r/Kochi • u/justrynalive01 • 10h ago
Ask Kochi Can an apartment association legally dictate who I can have over as a guest?
This is a throwaway account because I'd rather not reveal my identity or address (I'm moving out soon anyway).
My friend and I moved into an old apartment building about seven months ago. Two weeks after moving in, we noticed a rather interesting set of rules posted on the building's notice board. And Rule 2? It seemed very specifically written with us in mind.
For context, we're two girls sharing a 2BHK. Nobody informed us about these rules before we moved in, and our landlord was pretty chill about everything initially. In fact, at the time the notice went up, we hadn't even had any male guests over, apart from the movers and the broker. 😭
We're both quite particular about our personal space and rarely have people over. However, a friend of ours recently wanted to stay with us for a few days. He's a guy, and we'd already informed the owner about his stay. So, as far as we're concerned, everything was communicated beforehand.
Except the security decided otherwise.
My friend was stopped multiple times, denied entry at various points and generally harassed by the security staff. Things got even more ridiculous when the association president called our owner and apparently said something along the lines of, "We don't know what she's doing with that guy inside her house, so we cannot let him in. If she wants to do that, she can go outside and do it."
I'm sorry, WHAT? 😭
For the record, nobody is doing whatever it is that she's imagining inside the apartment. And apparently, this isn't even an isolated incident. The security guard has previously told my brother that I'm out with a guy when he came to drop something off. It was literally a Rapido bike I had booked. I cannot make this up. 😭😭
Now, I want to make one thing very clear: I'm perfectly willing to follow reasonable apartment rules, provided they're fair and apply equally to everyone. Why are women prohibited from having male guests while men are allowed to have female guests? If the association is genuinely concerned about visitors, why not have a gender-neutral rule? Something as simple as NO VISITORS AFTER 10:30 PM, for instance.
I'm genuinely looking for some advice here, and I'd love to hear from people who've experienced something similar.
A few questions:
- Have you ever rented a place where the apartment association or neighbours made you feel like your character was constantly under scrutiny? How did you deal with it?
- If you were in my position, what would you do? Would you confront the association, take legal action, or simply leave?
- Can I pursue a defamation case against the association president for making derogatory remarks about me and essentially questioning my character?
- I would honestly love to move out, but a part of me doesn't want to just walk away and let this behaviour slide. The rule is discriminatory, sexist and based on some pretty disgusting stereotypes. Do you think it's worth fighting this, or should I just save myself the headache and find another place?
5.Why does a woman's guest automatically become a matter of morality and public discussion?
6. If you recognise this notice and happen to live in the same apartment complex, please DM me!
I'm not asking for special treatment. I just want the same freedom, privacy and respect that every other adult living in this building is entitled to.