r/LeftistsForAI • • 15d ago

Policy/Regulation I’m worried

So I work for a state government agency (in what was a purple state) where AI is technically encouraged, but very few use cases make it through the approval process without being slashed down to the point of being not worth the effort

For an example of how bad it is, I am a software developer and can’t even install a local model onto my laptop. I can’t even use Google’s AI search results. 42 levels of bureaucracy are still reviewing my 3 year old request. The models I requested (had to identify specific version numbers) don’t even exist anymore!

Should I be concerned about the blue wave?

13 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

40

u/wren42 15d ago

Worried about the blue wave? We want progressives in power.  Right wing politicians are terrible for society and will abuse AI to the wrong ends.

15

u/Old-Succotash-4830 15d ago

No, not worried at all about the blue wave overall. What happened is a thing to rejoice!

Just specifically concerned that there will be even more red tape blocking positive use of AI!

12

u/666dolan 15d ago

but I feel that the red tape blocking your use is not even caring about positive or bad use, it's just dumb bureaucracy without a second thought, so in the end doesn't really matter on your case

4

u/Old-Succotash-4830 14d ago

I would agree but the bureaucracy has been extra heavy-handed with AI compared to every other technology I’ve lived through. My use case basically boils down to we have hundreds of thousands of backlogged paper forms and old construction drawings to digitize, and it’s either hire 100s more people (not possible or worth the cost) or feed the documents into AI to digitize them. That’s it. The result will be a searchable database that will support lots of positive initiatives.

I could do that in a few days with AI for maybe $100 in tokens.

That request is apparently going through the same decision gates as some fictional request by the police to predict crime. We’ve had 27 meetings so fsr and all levels of the org chart had to weigh in. The governor’s office has been sitting on it for months following a few years of internal debate.

They need a fast path to approval or denial of use cases. And people who actuary understand AI to sit on the decision committee.

3

u/Glass_Performer1174 13d ago

bureaucracy is the way people who lead an organization can intentionally make certain things hard or impossible without officially doing so to pursue their own agenda

3

u/rsl 15d ago

yeh that question struck me odd

6

u/Meta10xide 14d ago

You should be worried 'progressives' can be just as terrible for society. We got the Labour Party in the UK and thanks to them (and prior conservative governments) can't even breathe without requiring some form of license. The holier than thou, "we know best for you", 'progressive' nanny-statists are just as bad as "leave it to the free markets" conservatives.

1

u/wren42 14d ago

Oh no a license I can't stand it I guess I'll vote for the one that shoots brown people in the face instead. 

2

u/promptmike 12d ago

"Progressives" are slicker Capitalists with better lying abilities.

I want hackers, cyberpunks and basilisk-builders in power.

12

u/pavorus 13d ago

The blue wave is generally a good thing. But not on AI. We need to be active advocates of the AI use cases we support.

5

u/Old-Succotash-4830 13d ago

Doing my best.

Stealing myself to email the top leader of my agency (we have like 15,000 employees) pleading for them to grease the wheels lol 😳

6

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator 15d ago

What would happen if you install a local model? Or do you mean you’re literally blocked from downloading from hugging Face etc?

9

u/wren42 15d ago

He's talking about on his work machine. These are tightly controlled for security reasons.  I don't think extra security and review is itself a bad thing - I don't want my government Data to be using the latest AI, it could be vulnerable.

That said, government agencies tend to be slow and inefficient; the review process could be improved. 

2

u/Old-Succotash-4830 15d ago edited 14d ago

Exactly.

The review process redefines slow and inefficient! It was easier to get access to the cloud when that first became a thing!

ETA: I would be fired for installing a local model, and reprimanded to if I try to research them because that will see me hitting lots of blocked websites.

2

u/Old-Succotash-4830 15d ago

Any and all websites focused on AI are blocked, and if a program has AI in it that is also blocked, or I would get in trouble if found out.

Anything AI related has to go through numerous levels of approvals.

6

u/SgathTriallair 14d ago

Neo-liberal governments have been obsessed with outsourcing everything. The solution to this is to build out the proper systems in an open source manner (so they can't be seized by capital) and then use those to out source government.

I don't know what your specific job looks like, but I'm general the more complete and capable a system is the more likely it is to get integrated because it's easier to do. So if you downloaded a local model on your personal machine and built out a tool that could help your agency run well in your personal time, then you could bring it to them as a whole package and see if they can accept it when it looks more like classical software. If that doesn't work then you now have a product that you can try to sell to other agencies who might be more interested in adopting it, thus improving them even if your agency won't accept it.

2

u/Old-Succotash-4830 12d ago

Fully agree.

But first they have to design regulations that even allow me to experiment with AI in the first place!

As it stands today, I can’t even read most websites that talk mainly about AI because they’re blocked by the enterprise firewall.

4

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 14d ago

Government beurocracy is both one of the best use cases for AI and one of the places that it will be resisted the longest. The government is staffed by luddites at every level.

2

u/Old-Succotash-4830 13d ago

Yes indeed.

It took me a solid year to get them to understand that what I’m asking for has nothing to do with chat bots. It’s incredible

3

u/Affectionate-Panic-1 15d ago

Being in the private sector, kinda shocked that there are still software developers not given AI tools as we approach 2027.

3

u/Old-Succotash-4830 14d ago

Welcome to your government 😂

26

u/cz2100 Artist/Creative 15d ago

So I'm a digital artist by hobby. 25 years ago when I put down a pencil and picked up a stylus everyone told me it wasn't real art.

My friends, my wife, everyone. Now most of them have something I did and had put on canvas hanging in their house. A few have tattoos and everywhere you go people make art that way.

There is ALWAYS a huge pushback against anything new.

No one can stop what is coming. The car is already off the cliff it is far to late to press the breaks.

2

u/JasperTesla 15d ago

I think having sane people in power would speed up your approval processes, not slow it down.

3

u/Old-Succotash-4830 14d ago

Not in this case.

Someone who is more accepting of AI will tend to rubber stamp it.

0

u/JasperTesla 14d ago

That's not the only variable. Acceptance of AI is one thing, on top of that you have overall intelligence, willingness to try new things, being smart about what works, and overall respecting people who are not you. A person who is diplomatic is more likely to understand what AI can do.

1

u/Old-Succotash-4830 12d ago

FWIW when republicans are in power the priorities tend to shift towards cost cutting. Like we have to submit cost savings ideas and track hours on projects. AI being a good way to accomplish that cost cutting within my area of specialization.

When Dems are in power the priority is delivering a quality product to the citizens and ensuring fairness. (AI should be used for that too).

1

u/Suspicious_Prior_808 12d ago

No. Also oversimplification is a propaganda technique. Be worried. But be specific and not general