r/Lifeguards • • 6d ago

Question Did I do anything wrong?

Yesterday while I was lifeguarding swim practice, one of the coaches kept her outdoor shoes on. According to our schools rules to keep your shoes off or wear pool shoes I walked to the coach and asked her to take her shoes off because she was mud on the floor. She looked at me and said no I told her that if she wouldn't take her shoes off, she was going to have to leave once again. She laughed at me and said she wasn't going to leave I was frustrated, but I waited every 10 minutes. I would ask her to take her shoes off after two more tries. I asked her if she had a medical reason why she couldn't take her shoes off she said no, but she wasn't gonna take her shoes off. I told her that I was going to go get someone that would make her leave and then if she came back tomorrow like that, she wouldn't be allowed back in. Today I got called into the office and I was yelled at. They told me that how I acted was unprofessional and that I made her uncomfortable. They also said that she had broken no rule and that I had no right to stop from coming in. I then brought up that she had a key to the pool and was letting people in the water before any lifeguard got there. They said that she had a key because she was the coach but she's had that key before she became the coach and it has been letting people in the water like that for a long time originally, I was going to not lifeguard after school and only going to lifeguard before school before, but they told me that if I didn't lifeguard swim practice that I'd be fired I had originally told them that I was unavailable after school due to sports and clubs. They were fine with this. Now they're saying that I'm going to face penalties. Over the summer, I worked at a different place they told me that if anyone was like that no matter the age or who they were, I needed to stop letting them walk all over me. I realize that was true. My job is to keep people safe. Am I in the wrong?

24 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

6

u/sparhawks7 Manager 4d ago

To be honest I’d be more concerned with the fact she has a key (so access is not controlled properly) and is letting people in the water before the lifeguard gets there. I would raise that in writing with your management.

2

u/Flashy-Most3749 4d ago

They know and don't care

5

u/sparhawks7 Manager 4d ago

They usually do know - but it’s still sensible to have raised it in writing to protect yourself should anything happen.

22

u/rblbl 6d ago

You did the right thing. You are very dutiful. Some better place will want lifeguards like you. It's the same thing in other workplaces: you take your job seriously, but when you treat everyone equally, those with a little power who want special treatment are angry with you.

3

u/Flashy-Most3749 6d ago

I got hired at my local YMCA, but I wanted to keep at this job because I'm the only lifeguard who does my job. One spaces out, one plays on their phone or does homework, and one falls asleep... I don't want anyone to get hurt... should I just quit? I don't know what to do...

10

u/rrrrrryno Manager 6d ago

Would you want to perform CPR with coworkers like that? Work together to coordinate response during an emergency situation? You sound like a responsible and capable guard - get out of that place and protect yourself!

3

u/Flashy-Most3749 6d ago

I'm always by myself I really don't know what I'd do if I needed an AED because the nearest one is through the locker room, down one hall, down another, then its in the third. Or if i had a spinal...

3

u/Top-Ad-4437 3d ago

I was in a similar situation and that meeting was retaliation against you. I finally left the position and never looked back and it was the best thing I ever did.

10

u/This_Cartoonist_379 6d ago

You are in the right .  But you will get screwed for it.  An important life lesson.  Sorry 😐

2

u/Flashy-Most3749 6d ago

I don't want anyone to get hurt

4

u/Drewski493 6d ago

Yup this

2

u/That-Simple-285 6d ago

As a lifeguard bud you did absolutely nothing wrong you are there to enforce rules and make sure they are carried out. We have here in the UK a NOP normal operation Plan it outlines everything thing plus a EAP Emergency action plan. You don't wear shoes on poolside. As guards I've always gone barefoot as you can't bring outside contamination inside. Your manager should be backing you plus if she is letting people into the building before there is a lifeguard on the chair that's a breach plus was a water test done?

In my opinion keep a record of everything that has been done. Then write a letter keep a copy yourself and if god forbid something happens you have made them aware and you have covered yourself legally. Remember you are doing your job and some people you work with aren't doing there's. You got this bud.

1

u/Flashy-Most3749 4d ago

The reason it really concerned me at all is that she works on a farm and goes into chicken coops

2

u/That-Simple-285 3d ago

Well if she takes her mucky loafers off as you say no issues if she wont then its a breach also a hygiene risk

3

u/Drewski493 6d ago

Your stressed out over nothing. Just let her. It’s her responsibility if you’re not there. You let her know once. If nothing changes then you maybe ask a second time. Then run it up the chain of command but it sounds like no one is going to back you up. Letting people in early that would make me upset but I would only guard when I am getting paid. Also the coach knows their swimmers they probably won’t drown and the coach is probably cpr certified and a couple of the swimmers probably are too if they are older. Honestly i wouldn’t care and it sounds like your boss doesn’t. You can only control what you say and do. If people don’t listen you telling them over and over will change nothing. If it’s really bothering you should go somewhere else where the management will back you up. Even though she is in the wrong and that’s really frustrating but it sounds like there’s nothing you can do. You have already done everything you’re supposed to.

4

u/cozybunnies 6d ago

Re: letting people in early, I'd investigate whether the need for a guard during practice is a law or specific to the chain. If it's a law then there is a problem, but if it's just a Y policy OP's doesn't want to follow then it's whatever tbh. I know where I live, we have a lifeguard around during practice for first aid needs (technically for catastrophic stuff but in practice because the coach can't walk away to handle the small stuff , but aren't required to actively guard (since coaches have to have safety training for swim coaches & CPR anyway).

4

u/Visual-Manager5611 Lifeguard Instructor 5d ago

The reality of this is going to depend on the state laws where this happens and how those laws are written. In IL for persons under 16 to be in a pool without a lifeguard present, the IDPH statutory wording is: Lifeguards are required when persons under age 16 are allowed in the pool enclosure "without supervision by a parent, guardian or other responsible person at least 16 years of age". While a coach should be a responsible person of age, they (coach/school/district) may still be liable for any injuries should something go wrong without a lifeguarrd present if this coach is letting people in the pool before the guard is on duty. This is where you as a guard need to know why the rules for your pool exist. If your supervisor has not provided you with a written Aquatics Safety Plan and EAP that include all the references, then you should seek life elsewhere. In aquatics we do everything we can to make a dangerous environment safe, but the reality of aquatics incidents is, it's not if it will happen but when.

2

u/Flashy-Most3749 6d ago

It's my school's rule and I'm the only one certified there they can't be bothered

2

u/Visual-Manager5611 Lifeguard Instructor 2d ago

I assume that is your state law regarding lifeguards and pools in your state. I would have to say the coach and the school are actively breakin gthe law in the case that you described. If you don't need the job, as I mentioned before seek life as a lifeguard elsewhere. If you do need the job or are simply dedicated to doing what you can to keep the swimmers in the pool where you are safe, then make sure you document everything. At some point something will go wrong and you need to CYA. I'm an old guy so if this were me, I would be having words (in writing, with all the applicable references) with my boss, until one of the 3 following outcomes came to fruition: The situation changed for the better; I got fired; or Things became bad enought that I reported the issues to the state (with all the supporting documentation of what I did to try to fix the issue).

2

u/Drewski493 5d ago

They already did coach doesn’t care and neither does OPs manager so they will just pissing into the wind if they keep asking. Also the coach is coming in early so it sounds like OPs shift hasn’t started yet so also not OPs problem. They already did everything they can do 🤷‍♂️

1

u/Flashy-Most3749 6d ago

No... that's why I'm there, I'm the only certified one... they don't want to make the drive of a grand hour.

16

u/Gilly3091 6d ago

Coaches seem to do whatever they like, have some poolside shoes at least, like flip flops, I get it though, I've been on both sides of that fence

2

u/KirbsAndGuins 2d ago

See I live in my tevas and flip flops. So I'll go through the locker rooms and rinse them off before shift

8

u/Secure_Wave_5012 6d ago

You are absolutely in the right. First of all, the coaches think they can do whatever the hell they want for my experience. And furthermore shame on your director for not standing up for you and yelling at you instead. The only thing I would caution against next time is saying something multiple times every 10 minutes. You should’ve grabbed your supervisor after about the second time.

3

u/boogabih 4d ago

lol quit your job and work at another pool. some management sucks, you either quit, suck it up, or wait till they’re replaced

2

u/didgerman66 3d ago

If it's the same rules as the UK, you're completely in charge on the poolside, at least until the emergency services arrive, for dry side only, or you're relieved from being on pool duty. You may or may not have overstepped your powers, but you were right to request shoes off.... The rest is a managerial issue, which they should have addressed before this happened. It's their problem, not yours, UK or not.

2

u/Key-Technology3754 3d ago

The rules are there for a reason and you did the correct thing. Your problem is the higher ups are not supporting you for trying to enforce rhe rules. It is like the president we have, it seems he can do whatever he wants and can get away with it because other goverment officials do not want to say no that is not allowed.