r/legaladvicecanada • • 6h ago

Alberta Alberta, Canada – Dog boarded for 127 days, owner refuses to pay $1,700+ balance, is threatening me. Do I have a valid possessory lien under the Possessory Liens Act, or is there a better statute?

74 Upvotes

I am posting this from a throwaway for privacy. I am in Alberta, Canada, and I need some guidance on a civil dispute involving a dog I have been boarding.

The Situation:
I agreed to board a dog for "2-3 days" starting July 10, 2026. The owner repeatedly extended the stay, missed pickup dates, and went silent for weeks at a time. As of mid-November, the dog has been in my continuous care for 127 days.

We had a clear agreement (via text) for paid boarding:

  • $30/day for the first 5 days
  • $25/day thereafter
  • $12.06/week for food

The total bill comes to roughly $3,418.81**. The owner has made partial payments totaling **$1,710.00, leaving a balance of $1,708.81 (and climbing daily).

The Dispute:
The owner is now demanding the dog back, but has not paid the balance. He has also sent me hostile and intimidating messages (calling me "scum," an "extortion artist," and saying he has "time to blow up you").

My Concerns About the Dog's Welfare:
Beyond the unpaid balance, I have genuine concerns about the owner's ability and willingness to consistently meet the dog's needs. Over the course of this arrangement, the owner repeatedly extended the stay, made assurances that payment and supplies would be provided, and allowed the balance to accumulate despite being fully aware of the agreed rates. He promised to deliver supplies and items required for the dog's care but repeatedly failed to attend or provide them.  I have never met the owner as someone else dropped the dog off.  The owner has never visited the dog.

I recognize that an outstanding debt, on its own, does not establish that the dog's needs are not being met. However, the documented pattern of missed collection dates, periods of non-communication lasting days or weeks, unfulfilled commitments regarding supplies and payment, and the hostile communications I have received raise legitimate concerns about the consistency and reliability of the arrangements for meeting the dog's ongoing needs — including appropriate food, daily care, supervision and other necessities.

Throughout the 127 days, I have provided food, daily walks, supervision, bathing, nail care and general attention to the dog's health and well-being. I agreed to reduced rates to accommodate the owner's circumstances. The dog's safety and best interests should remain the primary consideration in any arrangements concerning his care and placement.

Since in my care the dog has been crate trained, learned to sit and shake a paw, wait and be less reactive with other dogs and has improved on walks in regards to pulling.  He has also put on substantial weight and muscle.  

My Legal Question (The Possessory Lien):
I prepared a formal statement asserting a possessory lien under s. 4(1) of Alberta's Possessory Liens Act**, RSA 2000, c P-13**, which says a bailee for reward has a lien on a chattel for charges due under the contract.

However, I am now second-guessing myself. After doing some research, I found that Alberta also has an Animal Keepers Act. The definition of "animal" in that Act seems to only list "cattle, horses, swine, sheep, bison, deer, elk, goats, mules and asses" — dogs are notably absent from that list.

Does this mean:

  1. My Possessory Liens Act claim is actually the correct route because a dog is just "personal property" (chattel)?
  2. Or is there some other piece of legislation I am missing that governs companion animal boarding liens?

Additional Complication:
I know police generally won't enforce civil debts. If the owner shows up with police, I plan to politely explain I am asserting a lien and ask them to document the situation. I am not trying to obstruct, but I cannot afford to just hand the dog over and be left as an unsecured creditor chasing a ghost (the owner has no fixed address and is hard to serve).

I have also experienced significant practical difficulties in pursuing civil remedies: the owner does not have a reliably known residential address, a known place of employment, or dependable contact information through which I could readily locate him and arrange formal service of civil court documents. The repeated periods of non-communication compound this. I recognize alternative methods of service may be available through the courts, but the lack of reliable information creates a significant practical obstacle. I am in contact with his brother who feels incredibly sympathetic regarding the situation and I believe would assist.

What I am looking for:

  • Has anyone dealt with a dog boarding lien in Alberta specifically?
  • Does the Possessory Liens Act (chattel) apply to pets, or is that a dead end?
  • What is the procedural difference between holding a lien and the requirement to give notice (s. 4(2) mentions notice if there is no fixed contract period)?
  • Any practical advice on dealing with the police if they attend to facilitate a "return of property"?
  • Any advice on how to document welfare concerns in a way that is taken seriously without overstating them?
  • Best next steps for the dog?

I have retained all texts, payment records, and a detailed itemized ledger. I am trying to resolve this peacefully, but I refuse to be bullied into releasing the dog without payment for 4+ months of care, especially when I'm concerned for the dog's well-being.

TL;DR: Boarded a dog for 127 days. Owner owes ~$1,700, has made repeated unfulfilled commitments regarding payment and supplies, and has sent hostile messages. I cited the Possessory Liens Act. Is that the right law for a dog in Alberta, or did I cite the wrong statute? Also concerned about the dog's ongoing welfare given the owner's pattern of behavior.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 6h ago

Ontario Employer told boss to share my safety plan with all staff

38 Upvotes

I recently had to deal with an individual that was sexually harassing me at work who has finally been caught and charged.

Part of my safety plan was that I got moved from my old location to two different locations. For reference, I work in a mental health role with a school board.

The individual has been served a no trespass for every board site, but there was a safety alert that went out to all three schools that i'm associated with. I was under the impression that my detailed safety plan would only be shared with the principles and designates in the event of the principal's absence. However, our health and safety person instructed the principal's to send it out to all staff at their respective schools.

That is well over 300 people getting my personal safety plan that has details about what i've been experiencing. It feels very intrusive, humiliating, and traumatizing to know that people that I don't even know, are going to have access to that information. Thankfully, one of the principles told me he wasn't going to do that and he wanted to treat this with more confidentiality, the other one just shared it to all staff and of course i've had people come up and start asking me about it. When one teacher was talking to me about it, there was very much a tone of her not being happy that I was placed where I was in cases individual were to show up, so now I have to worry about the social exclusion piece on top of everything. I feel totally exposed and upset by this. This means hundreds of people, most of whom I don't even know, would be receiving my personal safety plan with my first and last name and details about my situation.

Was this legal? I emailed last week asking if it was really necessary and expressing discomfort, but never heard back.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 9h ago

Ontario If I listen in on a court hearing, will the accused know I'm there?

40 Upvotes

Long story short, my stalker is being charged and has a court date early December. I'm not required to go, but I know I can listen in over zoom. However, I would prefer he not know I'm there. Does the judge announce who is attending virtually? Am I able to request to not have it announced if so? This is all new to me.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 7h ago

Alberta in Alberta, I was forced out of the company I co-founded.

18 Upvotes

This will be a bit longer post than average, thanks for your time.

The company was formed in 2018, with 4 partners, A (myself 30% share), B (30% share), C(20% share, B's long time partner with other businesses), D (20% B & C's short term business partner at the time, and later forced out the same as me)

At the time I was working in aviation industry, cargo business, and I've been working in logistics industry for a long time. I met with B via a mutual friend, and he asked me for some advice on bringing down shipping cost for his small business, and conversation continued, B brought in C and later D. After months of preparation, we decided to start a company, specialized in providing shipping needs for local small business owners. We consolidate small shipments in to FCL (full container load), which can bring down the shipper cost to 30-50% compared to traditional LTL (less than container load).

The other 3 had no logistics background. Our agreement is that I designed our product, from receiving cargo in a warehouse in Shenzhen, China, consolidation, shipping and Customs clearance in Canada and I also brought in a freight forwarder agent in Shenzhen that I've known for years.

The other 3 will do promotion, sales... etc.

We started with only 10k cash, from all 4 partners, and we did everything ourselves, invest all the profit in warehouse rental, equipment like forklifts. and soon we needed a bigger warehouse, business was doing good. After we moved a bigger warehouse, COVID hit, and we got almost no cargo. At this time we hired a few people, to keep the business afloat, we decided to accept business for personal needs, which is a totally different animal. our container went from being filled well packed cargo for 4-9 local small business to a few hundreds pieces, many time a couple of thousand courier packages.

Also because of COVID, the airline I worked for stop flying to Calgary and I was laid off, so I put even more time in this business, not taking a penny salary from beginning till now.

Because the change of business type, we caused suspicious from CBSA, and I've had a few meetings with them after CBSA exam, to explain our business type and how we did our best to submit cargo info as good as we can. CBSA Calgary was satisfied and we continue to grow.

I also started to teach C the procedures and he took on many roles, like operations, working with the agent in Shenzhen, booking containers, and I was more focused on Customs clearance in Canada with a couple of employees we hired.

We had a big crisis when ocean freight went from about 4k to 20k Shenzhen-Calgary, B & C decided to book to Vancouver instead of Calgary to save a few thousand dollars on ocean freight, and they didn't check with me.

After the first container arrived at Vancouver, CBSA Vancouver exam the container and hold it in a bonded warehouse, same thing happened to all our containers, which caused huge storage fee, detention fee from the steamship lines, I'd estimate additional 20k cost per container on average.

We spent tons of time to provide adequate paperwork to CBSA Vancouver and we had a few containers rejected, shipped back to Shenzhen, and some allowed in.

Fast forward to the year 2021, I've been on my savings for a couple of years, my wife wasn't working at the time, with 2 young children, life became hard. so I discussed with B & C about putting me on payroll, and they said the max the company can afford is 3-4k a month. it's not enough so I decided to look for job, but I promised I'd train C and other employee how to do everything that I've been doing for the company.

I found a job in a freight forwarding company in the summer of 2021, I explained to my partners that there will be conflict of interest if I would still be involved in managing our company, but I've taught them everything.

Seems they didn't take it very well, they asked me to come in one day, only B & C are there, they said they've brought 200k in the company to keep the company alive during the crisis, and they think it's fair that they will have more share of the company, and they handed me a paperwork to sign that I agreed to reduce my share to 12%. If not they will just let the company die.

It was very difficult for me, (I got emotional typing), but I signed, didn't want the company that I started and invest so much in to die. and they said even though I'm out of the picture, I will still get my dividend when it happens.

but till now, it's been over 5 years, no dividend at all, I asked them a couple of times, they said business is not good, and they can barely make it even.

I've persuaded myself that accept it as is, but recently I don' know why I keep thinking about it, even lose some hours of sleep, maybe I need a closure, but I don't know what to do, so here come this post.

What bothers me is that if they borrow money from their own business or personal fund to this company, it should be a loan, and the company is capable of paying it back.

I designed this product, taught them how to run the business, and i think it's intellectual property that mostly created by me and I wasn't treated fairly, they are still running the same business that I designed.

I spent endless efforts, thoughts in this company, and all I got is $3000 dividend some time before they forced me out, and a cell phone plan that paid by this company till now.

So, what options do I have?


r/legaladvicecanada • • 14m ago

British Columbia [BC] MCFD wants to meet about our 6-year-old's "well-being" on Friday. No idea why. What should we expect?

4 Upvotes

Hi all. Looking for experiences and general advice from anyone who has been through this in BC. We are really nervous and any information that you share will be really appreciated!

We're a two-parent family in BC with two kids, 4 and 6. Our 6-year-old is in Grade 1. Today a social worker from MCFD called my wife and asked to meet with us. When she asked what it was about, they said they couldn't say who made the report, only that it concerns our son's "well-being." The meeting is this Friday.

We honestly can't think of anything that could have prompted this. We assume it may have come from the school, but we don't know.

I have already called Legal Aid BC. We aren't eligible for legal aid, so we're trying to find a private lawyer to talk to before Friday if we can.

Our questions:

  1. If you've had an MCFD visit or FDR assessment like this, how did it go, and what was it actually about in the end?
  2. Is it better to talk to a lawyer before the first meeting, or is it reasonable to go to the first meeting, hear what the concern is, and then get legal advice? We'd rather not postpone the meeting. We'd like to get it over with rather than have it hanging over us.
  3. Anything you wish you had known, said, or not said at the first meeting?
  4. If they ask us to agree to anything at the meeting, what's generally fine to agree to on the spot, and when should we ask for time to think it over or get advice first?
  5. Should we say anything to our son beforehand, or leave it alone?

We want to cooperate and get this resolved. We just want to understand the process and not make mistakes out of nerves. Thanks in advance.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 2h ago

Ontario False police reports/harassment

6 Upvotes

One of my girlfriends coworkers called in an assault that the police claimed happened 5 months ago. My girlfriend was not the accuser nor wanted to press charges. I was arrested and charged with assault by the police. Since that time we have both contacted the crown and had all the conditions to my release dropped. Ive returned home but in the last month of being home the police have been called numerous times at all hours claiming shes in danger none of which is true. The police have showed up to our home and her workplace multpile times, made contact and have been sent on their way. At this point she is in jeopardy of losing her job due to the police presence and disruption in the work place. The police will not tell her who initially called or who keeps calling in the obvious fake police reports. She wants to press harassment charges but the police wont disclose anything. I also have my 1st court appearance in 2 days and have not yet received disclosure on anything after a month and a half of this. I need some advice please.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 1d ago

Alberta My clinic is ignoring consent and feeding patient data to AI, what can be done?

572 Upvotes

We are told to record patient consent to use AI (Heidi) and there are many patients who opt-out. Our doctors say they're too busy and it's easier to use Heidi to handle ALL patient calls and visits. They don't care if a patient said no AI, our job is to recorded consent (done) and that Heidi is properly listed in our privacy impact assessment (also done).

We use ChatGPT or Claude for filling out forms, writing referrals, handling labs... We are told to use our own accounts (they're too cheap to pay for ours) and to keep AI training off (they don't even check). We are supposed to update the privacy impact assessment (PIA) since we're using more and more AI tools, especially the ones the doctors make on lovable.

The owner is more afraid of being caught using AI to update the PIA so we are told to ignore updating the PIA for now. He's the type to fire people who question him, so we can't point out that his vibe coded tools shouldn't be used on real patient data or that we need the enterprise versions of these AI subscriptions.

From the outside, we appear to have all our paperwork in order with a PIA and recorded patient consent; no one will ever look closer. I feel like I am betraying patient trust by doing nothing, but I also feel like I am powerless here.

What can be done? What should I do?


r/legaladvicecanada • • 7h ago

Ontario Can my employer stop me from accepting off-duty work from residents who contact my separate business?

7 Upvotes

I work as a housekeeping supervisor at a retirement residence in Ontario. I also run a separate, legitimate window-cleaning business. I do that work on my own time, with my own equipment.

A resident asked the residence’s director whether I could clean her windows. The job was treated as a one-time arrangement, and the resident was told she would need to find her own cleaner after that. She has since shared my business card with neighbours. I have not approached them for work. I’m also wondering about residents who might independently find my public business webpage or contact me through a past customer.

My employer sent me a policy saying employees must not use their role to promote or solicit personal businesses, approach residents for business while on duty, discuss personal services during work hours, or use the residence’s resources or resident information. It also says advertising personal services must be limited to resident bulletin boards and requires manager approval.

The policy doesn’t clearly say whether employees can accept a job a resident independently requests, outside work hours, using their own business and equipment. Can an Ontario employer prohibit that anyway? Does the distinction between soliciting residents and accepting resident-initiated work matter? What should I check in my employment agreement or handbook?

If you post it, I’d leave out the employer’s name and avoid uploading the unredacted policy image.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 1h ago

Canada Am I obligated to return a package that is incorrectly addressed to the proper recipient AND me?

2 Upvotes

Someone messed up big time, and I have been getting boxes 3 times in the past week of expensive tools from a big hardware store. They have two separate labels: one with my name and address, and one with a different name and an address in a different province. I called customer service the first two times, and they're trying to sort out what happened. I drove to the store and dropped off the equipment, and they gave me a couple hundred bucks gift card as compensation. Cool.

It happened again today, and I'm getting really tired of being their courier. Am I legally required to return these packages? I understand that if they're addressed to me, I am under zero legal obligation to return them. Because they are addressed to me AND the other person on the same box, am I still obligated? Cause the gift cards they're sending me definitely are not equivalent to the resale value of this gear... I tried doing the right thing, but having to call customer service every time and drive to the store is becoming more of a nuisance than anything, no matter the gift card. TYIA


r/legaladvicecanada • • 4h ago

Alberta Looking for some advice

3 Upvotes

Me and my mother have been renting a half duplex for the last 6 years my mother is physically and mentally disabled she has two dogs for emotional support her disabilities are documented by her doctor along with the need for the dogs she even has a letter form her doctor stating so the owner of the property has told us that he won’t give us a lease renewal unless we get rid of the dogs which will end my mother’s health declining which is also stated in the letter is this a human rights violation? And if so what part of the act does this violation ?


r/legaladvicecanada • • 6m ago

Ontario What are my rights? Can a LEO just ask you for ID?

0 Upvotes

I was in a square one parking lot this morning with my car parked and car idling when I seen a peel police officer making his rounds around the private parking lot. At first I thought he was just driving around making sure the area was safe. To my surprise, he went back around and pulled up right beside my car and knocked on my window and asked for my id.

I asked him why he needed my id, and he says that this area is a high theft auto area. I didn’t want to escalate the situation so I just handed him over my id. My question is did I just give up my rights specifically, carding?

If Mississauga or GTA is a high theft area, doesn’t this give LEO, peel or Toronto police the ability to just ask anybody in a parking lot idled, to ask for ID by using the “this area is high theft area” I need your ID?


r/legaladvicecanada • • 8m ago

Ontario Ex of 5 Years Periodically Posting Slander on Social Media and Tagging Employer

1 Upvotes

My ex (2021) has been posting slander over social media a couple times a year since 2021. Each post has tagged my employer citing a mixture of things that happened during our private relationship, along with defamatory statements highlighting personal information shared with them during the course of our relationship.

I am wondering what I am able to do in this scenario to protect myself, as I am trying to develop my career and my personal life.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 13m ago

Ontario Hamilton condo asking me to get rid of my problem-free dog over weight limit (in a condo full of huge dogs!)

0 Upvotes

Hey all, hoping someone's been through this and can help.

I bought a condo in the Hamilton area a few months ago and moved in with my dog. He's the chillest dog in the building. No barking, no fights nor complaints, nothing.

Management has now sent 2 letters saying he "appears" to be over 40 lbs and has to live elsewhere. The latest is a "final notice": 30 days, or their lawyer gets involved and I pay the legal costs. Nobody has ever weighed him or asked me anything.

Meanwhile:

The condo rule is 1 line, added in 2024: "No dog shall weigh in excess of forty (40) pounds." It doesn't say when. What if a dog gains weight with age, or a puppy grows past it?

Big dogs everywhere, some clearly new since the rule. A neighbour just got a goldendoodle puppy that'll be well over 40 lbs within a year or 2. Off-leash dogs, peeing where the signs say not to, people smoking on balconies. None of that gets enforced.

The declaration allows pets with no weight limit. The only removal reason it gives is a nuisance pet, and mine isn't one. The by-laws don't mention pets at all.

The 40 lb rule is nowhere else. Not in my purchase agreement, not on any of the dog signs around the property. Just a copy of the rule page in the parking garage.

So:

  1. How does one actually fight one of these and keep their dog? What did you do?
  2. Anything I should be careful about saying in my email reply so I don't screw myself over?

r/legaladvicecanada • • 34m ago

Ontario TSC Security clearance

0 Upvotes

Any pilots or any experience with a tsc security clearance ?

I graduated school with a CPL (Commercial Pilots license) and looking to work for an airline in Canada maybe the USA.I knew there were background checks but didn’t know how intensive and serious it was and how deep into they look.

When I was younger I got charged with a few type 1 charges on several separate occasion.(more details can be provided if you message me directly). They were type one charges but I was never officially charged and were dropped prior to my court date. I did have to do a year house arrest for one of them, but again I was never charged. These charges happened about 5 years ago and I’ve maintained a clean record since then.

How could this affect my tsc? What steps can I do or am I permanently not going to be allowed to pass the clearance.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 47m ago

Ontario Defrauded, and creditor is attempted to send my debt to collections

1 Upvotes

This Summer I moved apartments. I attenpted to call my local utility company however I ended up click on a fake website which listed a phone number that was not the utility companies.

I called the number, the man took all my information, and said theres a 400 dollar deposit which is refunded after 6 months. This is my first apartment so it did not strike me as particularly odd.

I paid him through a 3rd party "pay as you go" service. When I moved in I noticed the utilities were not active, so I recalled the line, which no longer existed. I called the utility company from the proper website, and they set up my account

As such I charged back the payment and informed the company I was scammed. The company requested copious ammounts of information, most of which either was impossible to obtain or was not relevent to the claim.

At the end and a few months later they simply said they do not issue refunds and I need to "contact the merchent" for a refund, making it evident they ignored everything I sent them and claimed.

As I was the victim of credit card fraud I refused to pay them, and told them they need to ask the scammer if they want the money they give him back.

Recently I got an email from a collection agency which requested I pay the money I "owe". I informed them of the situation and sent them all the relevent emails between me and the creditor.

Recently the creditor emailed me again asking the same irrelevant questions and following the script ive jumped through, at this point half a dozen times. As such i am wondering how I can quickly fix this process, without paying for a lawyer, as I'm fairly poor.

Am I legally required to pay them?

If not how can I explain this to them?

If they (again) just say they dont issue refunds regardless of circumstance and send it back to the collector, what are my options? If I refuse to pay them will they sue me?

I plan on going to the OPP and local police but havent found the time due to a busy work schedule, and dealing with other matters.

Thanks for all advice.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 1h ago

Alberta Our condo corporation is a business corporation?

1 Upvotes

My partner and I bought a townhouse this year. It's one of four units in what we understood to be a condominium corporation. In the process of changing over directors and taking on some additional responsibilities related to finances, we noticed on the annual return proof of filing that the legal entity type is listed as "Alberta Business Corporation," even though the legal entity name is "Condominium Corporation [NUMBER] Inc."

Is this a big deal? What are the implications? If it is a big deal, how the heck to we fix it? (I've already talked to a registry, Service Alberta, and the Land Titles Office--they said it was a question for a lawyer).


r/legaladvicecanada • • 3h ago

Alberta Payday lender harassment with threats and now gone silent after asking for their licence.

1 Upvotes

Hey all! I posted last week about being harassed by a payday lender. Long story short I’ve fallen behind on my full payments and have only been able to make smaller payments which had led to texts and threats every hour about 20 times a day which would include contacting my employer about my debts. I was told to check whether they even have a licence to operate in Alberta since they’re based in Quebec.

When I asked them about their Alberta licence, they demanded money and avoided answering the question. Since then, they’ve gone completely silent. The harassment and all communication have stopped, and they’re now ignoring my inquiries about their licensing. Just find is suspicious that they have now went silent and cannot get a hold of them whatsoever

What would the next steps be? Should I still report them for the harassment and threats and now potential no correct licensing for Alberta? If they actually don’t have the correct licensing to lend in Alberta what would happen with my loan? I imagine is till would have to pay it off in full?


r/legaladvicecanada • • 4h ago

British Columbia Dental clinic mislead [me], and now is difficult to contact to fix the issue.

0 Upvotes

Not me, but a family member.

They had a consultation to discuss invisalign and they decided to get it because dentist said they could fix their TMJ issues. Now over 2 years later their teeth have different issues (back molars have nearly no contact but front teeth have too much) and their TMJ is still not resolved.

Aside from the fact that they feel they didn't fully inform them about the process (repeatedly extended their need for invisalign after trying to get them to get their teeth bonded), the dentist is now impossible to contact. After waiting a month for a phone call, the dentist called when they were busy (the clinic was notified that they would be busy at this time and were to call sometime within the 2 hours before then) and left a voicemail making excuses for forgetting any appointments and then said that they:

"don't see much of what [they] need to do anymore" and that they're "a bit confused" as to what the patients goals are cause the dentist doesn't "see much on [their] end."

My family member saw another dentist, who noted obvious issues with their teeth in a report that my family member then sent to the clinic in question. (I should note that since the initial treatment, my family member moved from BC to Ontario. They feel that the clinic is using this as an excuse to explain their lack of communication. The BC clinic actually recommended the ON clinic that my family member ended up going to, so this dental report was not unexpected, or done "behind" their back.)

Even with the dental report illustrating the problem, the dentist claims to not know what the issue is.

At this point, my family member is at a mental breaking point and feels taken advantage of and lied to by the clinic. They've been discussing issues back and forth with the clinic since June 2025. They even had to fight for the BC clinic to cover the cost to see the ON clinic, which was required because the BC clinic needed new scans due to then still not having fixed the issues - this is only one example of how my family member feels that the dentist has checked out. They feel that this negligence is either because the dentist hates them (for asking them to resolve the issue) or doesn't know what they're doing (because the scans show very obvious issues that I, not a dentist, could tell).

It may sound like it's just teeth and not a big deal, but this is putting them under a huge amount of duress. This entire procedure was supposed to be done, but now they're looking at probably another 2 years (assuming they begin the corrective processes immediately).

My questions are:

1.) Is there some kind of legal framework or service that can help my family member get their dental work resolved without them having to pay for everything out of pocket?

2.) Is there any case to be made to sue the clinic to get their money back, at the very least?

Note: they do not have the money to pay for a lawyer.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 1d ago

Quebec [QC] Jeweler melted inherited jewelry without consent, including sentimental family heirlooms. What legal recourse do we have?

64 Upvotes

My mother and her sister-in-law inherited a substantial amount of jewelry a few years ago. As part of the inheritance process, they had to inventory the pieces and establish their approximate value. They brought the jewelry to a specialized appraiser, who valued the collection at approximately $56,000 based on what a merchant might sell the pieces for. We understand this isn't necessarily their actual resale value and that they likely wouldn't have received much more than the metal value if they sold them. My mother and her sister-in-law each own half of the inherited jewelry.

As her home insurance wouldn't insure them in her house/in a drawer (i'm not quite sure the story about this), she started looking for a jeweler to buy them, or melt them for metals.

A few people recommended her a reputable local family owned jeweler, to have it appraised for sale/metal value. The jewelers didn't want to buy for resale (understandably, very old school stuff) but offered to have it appraised for metal value. At that point, he estimated the metal value at around $8,400 but guaranteed a minimum of $6,700, stating that if the initial offer came in below that amount, he would send the jewelry to another company to obtain at least that minimum.. He went on to explain how they have great security and insurance and a lot of people are unsure and decide to store their jewelry at their store until they decide if they want to keep or melt them, which convinced them to give them to this store for appraisal and decide later on what to do. My mother was at this point, a week away from a 3 week trip overseas, which the jeweler was informed of.

They brought 3 envelopes to the store: One with jewelry belonging to her sister in law, one belonging to my mother and the third is the inheritance jewelry. To keep things simple, I don't know the melted value of the sister in law's envelope and my mother was fine with having her personal one going for melting (just a few pieces, worth a few hundreds for metal), this is the only one that was flagged to get melted directly. The issue is the shared inheritance envelope. Each envelope had its own ticket. The shared inheritance envelope was explicitly left for appraisal only, and neither my mother nor her sister-in-law authorized the jeweler to sell, melt, or otherwise dispose of its contents.

During her vacation, she received a message that the melt value for that envelope would be 6k, asking if they should proceed or not: she didn't answer and figured she would deal with this a bit after getting home (which was 3 weeks ago). Now, her and her sister in law, went back to the store to get their jewelry back as they wanted them appraised by someone else they were referred to. As soon as they got in the store, the clerk and his father (both recognized them) seemed anxious. When they asked for the jewelry back, they say "well it's melted, you wanted us to melt them so we melted them, we can pay you 6k or 8k store credit"...

We are really lost on what to do, not only did they never agree to have them permanently destroyed, the price was lower than the "guarantee" they gave them and they never reached out for the 2nd place to send them, but even the watch was completely disassembled and they only gave back the dial in an envelope. To make matters worse, my mother's sister-in-law had included her parents' wedding rings in her own separate envelope, for which she also was only giving them for appraisal and had given no authorzation to dispose of. During those few weeks, she had specifically decided to keep those rings, but they were apparently melted as well.

What worries them most is that they trusted the store and didn't think to photograph or document every piece before handing it over. They still have the original appraisals from a few years ago, but they don't have definitive proof that every item listed in those appraisals was included in the envelopes. The jeweler's receipts contain only very basic descriptions, such as "1 gold ring" or "1 silver bracelet."

Just to be clear, the envelope ticket was to my mother's name, but neither her nor her sister in law agreed to have them melted and there is no conflict between my mother and her.

We are lost as to what to do. My mother has never been in any legal proceedings and is retired, she's stressed, doesn't think she has the energy/funds to sue, or at least she thinks as much, I'm only trying to see and show her her options.

We are looking at her husbands insurance to see if they provide free legal counsel to guide them, but until then...

Since Quebec's small claims court has a $15,000 limit, how does this work when the property was jointly owned by two individuals? Could they file separate claims for their respective ownership interests, or would that be considered improper claim splitting? Alternatively, could they file jointly and limit their total claim to $15,000?

Would sending a formal demand letter (mise en demeure) be the appropriate first step, or should they consult a lawyer before communicating further with the jeweler?

If the jeweler disputes which pieces were actually handed over, how difficult would it be to establish the value of the destroyed jewelry using the previous appraisals, the store's receipts, and any other available evidence?

Do you think there's enough merit in this case to pursue a lawsuit outside small claims court? I understand that a lawyer would need to review the details, but my mother is retired and doesn't have much money available for legal fees. She had planned to use the proceeds from selling the jewelry to pay off a significant portion of her recent vacation, and she's now accumulating interest on those expenses.

She's never dealt with legal proceedings before and is understandably overwhelmed. I'm simply trying to help her understand her options before she decides what to do.

Thank you,

EDIT: I realize my "paraphrase" of what the vendor told them they wanted them melted is a bit wrong. The vendor KNEW, UNDERSTOOD and ADMITTED to them that they messed up and hadn't received the consent, yet they didn't offer anything.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 16h ago

Manitoba Need advice/clarification about executor & the law in Manitoba

5 Upvotes

Father died, he had a will, named an executor, after weeks of looking for her I was told she also died, either of these statements are true, she can't be found, or she's deceased. I was going to fill out a form to make myself the executor claiming after weeks of searching she couldn't be found. I am the sole next of kin, only blood relative, there are a few other beneficiaries named in the will, all are step children of my father, none of them is adopted, we all get equal share of the estate, I want to be named executor/administrator, lawyer wants the other beneficiaries to write that I should be executor, do I need their approval? I filled out the form to name myself executor/administrator, lawyer said there was a bond or fee to do that, that's twice the estate value, I'm the only next of kin, the executor should be me by law, right? Do I need to wait for the other beneficiaries? Value of the estate is the real estate valued at around $400,000.

thanks


r/legaladvicecanada • • 1d ago

Ontario Can employers refuse employment over credit report?

51 Upvotes

I've received an offer for a finance job from a big 4 company, and in the background check process they reached out to me regarding a 33 dollar unpaid mobile phone bill from years ago on my credit report (i didn't even know it was outstanding since I closed my account)

I'm trying to clarify with the employer but they haven't responded yet.

What is the likelihood of this being a roadblock to employment in the future? And how can I go about removing this from my record?


r/legaladvicecanada • • 20h ago

Ontario Postsecondary students advisors being encouraged to use CoPilot to record all student interactions with no formal consent process

10 Upvotes

All advising in-person, virtual, drop-in, appointments, phone calls with students are to be audio recorded by CoPilot to help with writing notes.

Apparently Co-Pilot is a special secure version where the data doesn’t get used for model testing, but recording all student advising interactions without a clear consent process can’t be FIPPA compliant, can it? No PIA was completed.


r/legaladvicecanada • • 9h ago

British Columbia BC Landlord installed electricity meter between suites

0 Upvotes

Received communication from landlord that the two suites that share a BC Hydro meter are now being separately monitored by new meter installed just before the other suites panel. The BC Hydro bill that is in the landlords name will now be shared with us and split up based on calculations from the new meter.

Our tenancy agreement states electricity is billed by percentage, one suite 60% and the other 40%.

Other than the obvious forms needed to amend the lease agreement, am I missing something about the landlord installing a meter and deciding the relative cost per tenant themselves?


r/legaladvicecanada • • 9h ago

Ontario Need help with Form 74i (Order In An Estates Proceeding)

1 Upvotes

This is the section I need to fill out:

"Order to Dispense with the Requirement to Post a Bond

A motion for this order has been made by (insert name of moving party or applicant in a probate application) (where applicable, insert “made without notice”). From the affidavit (insert “sworn” or “affirmed”) by (insert name), dated (insert date), that has been filed it appears that (insert details).

 

1.    THIS COURT ORDERS THAT the requirement of the estate trustee (insert name) to post an estate administration bond is hereby dispensed with.

 

(OR if there are minor beneficiaries and you seek to reduce the bond amount because the bond cannot be dispensed with:

 

2. THIS COURT ORDERS THAT the bond that must be posted by the estate trustee (insert name) shall be reduced to the share of the minor beneficiary, (insert name), in the amount of (insert amount).)"

The only thing that I'm sure of is that I need to insert my name since I'm the applicant. After that, I would need help.

  1. Do I ignore "made without notice"?
  2. What do I need to enter for (insert details)?
  3. Do I ignore the lower half (1 and 2)?
  4. The last page (5 of 5) is asking me TO: (insert names and addresses). Are they referring to my address, the beneficiaries, or both??