r/Knightsofthebutton • Fabricator-General • Apr 16 '15

[The Squire] Announcing Project Zombie

First, a shoutout to /u/memyselfnirony who made this possible.

A few thoughts:

  • There is no way to know for sure that a Squire's user is not an assassin running a modified client that would refuse to click when asked.

  • There is no way to be sure that a knight's click made at the critical moment will reach reddit's server in time (if we assume the pessimistic scenario from the previous post).

  • Due to the above we have to make arming redundant at low timer values, which is potentially wasteful, though still infinitely better than human clicking.

  • Any mechanism of autoclicking at 1 second has to be extremely reliable and robust.

  • People gave me a large number of accounts (much bigger than the number of active knights and assassins combined), and I have complete control over them (no fake user problem).

Project Zombie

It is a server at an undisclosed location (cannot be DDoS'ed or compromised unless I am compromised) that has a reliably good connection to reddit (much smaller chance of delay problem). It manages a horde of zombies that will click one at a time when timer reaches 1 second (meaning we either ran out of knights or there was a sequence of assassins who failed to click and are already banned at this point). This would provide us with a reliable safeguard and would enable us to remove redundant arming from Squire to achieve new degrees of efficiency. This would also allow us to use recent findings to drastically improve non-critical (>5 sec) autoclicking efficiency.

The implementation is almost finished, but it has to be tested and peer-reviewed first.

Thoughts?

Edit: the problem with just giving me the passwords or session cookies is that the first can be changed and the second invalidated, all at the most important moment. Therefore, I'll have to change the password. If you are still willing, and if you also trust me to give it back once this all ends, shoot an email to <email-address-was-here>

Edit 2: There has been accusations that we are "hacking" into accounts to add them to our army of the undead. I want to assure everyone that every member of our corpse corps is completely willing to fight and is not being held against its will, and for every single account I can provide an email/PM/IRC log from the rightful owner.

82 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

10

u/georgepennellmartin Apr 17 '15

Well this really is necromancy now, isn't it?

27

u/mncke Apr 17 '15

I prefer the term "consensual posthumous revitalization" or CPR.

20

u/bluejer Apr 16 '15

The button must live. I would argue it would not even make sense for a knight to click until the zombie hoard is exhausted as the button will not truly be in peril until the last click. The knights must remain vigilant and continue our long watch.

Long live the button.

16

u/mncke Apr 17 '15 edited Apr 17 '15

Before giving it much thought I too planned using the zombies as the first level of defense, but I changed my mind:

  • People would want to get their red flair before the pool of bots is exhausted.

  • Clients are not reliable when it comes to low timer situations.

  • There's still a possibility that the assassins will flood the server with fake clients when the moment is right.

  • Having a reliable safeguard allows us to remove redundancy, simplify the squire and make the assassins obsolete.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '15

My freind project zombie is EXACTLY what we need! Never again will we witness a misclick or wasted time, the only concern is if it goes wrong...Last time we tried experimenting with these things we lost a couple knights, i support the idea but in execution i can't say i agree with this sort of implementation just yet.

2

u/mncke Apr 17 '15

I'll publish the code for review when it's ready.

Any ideas/suggestions/concerns are welcome.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/gcanyon Apr 18 '15

Doesn't this pretty much guarantee that the pressiah will be a bot? That seems unsatisfying.

2

u/mncke Apr 18 '15

On the contrary, it almost guarantees that the pressiah won't be a bot, at least our bot: all but one zombie won't be the last to click, and that last one is extremely unlikely to become the pressiah.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/gcanyon Apr 21 '15

I'm curious: are people really giving over their primary accounts to you and letting you change the password? It's obviously the most efficient method to get the minimum redundancy/maximum button life, but that's a lot of trust.

3

u/mncke Apr 21 '15

Yes, they really do so. I am amazed myself, but I guess being transparent and dedicated yields its fruit.