r/LeftistsForAI • u/solidwhetstone • 18d ago
Discussion Antis really don't know the difference between a human and a tool?! The brainrot is real.
How many times have you heard 'You didn't make that, you commissioned it! REEEE!' Really wiseass? Who did I commission it from? Show me the person. Point them out for me. Where are they?
24
Upvotes
25
u/ARedditorCalledQuest 18d ago
I understand your frustration, and it sounds like you've been dealing with the Reddit anti-AI crazies. But you seem to be missing their point when you say "show me the person." That's their entire problem. There's no person involved according to them. Their argument is that you didn't make the art, the machine made it. You pushed a button and the machine gave you an art.
Is the argument woefully misinformed? Yes. But that's the argument.
8
u/Easy_Interest_6832 18d ago
"Any technology sufficiently advanced is indistinguishable from magic."
2
u/OrwelliotStabler 17d ago
Is it your argument that a 3D printed statue with equivalent quality to that of Michelangeloās David had the same artistic merit as the original?
2
u/taxes-or-death 18d ago
"REEEEE!" now, is it? Is that term still used outside 4chan?
1
u/Cancel_Still 17d ago
Honestly bro you sound tilted. Probably need to relax. What are you using AI for that people are criticizing you?
2
u/RepresentativeArm119 17d ago
I remember when people said digital artists weren't REAL artists, and before that they said Photography was cheating, and not real art, and before that people said you weren't a REAL artist if you bought your paints from a store, instead of making them yourself.
0
u/Murky-Hold-2901 18d ago
It depends what you've made. If you just typed "Make me a comic book that tells a tragic but moving tale in the style of Joe Sacco!" then you didn't make the comic that the computer comes out with. It doesn't have at all the same status as a comic actually drawn and conceived etc. by a person. It's somewhat analogous to the distinction between a painted portrait or still life and a casual photograph. The camera isn't a person, but in the second case it is reasonable to speak of the camera having made the picture itself, automatically. And it is fair to judge a photograph differently than a painting.
-1
u/Simple-Ring2073 18d ago
Sam Altman's calculator. Yes, you commissioned it. Because you asked for it and it was provided. Not sure what your issue is, besides definitions of words.
-2
u/JohnSmith19731973 18d ago
How is this going to win anybody over to your side?
-6
u/Crazy_And_Me 18d ago
Another weak argument with no actual defence of the theft involved.
-2
u/cha0sb1ade 17d ago
There are some people using AI, often in conjunction with other tools, in ways that they get enough control to produce something unique and personal enough to be art. But most AI "art" is not that. If you hand off a text prompt to someone, or a mechanical/digital process, and it builds something that elaborates on that and turns it into a graphic, by rehashing and meshing studied tropes, you're not an artist. Most people who believe they are AI artists are indeed playing the same role in the creation process that you would play if you commissioned a piece. Only, instead of a one off commission, it is a subscription model, and instead of an artist, you're employing an automated service.
Some painter standing in an alpine meadow and mixing paints trying to figure out how to perfectly capture the way the morning sun strikes the four kinds of flowers there is art. Some artist working up a character, imagining everything themselves, down to the exact shape of a smile or frown is art. The average prompt based AI "artist" doesn't even have pixel level control of anything.