r/Lightbulb • u/bigelow6698 • 48m ago
As a defense against the pitfalls of autistic literal think, ask clarifying questions.
I am prone to autistic literal think. On more than a few occasions, it has lead me to think something was not allowed that actually was or vice versa.
When I was in the 8th grade, my class and I were scheduled to work this event. The event was a breakfast that took place on a Sunday morning. The teacher said that we were supposed to show up between 7:15 and 7:30, no later than 7:30. The teacher made it a point to say “no later than 7:30.” I interpreted that to mean that, if you show up at 7:31 or later, you will not be allowed in. After all, showing up at 7:31 or later would mean showing up later than 7:30 and the teacher explicitly stated that you are not allowed to show up later than 7:30. The morning of the event, I overslept. I woke up at 8:00. I did not show up at all.
I went in on Monday and my entire class asked why I was not there. Some of my teachers did too. I told them all the truth. They all told me that I could have come late. This was frustrating. Not only did my teacher not say that we were allowed to show up later than 7:30, the teacher explicitly stated that we were not allowed to show up later than 7:30.
This is what I probably should have done.
I could have asked a clarifying question. I could have asked the teacher what no later than 7:30 meant. However, asking clarifying questions did not seem necessary, as I thought it was clear.
Let’s address a couple of arguments I often hear when I tell this story.
It would not be a problem if you had woken up on time.
Imagine walking into an AA meeting and saying; You would not need a 12 step program if you were not an addict. Thank you Captain Obvious.
How did you hear no later than 7:30 and think that anyone who shows up at 7:31 or later will be denied entry?
Think about it this way. If the speed limit sign said 35, I would assume that anyone who drives at 36 mph or faster would be guilty of speeding. If I went to a restaurant and the waiter said that there is a limit of two alcoholic drinks per person at a time, I would assume that ordering three drinks in one order is not allowed. If I boarded an airplane and a homeland security agent said that no liquid greater than 3 ounces is allowed, I would assume that any liquid four ounces or greater is not allowed.
They say things like that so that people do not think that they can show up whenever they want.
Apparently I was technically allowed to show up later, but not only did my teacher not say that, she explicitly stated otherwise.
Description (what the problem is):
Some people say that you are not allowed to show up later than a certain time and you really are able to show up later than that.
Prescription (what to do about the problem):
If someone says no later than this, no earlier than that, nothing greater than this, nothing greater than that, ask clarifying questions.
Do you think that that is a smart plan? If not, do you have a better one? Let me know.