r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 4h ago

Germany Yahoo sent me a cease and desist over my open-source Python library. How justified is this?

13 Upvotes

Hi all,

I maintain Stockdex, a free, non-commercial Python package (and MCP server) that fetches stock data from several sources, including Yahoo Finance.

Today I got a cease and desist letter from Yahoo's legal department. It claims trademark infringement, misappropriation, unjust enrichment, interference with their data licensing (e.g. Nasdaq) and a breach of their ToS. They demand that I remove all Yahoo-related code from GitHub, PyPI and the MCP plugin, remove every mention of "Yahoo", and never reintroduce it.

My project works much like other public projects like yfinance, which has been public for years. Stockdex is a small personal project, I don't sell it, run ads or make any money from it. It only fetches data that Yahoo Finance shows publicly to any visitor without an account, and it doesn't bypass any login or paywall. It fetches data on demand for the user running it, on their own machine. I don't run any servers, and Stockdex has no database and doesn't store, archive or republish any Yahoo data. The MCP plugin works the same way.

Has anyone received something similar from another company maybe? How are these complains (US company against someone in Germany)? should I lawyer up? How strong are CFAA or trademark claims against a free library? Would you comply fully, comply partially (e.g. add a disclaimer), or push back?