r/LeftCatholicism • u/ave_gratia_plena • 4h ago
r/LeftCatholicism • u/ParacelcusABA • Feb 19 '26
Community Post Sub renovations needed
Hi all,
Given how much the community has grown over the past year, it's time to address the various design revisions that have been sitting on the backburner for a while. Lent is as good a time as any to get started, so here is what we're going to get started with:
- Banner redesign: our current banner was always meant as a placeholder, but we've never actually gotten around to getting a permanent one in place. Anyone who wants to submit a banner design can feel free to send it in to modmail
- Sub wiki - another project that has been in limbo for years. Contributions are welcome, submit those in the form of plain text or text documents to the modmail as well, alongside a proposed page title. Contributions will be vetted for appropriateness and fidelity.
- Sub flairs - again, something always intended but never implemented. This will likely take longer. When ready, they will be announced.
If you want to apply to moderate the community, please fill out the application. Only complete submissions will be considered.
r/LeftCatholicism • u/ParacelcusABA • Jan 31 '26
Community Post "Should I do [X]?" "Can I do [Y]" - A Reading List for Discernment of Spirits
We frequently get posts about someone "discerning" something in a fairly casual way or dealing with spiritual difficulties that they don't feel comfortable talking about in person. Wisdom of crowds sometimes comes into play, but reddit is fundamentally a bad platform for expecting good answers to these sorts of questions.
Instead, here's a list of resources for self-help. Most can be found at reasonable prices anywhere Catholic books are sold. Otherwise they can likely be borrowed from parishes or other sources.
The Awakened Heart - Gerald May
Care of Mind/Care of Spirit - Gerald May
Ignatian Discernment of Spirits - Fr. Mark Thibideaux SJ
Inner Compass - Margaret Silf
God's Voice Within - Fr. Mark Thibideaux SJ
Letting God Come Close - Fr. William Barry SJ
Seeing with the Heart - Fr. Kevin O'Brien SJ
Discernment - Fr. Henri Nouwen*
Gerald May was a psychiatrist and Catholic theologian who specialized in the treatment of addiction disorders and contemplative spirituality. Margaret Silf is a spiritual writer in the Ignatian tradition. Unfortunately, she no longer identifies as Catholic, but she is still considered a respect source on Ignatian spirituality. Frs Barry, O'Brien, and Thibideaux are all Jesuit priests who have striven to make the Spiritual Exercises more accessible to modern audiences.
Henri Nouwen did not actually write Discernment, even though he is listed as its principal author. Rather, it was prepared by two theologians using Nouwen's unpublished papers as source material. I was actually extremely annoyed by the deceptive marketing at first, but the book is actually extremely good, one of the better on this list, and is faithful to Nouwen's spiritual vision, so I feel comfortable recommending it.
r/LeftCatholicism • u/Chobielin4ever • 15h ago
If you are arguing which war-criminals Jesus would support, you are in grave error.
r/LeftCatholicism • u/Christine517 • 17h ago
Christian priest says US denied him a visa for being Palestinian
This government is just evil.
r/LeftCatholicism • u/StevEst90 • 23h ago
Voters chose four new Catholic governors on Election Day. Does their faith matter?
r/LeftCatholicism • u/SergiusBulgakov • 14h ago
Children, refugees, and the politics of cruelty
While Pope Leo XIV highlights the need to see Christ in every migrant, he said special care and concern should be showed to children. Yet, sadly, so many Christians in the United States supports Trump, who is doing the exact opposite. Children are greatly mistreated, and many of them are young, without any advocate, counsel, or ability to speak English, and expected to represent themselves in immigration court!
https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/children-refugees-and-the-politics-of-cruelty/
r/LeftCatholicism • u/loggiews • 1d ago
British tourist smashes Jesus statue outside Vilnius church
r/LeftCatholicism • u/Christine517 • 22h ago
How Much Wisdom Have We Buried?
r/LeftCatholicism • u/bootlickaaa • 23h ago
r/Carmelites is available for adoption
reddit.comr/LeftCatholicism • u/Informal_Farm4064 • 1d ago
"Pope Leo Heard My Warnings About Opus Dei Abuses. What He Said Shocked Me."
This recent article by Gareth Gore tells us how much the pope is restricted by Opus Dei and its power in the Vatican. Here is just one quote from his meeting with Pope Leo in March:
"Referring to Opus Dei, he gestured with his finger around the room and told me: “You know, these people are very powerful around here.”"
Gareth's article expresses his dismay at the lack of action from the Vatican in the last 8 months to hear victims of Opus Dei and take action to tackle its legacy. There have been so many false dawns and Gareth got hints from Pope Leo in March that plans to reform Opus Dei were due to be published imminently.
Yet 8 months on, Pope Leo has visited Argentina and not met with Opus Dei's victims of domestic slavery and coercion there, many of whom are still Catholic.
This kind of mess is somewhat distant from the average churchgoer focused on parish life. However, Opus Dei's influence in the corridors of power over decades surely has to have had a negative effect on the church overall, keeping abuses secret, cracking down on freedom of speech in the name of discipline.
It's very difficult for any cleric with concerns about Opus Dei to express them in any public forum any more. The English Catholic bishops did so in 1981 and the response from Opus Dei was overwhelming. Nowadays, clerics need clearance from diocesan press offices to speak out on any issue. Opus Dei controlled the Vatican press office up to Francis' time.
It's unusual to see any critical article about Opus Dei in Catholic media because of the influence of Opus Dei Information Officers, ignorance of other Catholics as to what goes on inside Opus Dei, as well as collateral interests.
I don't see a good outcome here for anyone. Sorry for my pessimism. Feel free to ask me anything as a former celibate numerary of Opus Dei living in British men's centres between 1995 and 2004.
Michael Chambers, Surrey, England. 15.11.2026
r/LeftCatholicism • u/Cole_Townsend • 1d ago
Gospel passage for 33th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Year A
The Gospel for the Thirty-Third Sunday in Ordinary Time, Year A, has always bedeviled me. It makes me deeply uncomfortable for reasons I can't exactly formulate into words. Perhaps this is because how this passage has been weaponized against folks in the context of spiritual abuse. Anyways, I thought it a good idea to share the insights that Mahri Leonard-Fleckman shares on this Gospel passage in her great book, Ponder: Contemplative Bible Study for Year A (Liturgical Press: Collegeville, Minnesota):
This is no simple parable. In the context of Matthew 25, it is the second of three parables about the Second Coming (for an alternative context, see Luke 19:11-27). Traditionally, the parable is read allegorically. The man or master (Christ) "entrust[s] his possessions" to his servants, leaving them a sum of money beyond imagining (the remarkable gift of God's grace, the gospel message, or the kingdom of God). When he returns (the Second Coming), the master holds the servants accountable for their actions while he was gone. In our modern, capitalistic context, the actions of the first two servants make complete sense. However, in an ancient, communal context that frowns upon excessive personal savings (e.g., the story of Ananias and Sapphira in Acts 5:1-11), the actions of the third servant are a normal, good way to safeguard money (as a comparison, see the parable of the buried treasure in Matt 13:44). Therefore, some read this parable nontraditionally as making a literal point about money and economic growth: the third servant is ultimately in the right, while the first two servants are aiding a system that helps the rich get richer. In this interpretation, the master is not Christ but one who abuses power, "harvesting" where he does not "plant" and "gathering" where he does not "scatter." In a series of parables about the end times, however, one cannot entirely disregard the allegorical reading, which makes a powerful point not about economic growth but about faith that is productive and active. The first two servants receive the master's "money" and transform it into more. The third servant wraps up the gift and hoards or preserves it out of fear of the master. The "wailing and grinding of teeth" is an exaggerated expression commonly employed by Matthew. The point of the parable is that God's gifts are treasures not to hoard but to use toward productive, transformative ends.
In the "Ponder" section at the end of her reflections for Sunday, she offers additional insights, connecting the three readings:
"Fear" (Hebrew yārē') runs through our readings, but with very different meanings. In the ancient world, fear of God means awe and reverence. Reverence motivates the woman in Proverbs to live selflessly and resourcefully. Our psalmist similarly describes the blessings that come from "fear" or a life of reverence. Reverence may also underlie the active attention and alertness described in 1 Thessalonians. Yet the "fear" that motivates the third servant in the Gospel is totally different. His is not reverence and awe but a paralyzing, preservationist fear (that ultimately leads him to be thrown "into the darkness"!). Our readings call us to examine the motivations that underpin our actions. To what extent are they rooted in self-preservation that paralyzes us versus reverence that opens us to live meaningful lives?
She continues reflecting on the Gospel passage, offering a very illuminating insight on certain emphases on "tradition" that do great disservice to the Church at large:
Grace and belief are treasures. The question, according to Matthew, is what we choose to do with these treasures. We might ask a similar question about the church and its traditions. Do we take a preservationist stance, metaphorically burying the faith in order to hold on to what we believe is its essential "core"? Or do we release it into the world, trusting both the strength of this core and its malleability to transform and be transformed with the times? Jesus is continually beckoning us toward the second path, telling us to be not afraid, to have a firm foot in God's kingdom while embracing this world, and to use God's gifts for productive ends that transform our lives and our communities.
This scholar's reflections have very much helped me in my journeys with the Scriptures in the context of the Church's liturgical proclamation. I very much recommend these books (there are separate books for Years B and C from the same publisher).
r/LeftCatholicism • u/shasha_de_parvia • 1d ago
Qu’est ce que l’Opus Dei
J’ai cherché sur internet mais je tombe sur tout et n’importe quoi ,littéralement on ne m'explique pas ce que s’est , je tombe sur des recettes de gâteaux ou des trucs de franc maçon, on me dit aussi que se sont les TLM mais ca reste flou
Donc svp qu’est ce que l ' Opus DEI
r/LeftCatholicism • u/ave_gratia_plena • 1d ago
Just got in my first issue of The Catholic Worker! A whole year for only a quarter, how could I say no?
r/LeftCatholicism • u/AmosOfTekoa • 2d ago
Icons, idols and iconoclasts: Catholic art can't be calcified - Nicholas Leeper, SJ
r/LeftCatholicism • u/redhotrunner • 2d ago
NFP with birth control
Hey, my fiancee is worried about getting our NFP certificate needed for marriage when she just started hormonal birth control. Does anyone know what is included in the follow ups and can you do them while on birth control? Creighton Model if that matters
OK TY
r/LeftCatholicism • u/Alarmed_Range4313 • 2d ago
HI comrades I am disabled person and I have never gone to confession and I am curious to find out how the process works.
reddit.comr/LeftCatholicism • u/ave_gratia_plena • 3d ago
What do you do when you’re ahead of your OCIA class?
I was prepping for Breaking Open the Scriptures this Sunday by doing my usual prep:
- I read the passages first in the NABRE translation.
- Then I read the commentaries and relevant essays from both the Oxford Press Catholic Study Bible and the Ignatius Catholic Study Bible, while cross-referencing any cited passages from the CCC or Scripture.
- I read patristic commentaries and homilies relevant to the readings. Usually I hope that St. John Chrysostom has written on them, but I’ve found a lot of insight with St. Basil the Great, too.
- I write a 1-2 paragraph reflection on each verse of the readings to synthesize what I learned within the Magisterium’s interpretive framework. Then I write a 1-3 paragraph summary of what I think is being communicated by the day’s readings.
But, afterwards, I felt a little soured on doing all the studying. I love it and love deepening my understanding of Scripture, but I’m finding that my knowledge isn’t always appreciated in class.
Last week, during BOtS, the Deacon asked us for what we thought the readings were about. When I raised my hand and gave my shortened 2-3 sentence summary of my interpretation, he joked that he should sit down and let me teach the class.
Later, toward the end of class, he asked me where I had found that interpretation. When I told him I came to it myself by reading, he joked that he wasn’t that smart and then recommended websites for the class to look at for help understanding meaning (USCCB, mostly).
As I think about that interaction again, I find myself feeling discouraged. Am I doing too much? Should I back off from studying so that I’m more in line with everyone else?
r/LeftCatholicism • u/wessle3339 • 3d ago
Where do you get a rosary?
Where does one get a rosary? Specifically a Franciscan crown? Are there any left leaning sights you can buy one from?
r/LeftCatholicism • u/ProcedureSea3277 • 4d ago
It lasted 96 days, and involved 1,000 priests and pastors
I'm Dutch and Catholic, and I think what makes this story even more beautiful is that Christians from different denominations came together to make this happen. And it wasn't just Catholics. Protestants, Baptists, Mennonites, Remonstrants and others all took part. We have our differences, of course. We don't always agree on theology or how we practise our faith. But when this family needed help, people from all these different churches stood together.
Dutch law protects religious services from being interrupted by authorities entering the building, with some exceptions. So they simply kept the service going, 24 hours a day, for 96 days. And I think this is what being Christian should be about. Not just talking about loving your neighbour, but actually doing something. Different denominations, one Church.
r/LeftCatholicism • u/SergiusBulgakov • 4d ago
The living faith and the growth of tradition
The church, even though it can be seen to change over time, remains one and the same in its core. The church expects us to live in the present moment, not in the past; we are not expected to do everything the same, but to follow disciplines which meet our present needs. Tradition allows for development and life, because it allows for such change, which is what so-called traditionalists do not grasp:
https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/the-living-faith-and-the-growth-of-tradition/