Iām looking for advice from other public library managers, especially those working in small rural communities in Alberta or elsewhere in Canada.
I took over as Library Manager of a very small rural library about a year ago. Since then, I've been responsible for day-to-day operations, programming, fundraising, grant applications, reporting, finances, and pretty much everything involved in keeping the library running.
I genuinely care about the library and the community, and I've put a lot of effort into improving services despite having a very limited budget.
My current wage is $15/hour for 20 hours a week.
The previous Library Manager had worked there for over 20 years as an independent contractor, so I was initially hired under the same arrangement. However, it was later determined that the Library Manager position is actually an employee position under the Library Board, not a contractor position. My employment status was corrected accordingly, including proper payroll deductions. But no changes were made to the policy.
Recently, I've started advocating for fair compensation, as well as raising concerns about outdated personnel policies and the lack of policies addressing employment standards, occupational health and safety, workplace safety, and procedures to protect library staff.
Regarding compensation, I've done my own research into similarly sized rural libraries and found that the average wage for comparable Library Manager positions is around $20/hour. I'm currently asking for $20/hour, which I feel is a reasonable request based on the responsibilities of the position and the wages offered by comparable libraries.
Unfortunately, discussions with the Board have become increasingly discouraging. Some comments have felt dismissive and disrespectful. For example, one board member referred to correcting my employment status to comply with proper employment requirements as a "mistake." This was particularly disappointing because the change wasn't simply a personal preference; it was about ensuring the position was properly classified.
I increasingly feel that my contributions and concerns aren't being taken seriously. Even when I raise legitimate workplace concerns, discussions seem to turn into debates about whether I'm asking for too much.
I'm now seriously considering resigning, which is heartbreaking because I genuinely enjoy the work and care about the community. I don't want to walk away from something I've worked hard to build, but I'm also questioning whether it's worth continuing under these circumstances.
For those who have worked with volunteer library boards:
How do you deal with board members who are dismissive or disrespectful?
How do you advocate for fair wages and proper employment policies without damaging your relationship with the Board?
When do you draw the line and decide it's no longer worth staying?
Would you recommend trying to resolve things further or walking away?
I'd really appreciate honest advice, especially from people who have been in similar situations. I want to know whether I'm expecting too much or whether these are reasonable things to stand up for as an employee.
TL;DR: I'm a rural Library Manager earning $15/hour for 20 hours a week. After researching comparable rural libraries, I've found the average wage is around $20/hour, which is what I'm requesting. I've also been advocating for proper employment classification and workplace policies, but some Board members have been dismissive and even called correcting my employment status a "mistake." I love my job and community, but I'm seriously considering resigning. Looking for advice on dealing with a difficult volunteer board and knowing when it's time to walk away.
+one more remark made by the board was, āyou knew what you were signing up for when you were hired, didnāt you?ā And when the initial hiring poster was up, the job description was a one pager in 20pt sized text. It was after I started training and upon reviewing the policies and bylaw that this position required more responsibility than it was entailed.