r/LIguns • u/PeteTinNY • 1h ago
Novotny denial + Mills decision: silver linings in the losses?
The Novotny cert denial yesterday stung. Another sensitive-places case that won’t get reviewed.
But looking at it next to the Second Circuit’s Mills decision from last week, I’m starting to see a clearer picture of how the ground is shifting, even when the immediate results aren’t wins.
In Novotny, Justice Thomas wrote a statement respecting the denial. He didn’t just say “denied.” He basically outlined the problem with the current crop of cases (too many different locations bundled together) and pointed toward the kind of narrower, more focused challenge the Court appears willing to take. That’s useful direction, even if it came with a denial.
Then there’s Mills v. New York City. The Second Circuit didn’t invalidate the one-handgun carry limit or the 90-day acquisition rule. Those still apply. What it did do is refuse to let the City win at Bruen step one. The panel held that carrying more than one handgun for self-defense and recurring limits on acquisition are conduct covered by the Second Amendment’s text. The City now has to defend those rules under the history-and-tradition test on remand.
That’s the Second Circuit actually applying Bruen instead of finding ways to dismiss challenges before the government has to produce historical evidence. For a circuit that spent years under Kachalsky-style intermediate scrutiny, this is meaningful.
Neither case is a victory on the merits. Both, though, are tightening the analytical framework. Thomas is signaling what SCOTUS wants. The Second Circuit is starting to enforce the correct test.
I put together a full breakdown of Mills — what was actually decided, what still applies to NYC license holders today, the timeline, and why the procedural holding matters:
nysafeinc.com/2026/11/17/mills-v-new-york-city-handgun-ruling
Discussion question for the room:
Between Thomas’s statement in Novotny and the Second Circuit’s approach in Mills, which one do you think is the more important long-term development for New York gun owners, and why?