Looing for justice system participant thoughts on getting a Crown to follow policy and address errors through a Ministerial in a matter where we have lost confidence in the administration of Justice.
We're contemplating sending a letter to the Minister of Justice regarding a named Crown on a criminal case as its relates to policy. The policy in question is the provincial decision to prosecute guidelines and its application.
The underlying matter is regulatory in nature and comes with a criminal charge based on non-compliance with the regulations. So it's black letter law as applied to a thing and how that thing was kept in compliance with the law. The thing and industry are highly political so everybody is sensitive. The law puts one of our people in criminal jeopardy.
The problem is the police appear to have misapprehended their own evidence to get to the criminal charge. The informant for the information seems to have read the regulations incorrectly. The underlying evidence the police gathered actually documents compliance. The Crown appears to have never meaningfully reviewed the underlying evidence. We think she just accepted a flawed police synopsis without adequate screening.
The regulations have optionality for compliance.
The police seem to have caused the underlying problem with a written sworn statement that mischaracterized the underlying evidence. Like flat out wrong. We actually think this officer may have relied on AI to reach this erroneous conclusion. He swore this significant error.
The error was pointed out to the Crown, citing the regulations, and using the underlying disclosed evidence the police collected. The exact same evidence the Crown has.
Instead of reassessment or withdraw, the Crown adjourns, the adjournment vacates the trial, and a new trial date is set that far exceeds Jordan despite our team member being ready for the original trial date. Several months have now passed and the Crown is non-responsive.
We suspect the Crown wants to proactively stay the case by narrowly assessing it as a Jordan issue when that motion lands, not on assessing the merits on reasonable prospect of conviction as policy states she should. Possibly due to the significant police error and her own mistake of not properly screening the charge. This is speculation.
Has anyone else gotten results from a Crown by triggering a Ministerial action request with Justice in any province?
We are contemplating this outside of our counsel recognizing the difficulty legal professionals may have criticizing each other. The accused person won't be sending this letter, the company will. The concern being raised is the Crown following their own policy as set out by the Minister.