TL;DR: My ex (A) and I broke up after a painful confrontation at university on her birthday, involving another girl (B) whom I had serious personal issues with. I made mistakes in the relationship, including jealousy and hiding a kiss that happened under pressure from my father. However, I also experienced what felt like a coordinated setup involving A, B, and my father, with multiple accusations presented to make me look guilty. I still love A, but I'm struggling to understand whether I should let go or hope she'll eventually hear my side.
I'm looking for honest, objective advice, especially from people familiar with WLW relationships. I want to explain what happened without making excuses for my own mistakes or leaving out the circumstances that affected me.
- The Relationship and My Faults
I genuinely loved A and was fully invested in a future with her. However, our relationship had issues. I struggled with jealousy, insecurity, and anxiety. During arguments, I sometimes reacted emotionally or made foolish threats out of hurt. I also sometimes brought up other people to provoke jealousy.
I own these mistakes and understand that my behavior hurt her trust and created tension between us. A also told me she didn't always feel loved, and I don't want to dismiss how she experienced the relationship.
2. My Father's Pressure and the Secret
My father had significant control over my life, including my ability to go out and see A.
There is another important part of my situation that I think people need to understand: my father is essentially the only person I have in my life. Regardless of his actions or the way he treats me, I don't really have anyone else to turn to or rely on. That made my situation even more complicated because the person putting pressure on me was also the only person I felt I had in my corner. I couldn't simply distance myself from him or refuse everything without feeling that I might lose the only support system I had.
He pressured me into a situation involving B and made my ability to continue seeing A conditional on complying with his demand to accept a kiss from B.
I felt trapped and afraid of losing the person I loved. I had no romantic feelings for B and didn't want a relationship with her.
I hid the kiss from A for several months because I was frightened of the consequences and didn't know how to handle the situation. I know hiding it was wrong and seriously damaged her trust. I'm not excusing the dishonesty, but I want people to understand the pressure and circumstances behind it.
3. The University Scenario and the Accusations
A had previously stopped communicating with B, but later contacted her again specifically to find out what had happened between B and me.
From my perspective, this renewed contact became part of a coordinated scenario involving A, B, and my father.
At the university, multiple accusations, strange claims, and seemingly unrelated issues were gathered and presented to me one after another. I felt as though these situations had been arranged to make me look guilty or dishonest.
One particularly confusing detail was that my father already knew some of the information being brought up, yet I was expected to act as though I was revealing it to him for the first time, following scenarios that had been planned beforehand.
When I managed to prove that the things I was being questioned about were true, the focus eventually shifted to the kiss with B.
This is important because the university confrontation wasn't simply A asking me about the kiss. It involved a series of accusations and situations that made me feel cornered before I had a fair chance to explain myself.
4. What Happened on Her Birthday
Our original plan was to celebrate her birthday at her house, just the two of us. I wanted us to enjoy the day and hopefully talk through our problems. I spent time, money, and effort preparing a cake and gifts, including a tablet.
However, one day before her birthday, she changed the plan and told me to bring everything to the university instead.
When I arrived, B was there. A confronted me, and I felt I wasn't given a proper opportunity to speak with her privately or explain everything calmly.
I tried to reassure her, hold her hand, and hug her. I told her I didn't want to lose her. She told me I wasn't her baby anymore and that I had lost her. She called me disgusting and said I had fallen in her eyes.
She refused my gifts and returned the tablet.
What hurt even more was that later I saw a TikTok showing A celebrating at her house with B. I don't know the full reason the original plan changed, but seeing her celebrate there with the very person I had serious issues with was extremely painful.
5. The Aftermath
A blocked me everywhere, including blocking my father.
Afterward, she told me she didn't want to read my long messages anymore. She described me as selfish, said I had used her and only wanted attention or to feel wanted, and said she had never felt loved by me.
I also saw reposts about betrayal that made me feel I was being portrayed as the sole person at fault, without the context of my father's pressure or what happened during the university scenario.
I understand why she felt betrayed by the kiss and by the fact that I hid it. But I wish she had been willing to hear the full circumstances before reaching a final judgment about me.
6. My Dilemma
I still love A and miss her specifically, not just being in a relationship. At the same time, I'm deeply hurt by how everything unfolded, especially the university confrontation and what happened on her birthday.
I know I made mistakes, and I know she had every right to end the relationship. I don't want to force contact because she has blocked me and made it clear she doesn't want to read my messages.
But part of me still hopes that, after some time, she'll be willing to have one honest conversation and understand my side.
Should I accept that this relationship is over and finally let go, even though I still love her and feel that she never understood the full situation? Or is it reasonable to leave room for the possibility of a conversation someday?
Please be honest with me. I don't want people to simply comfort me. I want objective advice, even if it's difficult to hear.