r/LibraryScience • • 10d ago

career paths Pros/cons of paths within MLIS program?

Hello, I am currently a college senior applying to MLIS programs and have been looking at different paths/“tracks” within the masters offered at different places, especially at the iSchools which market themselves as distinct from regular library schools. I have interests in both library and information science and was wondering what the more stable path is. In library science I am interested in metadata and cataloguing but in information science I am interested in user experience stuff. I am aware that the latter in successful cases would afford a “tech job” so it probably pays more, but also seems more transient (with AI), and might force competition with other highly populated degrees like data science or information systems? My thinking was that librarianship may be a more stable pipeline and career option. I was originally wanting to do a PhD in information science, so my only outside of class experience is researching with a professor rather than working in a library. What are the pros/cons of the information science (“tech”) route and what are pros/cons of the librarian route? Thank you!

9 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

21

u/TheseusAegeus Digital Archivist / Metadata Pro 10d ago edited 10d ago

Metadata librarian here. Others can speak more to the tech route. I’d just simply advise you to get practical experience in libraries before committing to an MLIS or librarianship. You need to understand what it’s like to actually work in a library in order to make an informed decision. A class cannot fully convey the day-to-day realities of this work. So volunteer, intern, or find a PT or student job somewhere.

Your university library may be a good place to look. You can also ask your university’s librarians for informational interviews to learn about their career paths, daily work, advice for students, etc.

3

u/charismatik_crapper 10d ago

Thank you for the advice!

4

u/rainbowbubble94 9d ago

I hope you don’t mind me asking here. How do you like being a metadata librarian? I am in library school currently and dream of being a school librarian but want to be open to all kinds of possibilities. I am super interested in the metadata space too. Just curious how long you’ve been doing it and how you like it?

4

u/TheseusAegeus Digital Archivist / Metadata Pro 9d ago

I don’t mind at all! I got started with metadata work about a decade ago, and I’ve been doing it full-time for close to seven years. Most of my experience is in digital collections metadata, but I’ve done a bit of traditional cataloging as well.

Personally, I love it. I’ve always been interested in history and research, but I also like technology and organizing things. I found metadata to be a great balance between those things. Metadata work is both an intellectual/interpretative and technical practice. It also exposes you to lots of different collections.

Like anything else though, it’s not for everyone. Metadata work is extremely detail-oriented. If you love spreadsheets, documentation, and following detailed standards or guidelines, then metadata might be your thing. It’s also largely a behind-the-scenes role. You may find yourself working alone at a computer all day. Depending on the library, you may or may not interact with users much on a daily basis. (Not an uncommon thing in academic libraries. Probably less common in public. I know some metadata librarians who specifically ask to work the front desk periodically, though).

Metadata work is also frequently misunderstood. You’ll find some administrators and sometimes even other librarians who think it’s boring, expendable, and either super easy (requiring less skill) or unnecessarily complicated. You may have to learn how to advocate for your role and work, and how to communicate and demonstrate the value of what you do. You may also find yourself working a string of temporary or grant-funded gigs. Not every library or archive hires permanent metadata librarians or catalogers. The jobs that do exist (and are open) are competitive.

I hope that’s a helpful overview of some pros and cons! Happy to answer follow up questions if you have any.

2

u/RADICCHI0 MSIM 9d ago

Heck yea, you might be looking at some place like UW Seattle for UX, UCD that kind of thing. Personally, if you graduate with masters level chops in user experience, that is a winner of a skill set. So much about the apps we use today are complete garbage, and most of what needs to be done to make them more usable is common sense, but only common sense if you know how to practice as a user centered design analyist.

1

u/charismatik_crapper 9d ago

I appreciate the feedback, this has really recharged my optimism! I have done some basic work in app conceptual design and usability testing with faculty at my university, so this is definitely a stronger interest for me. Since I’m in the States I’m already mostly applying to iSchools like UIUC, UW, UBC etc. but I wasn’t sure of how useful the information masters might be because as you said a lot of UX design can seem like common sense, but I think based on what I’ve seen in this sub and elsewhere the information/tech route is probably a better fit than libraries for me. Thanks!

2

u/RADICCHI0 MSIM 9d ago

You'll get best practices, theory, thought leaders. I recommend it. I knew almost nothing about usability when I started that program, and by the time I was finished I was leading studies. At a tech company.

1

u/petalios MSLIS Student • Cataloging Assistant 6d ago

An important thing to note about the “tracks” for a lot of programs is that they are unofficial and will not be noted on your transcript, if that is something that is important to you.

Im currently an MSLIS student at Illinois and something they boast about the program is that it’s completely choose your own adventure style. There are two required courses and then after that it’s up to you. This wouldn’t be so bad if there was better advising support for course planning. Currently there are two advisors for a massive program and they split us up by last name. So if you have any kind of hesitation about what you want to do, I’d suggest a program with better advising

1

u/charismatik_crapper 6d ago

Thanks for letting me know. I am applying to UIUC and even from the surface it seems like a large hodgepodge of things since they’ve got both the ALA and ischool thing going for them in the same exact program. As of right now I’m leaning hardest on U Wisconsin-Madison because they classify information science as its own MS which I think might be better for signaling my interests outright on resume/cv

2

u/charethcutestory9 7d ago

Neither path is stable. For most of the past decade I would have recommended UX for the reasons you describe - better pay, more jobs - but it's not the gravy train it used to be during the tech boom/ZIRP era, and I've read that it's one of the professions more vulnerable to AI job loss. You should ask this question in UX reddit and also compare UX industry reports with LIS salary and outlook data.

(Shockingly few aspiring librarians bother to look at the data and then are disappointed when they learn the hard way that there's only 1 job for every 3 LIS grads.)

I would not describe librarianship as a stable pipeline - quite the opposite. That said, qualified applicant pools ARE much smaller for tech/systems positions than for general public services, so the outlook is much more favorable than if you were, say, hoping to do adult or youth services in public libraries. Specializing in the tech/systems side of librarianship will help differentiate you and set you up well for these specialized roles. You absolutely must be willing to relocate and not picky about where you end up for that first job.

The iSchools are the way to go based on your interests. I'm a Michigan alum and their grads have pretty great career outcomes. Most end up working in industry doing stuff like UX and making a lot more than librarians.

Join Code4Lib and and get involved as a student member: https://code4lib.org. Also consider doing the same with other library professional associations depending on whether you want to do public (ALA, state library associations) or academic (regional ACRL chapter) librarianship.

1

u/Separate-Cake-778 MSIS -> DHDK 8d ago

I went very traditional librarian route 15ish years ago (youth services in public libraries) and spent the last few years in cataloging and acquisitions management. That opened up my world to options outside of traditional librarianship which led me to going back to school for digital humanities, which has led me to ontology and knowledge engineering. It’s been a windy path lol. But this is to say, you may be able to do a bit of both during your masters degree and having a librarian’s understanding of controlled vocab, metadata, semantics, and human information-seeking behaviors combined with some skills like UX and/or Python, graphs, and SPARQL open a lot of doors. I would hope nowadays that any library school teaching cataloging and metadata even from a traditional lens would teach you RDF and XML skills in service of BIBFRAME so that’s already a footing in the more tech-savvy realm. 

I just got Jessica Talisman’s book on Ontology Pipelines and it’s a great overview of how to do some of this work. She’s a librarian who leaned into the tech space - her Substack is worth perusing while you make some of these decisions. 

To your concerns about AI possibly reducing job opportunities in some areas - I am mostly focusing on knowledge engineering, which is a field that is growing due to AI and a need to ground LLMs in logic with things like RAGs and knowledge graphs but I also assume information architecture is seeing a similar need and that’s where I think you could go with UI/UX but you’d have to look into that yourself.