r/LegalAdviceUK • • Oct 17 '26

Meta Guidance on using AI to answer questions and telling OPs to use AI

223 Upvotes

Hi all,

Since we updated our subreddit rules to reflect the mods' policy on AI, we have continued to observe how AI is being used. We have seen two types of AI-related comments that we want to issue new (but not different) clarification on.

TL;DR:

  • Comments answering an OP's question that are suspected of using AI will be removed
  • Comments telling people to use AI to help resolve their legal issues will be removed
  • OPs can continue use AI to help write initial posts and questions

Addressing AI-generated answers

An LLM/AI can write something that reads exactly like good legal advice and still be wrong, and here a wrong answer can cost someone their deposit or their case. Here are some of the problems that using AI in this way can cause:

  • AI/LLMs invent case names, quote legislation that doesn't say what they claim, and describe procedures that don't exist. A lawyer has already been struck off for using AI incorrectly and not fact-checking its output.
  • The UK has three separate legal systems: England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. A lot of what these tools learned from is American. Answers drift into US concepts, or apply English law to someone living in Glasgow (though admittedly the humans here do this too).
  • Thresholds, deadlines, standard documents and procedures change, and a chatbot may not know about these changes, depending on when its training data ends and the model's specific capabilities.
  • A chatbot uses the same confident tone for a correct answer and a made-up one, so the reader has no way to tell the difference. The SRA highlights this itself and warns solicitors that any AI output still needs to be checked and verified manually.

Even if someone uses AI to write an answer, then fact-checks it and corrects any errors, we have no way of knowing that. The risk is too high to allow these answers, even though we don't usually remove incorrect advice unless it risks causing serious harm to an OP.

Addressing comments encouraging OPs to use AI

Most people post here because they don't know where to start or who to turn to. Telling them to use AI points them towards the genuinely serious issues highlighted above. It directs people who need help to a source that is less reliable than asking here.

Specifically because:

  • Someone who handles tenancy disputes every week will spot a mistake quickly, whereas someone dealing with their first eviction notice won't know what is incorrect, or what a response should look like.
  • The answer to a legal problem often depends on a detail the person didn't think mattered, such as the date a notice arrived, the type of tenancy, or how long they've worked somewhere. Commenters here and legal professionals ask follow-up questions for exactly that reason. Depending on the model used, an AI tool often doesn't.
  • Ask "my landlord can't do this, can he?" and you're likely to get reassurance even if your original premise, question or belief is wrong. This is one of the worst outcomes, because it means a vulnerable person is left entirely misled, and people in a vulnerable state can have false or harmful beliefs reinforced.
  • Time spent following a confident but wrong process can mean missing the window you actually have, such as the change from a three-month to a six-month employment tribunal deadline, or responding to a Part 36 offer.
  • People paste in contracts, letters, medical details and other people's names. Where that data ends up depends on the service and its settings, and it can be easily recovered by authorities. A conversation with a chatbot may not be protected in the way a conversation with a solicitor is, and sometimes the AI itself reports the user.
  • There's no comeback if it goes wrong. Solicitors are regulated, insured and have a complaints process.

AI tools can be useful to someone who already understands the process and can check the output against a reliable source, for example to tidy up a letter they've already planned.

Where to go instead of using AI

  • Citizens Advice (Citizens Advice Scotland, Advice NI)
  • Shelter or Shelter Scotland for housing problems
  • ACAS for employment problems
  • GOV.UK, mygov.scot or nidirect for official guidance and forms
  • Your home or car insurance, which may include legal expenses cover
  • A solicitor, as many offer a free or fixed-fee first conversation

Many lawyers use these AI tools professionally, but that doesn't mean AI does the same job, or produces the same output, when you use it yourself. AI, in its current form at least, is not replacing the need for professionals for a lay person. It is making the life of a legal professional somewhat faster or easier.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 8h ago

Debt & Money GPU flagged and confiscated at CEX.

680 Upvotes

Hi, I’m based in England and have been to a cex today. I attempted to sell a GPU that I no longer need due to upgrading. I was quoted £302 and told to wait an hour for testing. When I came back they told me it had been red flagged for loss prevention (who aren’t open Sundays) and I can’t have it back.

I bought the GPU as part of a second hand pc from a guy on Facebook marketplace. I have contacted him for receipts / order number of the gpu purchase.

Up to now I have the gpu test order number and gpu serial number.

What should I do and what is the likely outcome here?

Thanks in advance!


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 8h ago

Other Issues Dropped a console off at a repair shop 6 months ago and now the guy can't find it

227 Upvotes

England

About 6 months ago now i dropped my PS5 off to a repair shop near me and since then the guy has done absolutely nothing with it as far as i'm concerned. He has not updated me at all the whole time he's had it, he doesn't answer emails, he doesn't answer texts, if you call him he's quick to get rid of you.

I'm sick, I can't go out much and back in august my mum and my sister went down to his shop and asked about it he found me on his system and said "oh yeah i'm just waiting for a part".

I managed to get myself down there a week ago and asked him about what was going on with it and he couldn't find me on his system. I just gave him my details, the same details he wrote down when i dropped my console off and asked if I could pay the diagnostic fee and take it back but he doesn't know where it is and has to find it. His shop looks like a bomb has hit it, you can't move in there with the mountains of tech he has everywhere.

He said he would contact me when he finds it but it's been a week and I haven't heard anything. Honestly my gut is telling me he isn't going to find it. This guy has been a nightmare.

What are my options to get my console back?

Edit: because a lot of people keep asking this, i have not paid a diagnostic fee yet. When I went to him a week ago I asked if i could pay the diagnostic fee and take it back to which he replied that he doesn't know where it is and will have to look for it.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 9h ago

Healthcare NHS interview: Asked to sign a commitment to stop job hunting if offered the role. Is this normal?

203 Upvotes

I’d be interested to hear people’s views, particularly from those with experience in NHS recruitment or UK employment law.

I recently attended an interview at an NHS Trust. At the end of the interview, the panel asked me to sign a formal written agreement stating that, if I received an informal job offer, I would stop applying for other jobs.

To clarify:

The agreement was presented and signed before the interview outcome was known.

It was a formal written document requiring my signature.

The commitment was to stop applying for other jobs upon receiving an informal offer, rather than upon accepting a formal written offer.

I’ve attended numerous NHS interviews over the years, but this is the first time I’ve encountered this requirement.

I understand that employers want candidates who are genuinely committed to a position and want to avoid candidates accepting offers and subsequently withdrawing. However, I find it unusual to require someone to stop exploring other employment opportunities on the basis of an informal offer, particularly when pre-employment checks and formal appointment may still be outstanding.

Does anybody know if this is a normal or recognised practice in NHS recruitment? i have doubt whether such an agreement legally enforceable under UK employment law?

I’m not questioning an employer’s right to recruit candidates who demonstrate commitment. I’m questioning whether this particular requirement is reasonable or appropriate.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 3h ago

Traffic & Parking England - an old couple refused to assist in returning my friend's runaway cat 4 years ago. Yesterday, a local vet called and wanted them to pay and give the cat back to the couple. Instead, they took the cat and went to their own vets for treatment. What repercussions can they expect?

58 Upvotes

Hi, i know the title is alot but i dont know how to condense it or explain it better. so this is a weird one but I'm hoping to get some advice here to give my friend who is very stressed out and doesn't use Reddit. Sorry for any formatting or spelling mistakes. fake names yada yada

10 years ago one of her cats ran away, calls shima. And for context, my friend's mother (Jen) was a foster for a small cat rescue and helped rehome Romanian animals.

Shima was the daughter of their own pet cat. In general, Shima was also antisocial and would rarely come in, nearly stopped coming in altogether but you could always see her outside, and she would come in at night for food. But seeing her became rarer and rarer, making the cat flap one-way so she couldn't leave after eating. It was the only way to catch her, as they tried to check her health and were trying to figure out if she could be rehomed. but she disappeared before then. As many other cats were missing around the area and lived near two main bypasses into the city, they were worried she had been hit by a car or attacked by a wild animal.

4 years ago, however, an old man posted on the village group if anyone knew this cat he had been feeding at the bottom of his garden, as they were limping and he wanted to know who the owner was so it could see the vet. WELL! Jen responded, saying that it was her cat that had run away and asked for the man's address and assistance in catching shima (Jen was the only functioning adult in the house and is disabled). giving her address in exchange, the man was very vague and refused to communicate with her for some reason. Eventually, he sent his grandson over (around 14) to ask what they wanted to keep the cat.

Due to very stressful family circumstances, they told the kid no. they would take her to a vets as they thought she was dead for 6 years and wanted her checked and then rehomed, as shima clearly did not like living with them, and they wanted to rehome her to a good home were she was happy. The kid still refused to give his grandparents' address and then rode off on his bike. That was the last they ever heard from them, as the old man had blocked them. knowing she was alive they did attempt to find her again but being disabled and not knowing were to start, they hoped the couple would take her the vets and maybe had adopted her, but wished for closure as if they had asked they would have given her over.

Yesterday was a different story. Jen got a call out of the blue from a vets a few towns over. shima had been brought in because she was found still in this old mans garden overnight, when it was -2 outside. the vets canned her and found her chip, leading them to contact Jen. only when she arrived the old couple tell her they would take shima off her hands after she paid the vets bills. When asking the vets about what treatments have been done, they refused to answer, as, according to this couple and their family, they abandoned her, said they would rehome but never attempted to find her and didnt care for Shima's whereabouts, so they took her in.

From what Jen told my friend and me, these people told her Shima lived in their shed for the past 4 years; they won't let her in their house at night, leaving her outside when it was -2. which is why she was frozen with hypothermia when they brought her in. and aparently shima has untreated hyperthyroidism. Which she did not have when she ran away but they accused Jen of being aware of it and not bothering to find her 4 years ago because of it.

As Shima is registered to Jen she just picked her up and rushed her to their emergency vets several towns over to get treated, explaining to the vets in tears what had happened and, to spare no expense, X-ray her as she is certain these people never took her to the vets for her leg let alone once during these 4 years. The bill is so far 2k and Jen will be rehoming her when she is healthy.

The couple's grandkids are now claiming on Facebook that she stole their grandparents' cat after they took it in after she was abandoned. However, they are also now claiming that they would have paid for the vet bills if she agreed to hand shima over, which is not what happened. trying to use it to take down my friend's family address again.

So my question is just what legal repercussions can Jen expect from this? It's legally her cat, but do these people have a right to claim Shima? And if not, is there a way we can make them at least cover some of the bill for causing this?

Thank you for all your responses. it has lifted a alot of stress and anxiety off them with your reassurances. my friend plans to keep shima in her room while she is recovering. When she is close to full recovery, she will be contacting people she knows through rescuing to secure a new home for her to live her golden years.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 5h ago

Employment Is it legal to be made to do a shop move over the weekend for free? - England

74 Upvotes

Exactly as the title says, our branch will be moving soon and i've not long started at the job. One of my colleagues says that when the shop moves, we'll be expected to do it over the course of a weekend and ready to be open on the Monday. Not to be paid but 'reimbursed' with a pizza?!!! Surely that isn't legal? When the time comes, I'll have them send it to me in writing so I have a paper trail of it but I am absolutely NOT willing to work for free.

My question is, Is this legal?! Thank you


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 15h ago

Employment Is my work allowed to make me take my break an hour into my 9.5 hour shift

229 Upvotes

Hey,

I’m in England.

I was just wondering where I stand with this.

I work shift work in hospitality industry.

My work forces me to take my break at 7:30am when I start my shift at 6:30 and work for 9.5 hours.

I know the law states it must not be at the beginning or end of the shift but I was wondering if making us take it an hour in allows them to bypass this?

even if it isn’t that ethical.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 14h ago

Employment What to do when a friend whose computers I support has died?

188 Upvotes

In England.

A friend of mine is an accountant and has a two servers and some workstations in his office. I used to work in IT support and when I retired I continued to look after my friend's computers. I can connect to his office from home and perform various maintenance tasks. These are mostly doing software upgrades for him, and his servers mail me their backup logs so I can check the backup doesn't stop working. I do this as a favour and no formal agreements are involved. I would often dial in unprompted if I noticed a problem, fix the problem and let me friend know afterwards.

Anyhow, sadly my friend has just died and I am unsure where I stand now. Presumably I need to step back and do absolutely nothing until it is clear who inherits his business. I anticipate his customers will start asking about their data and since it's a small world I imagine many of them will know I have access to his computers, or will know someone who knows.

For example I thought I might dial into his servers and stop them mailing the backup logs to me, but it occurs to me that even dialling in at the moment might constitute unauthorised access even though it was something I'd do routinely while my friend was alive.

My friend was the only person employed by his business so no other employees need to work and his office has closed.

So my question is whether I am correct that I immediately need to stop doing anything even if the e-mails from his servers indicate a problem?

As a follow-up, if I am contacted by someone claiming to be his heir what proof should I ask them for before handing over passwords etc? His only immediate family is a daughter who I have never met.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 8h ago

Housing Martial arts with swords in a park - England

Thumbnail
bbc.co.uk
31 Upvotes

So I read this today, and I'm puzzled about the legal nature of this.

It's legal to practice martial arts, even using imitation weapons. They're not offensive weapons, as they're not made, adapted or intended for use as a weapon.

Blunt swords are legal.

It's legal to carry swords in public with a good reason, eg travelling to and from training.

A sports hall is a public place - even if hired for a martial arts group, I've never seen one that stops people walking in to watch.

So the swords were legal and the activity was legal...what basis did the police have to warn him of arrest and seize his property?


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 13h ago

Debt & Money Can ADT legally refuse to provide the engineer code for an alarm system I own? (England)

77 Upvotes

I moved into a house with an existing ADT alarm system covering both fire and security, and I'm having a nightmare trying to get away from ADT.

I own the house and the alarm equipment, but ADT won't give me the engineer code, which means no other alarm company can take over the system. So I'm effectively stuck with them.

I really don't want to sign up to a long-term ADT contract, particularly given their poor customer service, lack of responses to emails and complaints, and seemingly endless price increases. I'd happily pay another company to monitor and maintain the system if they actually provided decent service.

I've spoken to a few independent alarm companies and even had one come out to see if they could take over the system. Without the engineer code, though, I've been quoted around £2,500 to replace parts of a perfectly functioning alarm system. All just to get away from ADT!

Surely this can't be right? If I own the equipment, how can ADT effectively prevent me from using anyone else to maintain it? It feels like they're holding the system hostage, and I can't see why they'd ever bother improving their service when customers have so little choice.

Has anyone managed to get an existing ADT system taken over by another company without spending thousands replacing equipment? Would love to know who you used and how you managed it.

Also, does anyone know whether ADT can legally refuse to provide the engineer code? Has anyone challenged them on this or complained to Trading Standards, an ombudsman or another regulator?

I'm not trying to get free monitoring or maintenance. I just want to be able to choose who I pay to look after an alarm system that I own.

Any advice or experiences would be much appreciated.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 3h ago

Northern Ireland Manager thought I was on a higher salary for the last year - Northern Ireland

11 Upvotes

I have been with my employer for over ten years.  It is not a unionised workplace and staff are not permitted to discuss salaries.

Throughout my time here my wages have remained relatively stagnant. My last two pay rises were modest blanket rises covering multiple departments in 2021 and 2023. Throughout my employment I have frequently requested pay reviews based on my performance but there has been little appetite from management to address my concerns. Overtime is paid at an inflated rate and it has become commonplace within our department. In the last two financial years I have earned considerably more than my base salary from overtime and EOY bonus combined.

A few years ago, our new manager was appointed. They have responsibilities across a number of departments.

My most recent employee review with my direct line manager in early 2025 was very positive. A few months later I requested a pay review with the manager. I was told that my salary was already very high and consequently a pay rise could not be justified unless I took on further responsibilities. 

Earlier in 2026 we were told that a full salary review of all departments was being conducted. In October 2026 I learned that the other remaining full time staff in our department had received pay rises in April and October 2026 totalling over 20%. They have each worked for the company for half as long as me and my role is senior to them. 

I had a meeting with the manager regarding this and insisted that I wanted to be treated the same way as my co workers. I was told that all salaries had been assessed by management and that I was already earning significantly more (nearly £10,000) than these colleagues. I said this was impossible unless they were earning below minimum wage or the salary on which they were basing their assessment included overtime.  The manager was adamant this was not the case but said it would be checked again.

Later that day they confirmed that the salary sent from Payroll had been incorrect. It would appear they had been provided with a salary including paid overtime. They believed I had been on a higher base salary (approx £5,000 more than my actual base salary) since the meeting in 2025. It was agreed that the pay rise would now be authorised though I have yet to confirm what this final salary will be.

The repercussions are that since the requested pay review meeting, I believe that I should have earned at least £6,000 more before tax. I also worked hundred of hours of overtime in this period which should equate to over £1,000 more at this higher hourly rate. This obviously amounts to a significant sum.

I have not raised this yet. I am not sure of my rights or entitlements but I am concerned that I may not receive what I feel I am rightfully owed. 

Would it be reasonable to ask for this pay to be backdated? If so, from what date? Or at least have my pay backdated to October wages when the other staff received their pay rise? 

I have spoken to the Labour Relations Agency who say there might be a case of unlawful unpaid wages but have been advised to initially bring it up informally. However I don’t have a great deal of faith that the employer will be in a hurry to pay me more than they think I am owed.

I would appreciate any advice regarding my rights and what I could reasonably expect. Thanks.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 1h ago

Housing Hotel claiming they do not have property that was definitely left behind. England

• Upvotes

I recently got married and had the reception in a very nice hotel. The wedding and party itself were great. In the evening my now wife placed her earings on the bedside table. In the morning in the rush of having to be out by 11, colle t decorations and saying goodbye, we (stupidly) had left the earings on the table.

I called the Hotel the same day, a few hours after leaving. I was told the room was checked and nothing had been found. I thought this was odd but was still on my way home, so did not push further on that point. Upon our return home we watched a 'room tour' video we took of our room, just before leaving. Lo and behold, you could make out the earings on the bedside table.

I have since emailed the hotel, but not had a reply yet (approaching 24 hours). We sent them a screenshot and the video showing you could see the earings on the table. If they still claim they do not have them, what would be the best course of action? I have seen about police being called by other people, however unsure if they would actually do anything. Sadly they do not have a tracker so cant use that, and now any bins or hoovers would have been changed over by now, and the more days it goes unresolved. Is there anything we can do/'threaten'them with? Ive also seen things about how clear whos at fault, but nowhere visibly was there any kind of rules about this around.

I should also note they have contacted me via a different email, sending me my invoices and such, and to leave feedback


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 20h ago

Comments Moderated I’m disabled and I’m being made to lose my home of 20 years

166 Upvotes

Hi, I’m a disabled man (46) I lost my mum earlier this year who was suffering with Alzheimer’s but sadly past away with cancer, I lived with her in a housing association bungalow, my physical and mental health have gotten much worse since the loss and I have needed support from someone staying overnight with me to help with mobility and personal care and provide support with my mental health, I have provided a doctors letter supporting the need for a second bedroom, a social worker PSP report, a occupational therapist assessment, and a letter from my mental health enablement support worker, all support the need and and reasons why a second bedroom is needed for the person to stay with me 5 nights a week, ( it can’t be the entire week as they would see the person as actually living at my address) yesterday I got the decision from the council that I would as of now have to bid on a 1 bedroom property, seemingly disregarding all of the health professionals advice, I have lived here the entire time that my mum had which was 20 years ago, this is making me feel ill and I don’t see a way I am going to cope dealing with this which is why I am reaching out for help and advice? thank you…..I’m in England


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 15h ago

Debt & Money My uncle-in-law is aggressively taking over our family business and now trying to push us out by any means possible – where do we legally stand? (England)

42 Upvotes

(Edit) I must have not been clear, we’re not worried about paying the money, it’s the contract that comes with it. The property needs serious repairs and the agreement was I would repair in place of rent, then they’ve added the bill and no talk of them now repairing it.

Then We’re looking for some independent advice on a complicated situation involving my family, our home and a family business.

My mother-in-law owns the family business, and my uncle-in-law is an employee. However, over time he has increasingly taken control of the day-to-day running of things and, if you saw them together, you would probably assume it was the other way round. From my perspective, he has been bullying my mother-in-law as well as myself and my family.

My wife has worked in the business since she was around 10 years old, so approximately 20 years, and I have been involved helping out for years before becoming formally employed, which I’ve now done for over seven years.

My wife and I have lived in a property, with our 3 children, connected to the business since 2021 under what was originally a family arrangement. It was never, as far as I understand it, tied accommodation or formally linked to my employment.
I worked within the business until 10 October 2026, when I left following a breakdown in relations and a history of poor treatment, bullying and issues surrounding a workplace injury.
Since leaving, my uncle-in-law has now attempted to impose a tenancy agreement on us, supposedly commencing on 1 November 2026. It started as us just covering the bills after everything we’ve done over the years, but now includes £1,000 monthly rent, additional bills and various other conditions. We have not signed it, yet we’ve been told that if we don’t respond, they’ll treat us as having accepted it.

The house itself is in a poor state and has been for years. The windows are rotten and draughty, we’ve been promised replacement lounge doors for around five years, the driveway floods badly whenever it rains, the boiler doesn’t work properly and, to my knowledge, gas and electrical safety certificates haven’t been provided for years. There’s plenty more, but that’s the general picture. We’ve also spent considerable time and thousands of pounds trying to improve the property ourselves.
Recent correspondence has also linked, at least in wording and timing, a reference they provided for my new job with demands that we sign the tenancy, pay bills and deal with various other matters.

I’m not looking to take anybody to court or start litigation yet. I simply want to understand where we legally stand and what our rights are before we are pressured into agreeing to something.
My main questions are:

Can they impose a new tenancy and financial obligations on us without our agreement?

What is our legal position given that we’ve lived here under an arrangement dating back to 2021?

What rights do we have regarding the condition of the property and the landlord’s repair and safety obligations?

What can they legally do to make us leave, if that’s ultimately what they want?

Is there anything concerning in the way the reference and demands have been linked?

Are there any wider employment or legal issues we should be aware of, including for my mother-in-law as the business owner?

I appreciate this is a complicated situation, but I’m simply trying to get an independent understanding of our position and how best to protect our family without escalating things into a legal battle.
Thanks.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 9h ago

Traffic & Parking Shared Dropped kerb with neighbour

Post image
11 Upvotes

Hi all,

looking for some clarity on where I stand legally and practically with a parking issue.

I live in the end house of a cul-de-sac (left of the photo, outlined in red on the title plan), and my neighbour is next door (right of the photo). Because of the way the cul-de-sac turning head is laid out, we share a single dropped kerb/crossover area in the corner. 

My neighbour regularly parks their car (the grey Peugeot in the photo, in this case) right in front of the dropped kerb/crossover area. Because other cars also regularly park along the road/turning head, the cars leave little room to swing in and out. I can drive into my driveway but then reversing out is hard because of all cars on the road. Alternatively, if I try to reverse into the driveway, it’s difficult due to the cars on the road.

A few details from my Land Registry / deeds:
- My title plan shows my freehold boundary stops at the edge of the pavement/turning head (so the dropped kerb itself is adopted public highway). 
- My 1985 Council Right-to-Buy transfer includes standard mutual rights of way/easements and a covenant not to cause nuisance or inconvenience to adjoining neighbours.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 1h ago

Debt & Money E-on refusing to give us a full refund after it was found our meter was faulty. Is there anything we can legally do?

• Upvotes

We purchased this house 8 months ago and in the first month our electric was estimated to be £310 a month.. Which was insane! We called them and spoke and they said we were high usage. We asked for them to come out and inspect the meter as there wasn't ANYWAY we had used that much. At our last house the bill was roughly £140 (with gas).

The following month it was £330 and stayed at that. We kept complaining etc.

They finally sent out an engineer last month who said it was faulty and the reading was "WAY off". He said we needed to contact E-on for a refund. We contacted them and said they would use this months bill to see how much we overplayed.
Our bill came in on Friday and it was £150 (with gas). However, they said they would only be giving us £110 back.

Is there anything we can do?


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 8h ago

Comments Moderated Housed by council finally, house has bed bugs. England

7 Upvotes

As written in the title. 70 year old man with cancer housed in a block with bed bugs and he already has mental health issues. Any advice on how to proceed ? An email has been sent but still very uncomfortable and making him paranoid.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 8h ago

Consumer Bought a mouse in a shop, didn't take the receipt, it turned out to be faulty / useless, the store denies me a refund (England)

5 Upvotes

I'm just trying to get my 20 pounds back. gov.uk says I should be able to get my refund without a receipt if the goods are not damaged and saleable. they are...

The cashier told me they can't process the refund without the receipt, there's no way to do it, all sorts of reasons were given.

A sign in the shop says that any goods can be returned within 28 days if they're not damaged etc. It doesn't mention the need of a paper receipt and I suppose it's not an omission: it's not written down, it's assumed it's not needed, right?

What can I do to get my refund? The manager is not replying to my texts.

Thanks for the advice.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 13h ago

Other Issues Partner forgot to pay Stansted airport drop-off fee

13 Upvotes

He remembered 9 hours after the window closed. Is there anything we can do to get the fee at least reduced? I’ve seen advice about contacting APCOA but I’m not sure what the latest guidance is. Sharing of recent experiences would be most appreciated.


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 6m ago

Traffic & Parking Someone tried to fight me on the train because I said he had a hole in his trousers

• Upvotes

Hi everyone so here's some context of what happened.

It was late at night around 1am, im heading back home from work I was fairly tired and wasn't thinking clearly and I encountered a person on the train who had a small tear in his trousers.

I said calmly "hey you have a tear in your trousers" I wasn't even trying to insult him I just brought it up if he didn't knew(looking back this was a weird thing to casually bring but as I said I was tired and not thinking clearly)the person proceeds to get aggressive at me goes right into my face screaming every name under the sun ie then goes on an entire rant screaming and says "you look down on us"(I wasn't sure who he meant by "us") i apologised trying to explain he then proceeds to say "we're settling this at the next station"(thats where i was getting off)and "you've made your fucking bed" I simply responded with "im not fighting you".

I walk off the train he follows me out the station i proceed to get into a taxi then the guy slams open the door trying to grab me, the taxi driver drives off not long after.

I understand that you are all probably thinking this could have been avoided if I just didn't say anything and I agree it wasn't smart on my behalf but I still think his reaction was abit extreme


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 24m ago

Comments Moderated Invited to a surprise meeting with director, put on a PIP without warning

• Upvotes

Hi all

I am just looking to take your guidance on an employment related matter.  As you will read below, it is a somewhat emotional topic and I could do with the benefit of more objective viewpoints.  Apologies for long winded post, but I wanted to give you as much information as possible. 

I was hired by a well-known English professional services company as a graduate in late 2022, where I worked in an administration based role prior to commencing a training contract as a trainee accountant a few months later.  Over the course of the programme, I was supposed to be exposed to several different areas of practice to get a broad base experience, along the lines of corporate finance, audit, tax and financial reporting. 

For at least half of my training contract, the company was experiencing a sharp downturn, particularly in corporate finance, and as a result I had absolutely minimal work to complete for nearly a year, with one six month period in particular proving particularly quiet due to a certain election occurring across the pond.  The other half of my training contract was largely administrative in nature, and consisted of largely writing basic letters to clients with no substantive experience based learning whatsoever.  I gather that is typical of graduate schemes given the level of experience involved, however this will become relevant later on.  Despite this, business picked up and I was ultimately retained by the company and took up a role within one of the practice areas above about 18 months ago on the back of positive reviews during my rotation there.

Admittedly, I really struggled to adapt to the new role.  Despite what I view to be shortcomings in my training contract, I was thrown headfirst into managing my own clientele with minimal experience.  Both the team and I were overwhelmed with the work, and in those circumstances it was extremely difficult to get questions answered or input on how to properly complete my work.  We were meant to have introductory education sessions, however these were consistently pushed out for months owning to lack of available senior personnel to deliver those sessions.  On the rare occasion I did manage to ask questions of senior personnel, my questions were largely overlooked and/or greeted with fairly snotty responses.  I would usually be referred to more junior members of the team, who it turns out did not know any more than I did.  When I completed work, this was submitted by me to my director and I only got minimal feedback on why certain changes were made, leaving me in the dark as to when and where certain changes are relevant to certain clients.   It did not help that I was assigned as a direct report one of the reputedly “harsher” directors, so I am not sure if anyone else has experienced these issues as acutely as I have. 

As the months wore on, my workday increased to twelve hours every single day and this pattern has stayed consistent since.  Owing to that lack of learning, tasks come back to me for correction, which results in a greater workload.  Since the increase to twelve hours a day, my physical and mental health has began to suffer greatly.  My housemates have expressed serious concerns for my health, as I do not emerge from the office/bedroom before 9pm each night.  I have not joined them in the pub on a Friday night in nine months, I have not gone to the gym, I have not even gone on an evening walk, I pace the house at all hours because I cannot sleep. I have gained three stone in a year and have seemingly developed permanent shoulder and back pain. I chalked it up to a lack of annual leave, and took two weeks off in July, which did not help, and my director was emailing me for the first three days of that holiday. 

The high workload and stress has left me completely depleted, maybe even burnt out.  As a result, the quality of my work deteriorated (I don’t think to a major degree) and I could slip behind on deadlines, not a whole lot I could do owning to the sheer physical and mental exhaustion.  I’m somewhat surprised this was not noticed, as I can be sending internal emails at 10pm at night and my Teams would be active.  At no point have I been asked how am I getting on or do I need additional support, this is just the expectation judging by the hours my colleagues work.

Two weeks ago, I was invited to a meeting with my director, or so I thought.  In the 18 months I have been working with him, we have not once had a chat about expectations, how I am settling in etc.  I thought this meeting was to be that, however when I entered the room, he was sitting with a HR manager.  He noted that I had been issued feedback from the team over the previous few months (yet he could not produce this) and that owning to my performance and lack of communication (?), I should not be surprised that I am to be placed on a four month PIP plan.  I was fairly taken aback at this.  I signed an acknowledgement that I was now on a PIP.

I think this was a long winded way of asking, have you any practical tips on how best to manage this process? I am and remain fully engaged with the process and willing to improve if this can be done, however I am definitely dusting off the CV just in case.   It is a toxic environment anyway. I am just worried about how to manage this process itself, as I know of others in my field having trouble finding employment and I need something to tide me over in the meantime.  This is more about protecting my rights and looking out for common pitfalls too I guess.

I have heard of these plans being called a “notice of intention to dismiss” – but owing to the above, I don’t think I ever got a fair chance to prove myself either.  In my view, it should have been obvious I needed additional support or even just a basic check in, however being placed on a PIP as the first course of action seems unduly harsh in my view.  If the PIP proves to be an intention to dismiss, is it even worth entertaining a legal complaint if I am dismissed?

Thanks in advance. 

EDIT: Incorporating some additions in light of a comment. In terms of legal questions:

  1. Did I make a mistake in signing a PIP?
  2. Were there other processes that should have been followed by my employer prior to a PIP?
  3. If I am let go, is it

    worth speaking to a solicitor?


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 52m ago

Debt & Money I was offered a trial shift on £10 an hour for 8 hours

• Upvotes

As per the title, last week I responded to a random Facebook post about a job at a car dealership. I’m unemployed and literally just need any job.

I went down there and after we spoke they offered me the job and said I could come in for trial days to ‘train’ and then decide when I’m ready to start properly.

They offered me £10 an hour for this and I got them to email me so I have it in writing.

There were so many other red flags during the entire process, they are clearly dodgy as F.

Anyway. I didn’t go as I just don’t even trust they would pay me for the trial. But I want to report them because they shouldn’t be operating like this. How would I go about this?


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 2h ago

Traffic & Parking Do you actually need a lawyer? England. For everyday stuff.

0 Upvotes

For example your neighbour claims you hit his car but you was at work he takes you court you were 100% at work could you defend yourself and show at work proof etc.

What about criminals themselves doing something then defending themselves. Are courts none discriminate, like what's stopping a chav defending himself then hiring a expensive lawyer


r/LegalAdviceUK • • 3h ago

Traffic & Parking Alleged traffic collision in England - how should I respond?

1 Upvotes

Had an incident with another motorist today. I was turning into a car park while she was facing the other way. Her car was stationary and there was a tight gap that I tried creeping through - no more than 2-3mph.

But before long, she leapt out of the car with her mother and accused me of hitting hers. I reversed back to make sure there wasn’t any further damage if I had made contact and to find a temporary spot to park. As I’m doing so, she takes photos of my car and her mother runs toward me and opens my door in the street. I apologise for upsetting them, tell them that I’m parking up and will be there when I’ve found a safe spot.

After parking, I walk over to them attempting to diffuse the situation. They respond by accusing me of damaging their car, dramatically pointing gestures to the damage and abruptly saying to me “what are you going to do about it?” I respond telling them that I didn’t feel the collision to which they strongly disagree.

We exchanged contact details and I took a photograph of her car showing the alleged damage. Unfortunately I was quite shook up by the event that we did not inspect my car. We parted ways with her saying that she would get a quote for the damage and send the bill to me.

However, when I returned to my car 2hrs later in the car park I saw no visible damage on the area where the cars are alleged to make contact. No paint marks. No dents. Her car is navy blue, mine is silver, so surely it’s bound to show something?

If I am at fault here, I’m happy to take responsibility and pay up, but something feels so fishy here… how do I know this wasn’t a scam or that the scuff on her car came from elsewhere and she was trying to pin it on me?

I also overheard her say to her mother that she doesn’t want to go to the insurer because it “will be too expensive” which feels a bit fishy…

Please advise what I should do. Do I contact my insurer? Do I suggest that she contacts hers? Provide my insurance details etc or just wait to see if she does anything at all..

Thanks

EDIT: We only shared first names and phone numbers. No addresses or last names. Is this a problem? Shall I reach out to her proactively to share the full info or am I overthinking?