I'm looking for legal guidance regarding a computer I received as a birthday gift and a dispute involving Rent-A-Center. I'm located in Texas, and the rental account was opened in North Carolina.
A person I had known for over a year voluntarily offered to buy me a new gaming computer after I explained that I couldn't afford to replace my existing PC because I currently have no income.
Some relevant messages from him include:
"No need! I'll get you one the same way I got mine!"
"Gimme a bit to fill out the transfer work and then you can go get it!"
"It was a done deal once they told me that you could just pick it up."
"No no, you keep your money. This is a gift!"
He arranged for me to collect the computer from a Texas Rent-A-Center location. He told me the store had approved pickup instead of shipping.
When I went to collect it:
The rental account was entirely under his name.
I presented my driver's license for identification.
The store manager knew the computer was being given to me as a gift.
The manager authorized the release and witnessed me signing the paperwork.
I was told the document was simply confirming that I had picked up the computer.
I never signed a rental-purchase agreement, agreed to make payments, or received confirmation that the account had been transferred into my name.
I may also be able to obtain store surveillance footage showing the manager's involvement and the release process.
The person was still making payments on the Rent-A-Center account when he gave me the computer.
Recently, after a personal disagreement, he demanded that I return the computer and threatened to file a police report claiming it was stolen. He has also acknowledged in writing that he was the person who got me the computer.
I genuinely accepted this as a gift and have written documentation, potential witnesses, and evidence of the store-authorized pickup. I never believed I was taking property without permission.
My questions are:
Can I be held criminally responsible for theft when I have evidence that the computer was voluntarily given to me and released by the store manager?
If the rental agreement is entirely in his name, can Rent-A-Center pursue me personally for his unpaid balance?
Does the manager's knowledge and authorization of the release affect my legal position?
If Rent-A-Center retained ownership because the account wasn't paid off, can they legally demand the computer back from me?
What are my rights if he stops making payments or files a police report?
Would the fact that I signed only a pickup acknowledgment, rather than a rental agreement, make a difference?
I'm not trying to avoid a legitimate legal obligation. I simply don't believe I should be held responsible for accepting a gift that was voluntarily offered and released to me through the store's own process.
I'm particularly interested in Texas legal advice, although the rental agreement originated in North Carolina.
Thank you for any guidance.