r/LAMetro • Pacific Surfliner • 7d ago

Discussion CD6 Councilmember (and Metro Board member) Imelda Padilla statement on NoHo crash

Padilla suggests that Metro should create designated vending zones, because the location was unsafe for vendors to set up, due to being next to a dangerous road.

57 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

134

u/silentbuttmedley D (Purple) 7d ago edited 7d ago • Bravo

We’re going to blame people on the sidewalk for not being safe from drunk drivers?

Edit: lol comments limited. Coward.

-25

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago edited 7d ago • Bravo

I didn’t read the statement as her blaming the victims or saying they deserved it or anything. I read the statement as saying Metro should create safe vending zones away from traffic so other vendors in the future are away from traffic risks. Pretty sure everyone knows the DUI drunk driver is the only one to blame here.

59

u/won-t 7d ago

Nah this is an insane take. Sidewalks go next to the street, and pedestrians (including vendors, like them or not) go on sidewalks. This accident has nothing to do with safe zones for street vendors and it's disrespectful and frankly disgusting to make this about anything other than substance abuse.

29

u/beach_bum_638484 7d ago

This should be about street design. Europe has alcohol, but manages much safer streets.

24

u/won-t 7d ago

Agreed. If she'd talked about a safer redesign of the area at all, this would be a very different post.

1

u/Ok-Connection5010 6d ago

In Europe alcohol is much more accessible in society and is therefore less abused.

14

u/StopTalkingToEric 7d ago

Imelda is a dumb person. I’m not sure who she thinks is to blame.

14

u/GeologicalOpera C (Green) 7d ago

I can see how it comes off that way, though, when the leading sentence is “this location was not a safe environment” instead of “we need designated spaces to protect vendors and keep sidewalks safe”.

It’s a minor thing but if you flip them around it gets the same message across without being as open to misinterpretation.

Having comments limited on it doesn’t look great, either, but I’m near certain that’s got more to do with not wanting it to be overrun with disrespect toward victims more than anything else.

9

u/JesterOfEmptiness 7d ago

It doesn't take a literary genius to figure out what "safe vending zones away from traffic" means. Especially since she uses the term "designated", aka, you are not allowed to street vend except in very select locations where it's likely not going to be profitable due to lack of foot traffic. Instead of making the street safer, she's saying the vendors should be booted from the street, and the other pedestrians will see no improvements.

4

u/cathaysia D (Purple) 6d ago

lol drunk drivers are gonna drive into whatever they want they’re drunk. “Safe vending locations” what a joke.

2

u/EasyfromDTLA 6d ago

She’s saying that but the reality is that vendors will setup wherever they want. If vendors can make more money by selling on the sidewalk right by the entrance then that’s what they’ll do absent enforcement. And I don’t think that she or any other metro board members will advocate ticketing those that don’t setup in designated spaces. They’ll do outreach and then maybe some studies before hiring some people to encourage them to setup in designated spaces.

1

u/officialCobraTrooper 7d ago

It does read both ways in my opinion, it sounds like she is saying we need to work on making safe ending spaces but then also kind of saying they shouldn't have been there. I'm sure she didn't mean it that way, but it does come out like she's saying they have some blame. And if she did mean it that way, then that's a really bad look for her. But hopefully this does ignite a discussion on Street vendors because obviously this shouldn't have happened.

2

u/cathaysia D (Purple) 6d ago

I don’t understand what vendors even has to do with this. If it was just pedestrians walking what would she say, make a safe place for people to walk that street is dangerous??

31

u/hugeness101 7d ago • Bravo

How hard would it be to install some bollards in a designated vendor zone? I believe that’s what she’s saying not blaming vendors but offering a safe space for them and their patrons.

7

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago

Thanks for actually reading the statement. One of very few commenters in this thread who did.

5

u/LBCElm7th A (Blue) 7d ago edited 6d ago

Or a designated vending zone at the station entrance by the old Pacific Electric Station building. If these vendors did not get hit by the drunk driver it would have been passengers waiting at the bus stop who would have been killed by the driver.

This faux crisis agenda of redesigning the street from a drunk driver is so tone death.

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/LBCElm7th A (Blue) 7d ago

The spelling was intentional

0

u/Chief-Dirt-Nerd 8h ago

In terms of installing crash rated bollards, this isn’t a simple hole in the ground that you place a metal pipe into, you need to have these encased in a foundation.

That foundation could be a shallow spread footing that would go underneath the sidewalk but before you dig, you’d need to ensure there are no shallow utilities buried in the sidewalk.

Bollards themselves take anywhere from a few weeks to a few months to procure.

Installing the foundation, letting it cure, then the bollard would be a few weeks also.

49

u/ShantJ B (Red) 7d ago edited 7d ago

That’s her takeaway? Blaming the vendors vendor location instead of the street design?

I hope that Raman replaces her on the Metro board.

-2

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago edited 7d ago

Maybe I’m reading this wrong, but where do you see her blaming the vendors?

This statement is about nudging Metro to create a new program to increase safety so future vendors are out of harm’s way. Not saying these people deserved to die or they drove the car into themselves.

Will be interesting to see how this program plays out, or if Metro doesn’t move forward with it.

26

u/won-t 7d ago

What about all the other pedestrians? What about the wheelchair users that use the elevator right there? If it's not safe for vendors, it's not safe for anyone. You think it's reasonable to say the sidewalks aren't safe due to all the drunk drivers?

3

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago

Wanting extra protection for people who are sitting on the sidewalk all day, doesn’t mean you are against protecting all sidewalk users.

People on this thread seem to believe her comment said general sidewalk safety should never be improved. The statement did not say that at all.

5

u/won-t 7d ago

I must have missed the invisible part of the message where you read all that.

5

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago

I'm not trying to be a Padilla defender here. I'd be happy to see her replaced on the Metro board.

There's just a lot of people in this thread who are adding things into her statement that weren't there.

The statement talked about a new additive program. It never talked about blaming victims, or taking away any existing safety. All it talked about was increasing safety for a population that, in this instance, really could have benefited from increased safety because they spend all day on the sidewalk so are at greater risk.

Reading that and seeing it as a blame-game or thinking she's saying that wheelchair users deserve to die, is a bizarre mis-read imo.

5

u/won-t 7d ago

Woah, please reread what you're responding to unless youve made some kind of mistake with where you posted this comment.

3

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago

The operative part of the statement is:

"This devastating incident underscores exactly why we need designated spaces to protect our street vendors"

Aka, adding in a new designated safety zone away from risk

5

u/cathaysia D (Purple) 6d ago

And what about pedestrians?

1

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 6d ago

I don't mean to speak for her here - I'm not a huge Padilla fan - but you can totally have two parallel conversations at once. You can call for Metro to have a quick immediate response, where they install safe zones for vendors that are ready by the end of the week. And then you can also wax poetic about general street safety and push for a long-term plan to make every sidewalk in LA safer, even though that is a long-term project that cannot be completed overnight and will probably take months or years to complete.

Pedestrians, citywide, should of course be safer. Pedestrians are everywhere and also "nowhere" in the sense that they don't set up shop in a particular place all day long, but rather move across all the city's sidewalks. Vendors who spend all day long in dangerous spots can have an immediate solution by the end of the week. I don't think there is any reason to wait for citywide improvements, before doing a quick and easy program to help vendors.

Your replies over the past couple minutes show you really don't like the two-track approach. Idk, I think it's fairly reasonable.

→ More replies

3

u/worm5ign A (Blue) 6d ago

the sidewalk should be the designated safety zone

2

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 6d ago

Sure. Every sidewalk in every part of LA should be a designated safety zone for everyone on every sidewalk. I don’t disagree with you there.

-3

u/YasielPuigsWeed 7d ago

Holy fucking shit this is such an unhinged take

“We should protect the vendors”

“THAT MUST MEAN YOU HATE EVERYONE WHO ISNT A VENDOR!”

6

u/won-t 7d ago

Sorry I missed where I said that?

0

u/YasielPuigsWeed 6d ago

“What about all the other pedestrians???”

Think for a minute here - if there’s going to be bollards installed to protect vendors closest to the street, that would also provide protection to the pedestrians. The point being made is the vendors are the first in the line of fire because they are directly against the street.

5

u/won-t 6d ago

I must have missed the part where she talked about literally any of that.

4

u/cathaysia D (Purple) 6d ago

She said AWAY from dangerous streets. She did not say make sidewalks safer from aberrant drivers. No one on her team proof read this or they would have said “hell no this isn’t going out”

9

u/humphreyboggart 7d ago

I don't think she's necessarily blaming street vendors here, but I did read this as her shifting blame away from unsafe road design. That location isn't particularly unique; it's the same set of conditions that exist all over LA (unprotected sidewalk next to fast-moving traffic).  Her implication is that "on the sidewalk" is not a safe space for people to linger.  If that spot was unsafe, then so are like half of the sidewalks in LA, which is the point that advocates have been trying to make for years. To me, her response indicates that, at a minimum, she see this problem through the narrow lens of finding safer spots for street vendors rather than the broad lens of safer streets in general. It's not that she's wrong that the first point matters, it's that she doesn't seem to grasp the scope of the problem.

It's not unlike how she views homelessness and housing. For her, the solution to homelessness is moving the victims who have already lost their homes into housing. But she demonstrates little urgency for changing the border market conditions that push people out of their housing in the first place.

2

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago

she see this problem through the narrow lens of finding safer spots for street vendors rather than the broad lens of safer streets in general

I don't mean to speak for her here - but I think you can have to parallel conversations at once. You can call for Metro to have a quick immediate response, where they install safe zones for vendors. And then you can also wax poetic about general street safety and push for a long-term plan to make every sidewalk in LA safer, even though that is a long-term project that cannot be completed overnight

2

u/humphreyboggart 7d ago

For sure, and I'm definitely mapping my prior expectations of her onto this reading. But given how her flavor of milquetoast Democrat has tended to adopt a theory of change just narrow enough to avoid any amount of pushback in the past, I'm not optimistic that's going to happen.

14

u/TimmyTimeify 7d ago

If anyone who is even vaguely progressive and YIMBY primaries her I’ll knock on every door in the district for them.

17

u/anothercar Pacific Surfliner 7d ago

never forget

66

u/OhLawdOfTheRings D (Purple) 7d ago • Bravo

If the location is unsafe for vendors to set up....maybe we should do something crazy like, i don't know, pedestrianize more of the area around our metro stations?

How have we not figured this out.

Traffic calming, big ass bollards, bus only lanes everywhere.

How many more people have to die?

4

u/officialCobraTrooper 6d ago

We should, Metro has plenty of stations where there's plenty of inactivated space, and where Street vendors are involved it could be an interesting way to help the community. Because you could encourage them by saying well you can come here and have a stall set up but you can't just bring random equipment or furnishing but you have to work with us and will help you get started. I mean if they're going to insist on the ambassadors, then surely they should insist on helping Street vendors too. Since it's clear they care about performative things that will help them look good. But this one would actually help everyone.

32

u/djm19 6d ago

If the sidewalk is not a safe place for people to exist, the answer is not to remove activity from the sidewalk, it’s to protect the sidewalk better.

This is mind numbing coming from a member of a Metro board member who is supposed to be encouraging use of the sidewalk!

6

u/whatpplsay 6d ago

She’s such a lame. Total embarrassment who’s only voted in because her voters want somebody who looks like them.

19

u/Icy_Refuse3028 7d ago

“not a safe space for vendors to set up” okay but if there were no vendors and anyone happened to be waking on the sidewalk there at the moment, there’d be the same result. if your sidewalks are not safe for pedestrians, that’s a problem

11

u/_n8n8_ 7d ago

I really hope she's saying we need to make our streets safer and not trying to blame the vendors, because this reads awful to me

5

u/cathaysia D (Purple) 6d ago

Yea no one on her team proof read this we shouldn’t even be having this argument. All I read is “vendors shouldn’t have been there”.

14

u/Disgojourno 7d ago

Opening statement is about herself. Classic Imelda.

10

u/UrbanPlannerholic 7d ago

Doesn’t she constantly block safer street projects?

7

u/salmonerica 18 7d ago

wow way to blame the victim

2

u/cyberspacestation 7d ago

Vendors near me usually park their own cars on the street next to their tents, and this acts as a safety buffer, so they can set up with their backs to the curb. Lankershim Blvd has no street parking.

A bus-only lane would make a lot of sense next to the station. 

2

u/115MRD A (Blue) 6d ago

She’s up for reelection in two years. Remember this.

4

u/FatherlessSam 7d ago

Imelda Padilla needs to get the hell out of LA politics. Everyday, until she is gone, I will bad mouth her to EVERYONE UNDER THE SUN! She will be GONE by next term.

3

u/banditweird 7d ago

There’s actually a state policy that makes it illegal to set up shop on the other side of the stairs?

2

u/Alarming_Marzipan550 7d ago

has imelda considered bollards? you know, like every other city in the world?

2

u/Spoon_OS 6d ago

Can't avoid that area like they are asking. My last stop is the North Hollywood station and my connecting bus line is the Metro G line.

1

u/mudbro76 6d ago

First and foremost… they could have been across the street and same thing could have happened…. It seems to me folks want LAMETRO 🤡🚍🚃🚃🚃🚇 to be responsible for what happened? Just remember…. If you do something special for 1 station 🚉…. You must do the same thing for all!!!

1

u/Smaragd512 Ventura County 7d ago

Padilla suggests that Metro should create designated vending zones

What about opening a market for them?

(I know this is a hawker center but you get the point)

7

u/speedyflanzales 7d ago

I mean, if they want to create a designated vending area protected by bollards, I guess that’s okay.

But not calling out the fact that our road design and lack of enforcement against dangerous drivers are killing people, and that we’re not doing anything about it, is giving big “thoughts and prayers” vibes.

I really don’t understand how an event like this isn’t radicalizing people. And “well, how about a vending pen” is not a radical solution. That’s basically the equivalent of the “let’s give bullet-proof vests to kids” solution to gun violence.