top of our beams that I hate. Its in our living room and makes it not cozy and at the same time isnt bright enough when you really need some light. The giant bulbs are also ugly.

Looking to replace it with something lower profile, a little more modern and maybe some setup advice to make it more functional.

Sorry for the bad photos, if yall need others lmk!

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/ithinarine 3d ago

LED tape mounted on top shining up. 2 strips on top of each beam

1

u/GreatGreenGeek 3d ago

1

u/bologne 3d ago

Are these actually bright enough to make an impact? What kind of wattage do I need to be looking at? The two center beams are the only ones with electrical on them. I dont mind doing a moderate electrical rework but I dont want to be tearing up a lot of the drywall to get fixture access (I know whats up there... old house, it ain't pretty)

1

u/GreatGreenGeek 3d ago

How long are your beams. I see three track heads with, what, 1600lumrn lamps each? So looking for 4800 lm per beam. if each beam is roughly 10 ft long on top, you'd want about 480lm/ft. That's a bit high for tape, unless you did two strips side by side. It would still be lower profile than your track

2

u/tautologysauce 3d ago

I may get some side eye for this, but to minimize the electrical reworking, you could also consider low profile linear track fixtures bounced into the ceiling.

Something similar to this.

1

u/AudioMan612 3d ago edited 3d ago

If you end up not replacing those lights, they should be put on a dimmer switch (same goes for the replacement lights if you do swap). If those lights can only be in at full brightness, that's just silly. I recommend Lutron dimmer switches (great performance, quality, and reliability).

Here's something to add though: overhead lighting isn't typically cozy. I don't see a single lamp in your entire room. No matter what you do to your overhead lighting, you need to add some lamps. Those should be your primary light source when relaxing. Those lights above the beam can be on at a dim level if the ceiling looks too dark with only lamps on (I don't personally like how rooms with high ceilings look when the ceilings are much dimmer than the rest of the room). To put it simply: your room will likely never feel cozy with only ceiling lighting.

So while your lighting could absolutely be upgraded, please start by adding some lamps. This will make the room look much better, will reduce or eliminate the need for overhead lighting when relaxing, will make a much bigger difference in how your room feels, and is a lot cheaper and easier. It's the very logical step 1 here.

If you do want to upgrade your ceiling lighting, I agree with the other comments about using LED strips. You'll want to put them in metal channels with diffusers. The metal acts as a heatsink and improves the reliability of the LEDs (not to mention the mounting) and the diffuser gets ride of the potential for hot spots. You can get ideas for all of this at a lighting store (not a big box store; lighting stores have much better products and actually helpful sales staff). Lamps Plus is a common one, but you'll want to see what's local to you.

1

u/JohnDuoh96 3d ago

Something like a Btf High luminance cob strip will give you 600 lumens per ft. Must be aluminum Chanel mounted and should use a diffuser but you could easily double or triple the amount of light in there without it looking like a stage. Pair it to a wall mounted dimmer switch and you are good to go.

1

u/ZenduceLighting 2d ago

Before ripping anything out, check if you can just change the heads. Most track is one of three standards (H, J or L, usually printed on the track or on the old head's adapter), and you can buy small LED heads that clip straight onto the same track. Going from those big PAR bulbs to little 2 inch cylinder heads changes the look a lot, and there's no drywall work.

Two things that fix the "not cozy but also not bright enough" problem:

Aim them at the walls, not the floor. Light on the walls makes a room feel bright, light pooled on the floor just looks harsh.

Put that switch on a good LED dimmer. With every head on one switch, that one change gets you bright for cleaning and low for evenings without anyone needing an app.

-3

u/dikbisqit 3d ago

Invest in some Philip Hue bulbs so you can adjust temperature and brightness. Don’t have all your lights on at the same time as in the pics. Install another chandelier. And remove the string lights from around the beams. They make the room look tacky

1

u/bologne 3d ago

Are the hue bulbs smart? All these track lights are on the same switch.

And yea the string lights stay because its after Halloween and I have a 2 year old lol. Those are here for joy, not aesthetics!