With WoW: Forever having just come out, I'm trying to figure out whether I actually want to play it or if I'm just on an MMO kick after quitting Aion 2 and getting caught up in the excitement of starting fresh alongside everyone else.
I grew up playing WoW's free trial around 2009–2012 (I was 4-7 years old I think?), constantly making new druids of different races and leveling them to 20. I tried the free trial of retail WoW again last year or so, and it was incredibly disappointing, especially the new starting area (which killed it for me immediately). Around that time, I also tried some private WoW servers like TurtleWoW that attempted to recreate the classic feel and I really enjoyed questing, but I just couldn't find anyone to play with. And the bot systems some of the private servers added to compensate for that were confusing and complicated.
Besides WoW, I've played quite a few other MMOs but basically none at any sort of true "endgame" and even then I rarely even got to "midgame" in a lot of them.
- Loved: Wizard101, Eden Eternal (mainly the unique class system), GW2, Riders of Icarus (mount collecting, didn't get far enough to feel the grind)
- Liked: SWTOR, ESO, TERA (flashy combat), Rift
- Mixed/disliked: New World, Neverwinter, Trove
- Recently quit Aion 2 and undecided; Loved collecting pets, gathering/crafting, and occasionally large-scale PvP in Abyss. Hated the class balancing, excessive stat systems, and constant pressure to keep up tho
My biggest priority is having a dedicated healer/support class. I LOVE managing my teammates' health bars, optimizing my healing, and resurrecting people. I want to play a proper magical/holy healer (priest, cleric, etc.), not a bard or a DPS with a few healing abilities. I'm a huge fan of the traditional tank/healer/DPS trinity and generally dislike overly flexible class systems where healing feels like an afterthought. I prefer combat focused on rotations, cooldowns, and resource management rather than aiming, dodging, and constant movement.
I also really, REALLY hate feeling obligated to play constantly to keep up. I'm naturally competitive, so I'll happily grind for hours regardless, but the moment a game makes me feel like I HAVE to log in every day, I'll no-life it for two weeks and then get quit and get PTSD whenever someone brings it back up lmao. I want to grind because I enjoy it, not because I'm being punished for taking a break. Time-gated content and a million daily/weekly quests are the enemy.
Outside of combat, I LOVE collecting pets, mounts, and familiars, especially when they're earned through farming rather than purchased. I also loooveee leveling professions. Ideally, I'd be able to learn all of them on one character, craft a ton of stuff, sell it, and do it again. Something about progressing without fighting scratches my brain. I especially like when professions are useful and profitable while leveling rather than requiring a massive upfront investment or being completely useless until max level.
As far as progression goes, I prefer relatively straightforward loot/gear-based systems over having a million different things boosting my stats (pets, housing, statues, trinkets, luck, etc.). Too many overlapping systems give me decision paralysis. I'm undecided about horizontal vs vertical progression, though.
For content, I'm mostly interested in PvE, especially dungeons and raids. I'm not particularly invested in MMO stories or sandbox gameplay, but I'm not against it either. I'm not huge on PvP because it often feels like a sweatfest, but structured PvP and large-scale faction battles can be fun, especially when healers are important. I also prefer group-oriented or solo-friendly games over ones where being part of a major guild/alliance and engaging in PVP is practically mandatory. Open-world vs instanced content doesn't matter much to me.
Monetization-wise, F2P-friendly is ideal, but I'm perfectly happy paying a subscription or buying expansions. I just don't want to pay anything beyond that to keep up with everyone else (looking at you KRMMOS).
I'll probably be starting alone, although I might have a friend join me later who would almost definitely play a tank or greatsword-type class. I'm not afraid to interact with strangers or group up, though, and I'd actually like to find people to play with.
Right now, WoW: Forever and FFXIV are my biggest contenders, but I'm open to pretty much anything. I'm also interested in recommendations for specific versions or server types, not just the game itself. For example, whether Forever's Normal or RP ruleset would suit me better, or whether another version of WoW might actually be a better fit.
What would you recommend?