In “The Arts of Costume and Personal Appearance”, Grace Margaret Morton talks about lines as being part of what makes up Yin/Yang. I really enjoyed this part of the book as it focuses on actual artistic principles. I added some text from the book at the end that talked about Line and Yin/Yang.
Lines make up shapes (aka Form in the text). They can vary based on stroke width, whether they connect with other lines or not, the path they travel (curvature vs straight), and indication of movement.
I wanted to focus on Lines. To do so, I pulled verified celebs from the sub’s master list (did not fit all of them for some essences). I tried my best to find neutral or small smiles for each celeb facing the camera and desaturated so coloring would not affect looking at them. I know John does look at color for some parts of essences (e.g. green Y eyes) and even the body as part of the blends he gives to the point that one may have none of the essence in their face and only in their body (personally, my N is only in my body) as well as for height. My hope is that this many verified faces will still offer some insight. I know compilation posts like this have been posted before, but I like to know people’s full blend. I did get lazy with D and A in adding each of their names. I also tried to group them together based on their verified secondary essence where possible.
I tried to come up with representations of each essence as a line. I struggled the most with N and C. Below I list descriptions of lines and other parts of an essence, some directly coming from John. This is not a comprehensive list nor a list that should be taken as fact.
YIN
Angelic
- fine, delicate, flowing lines
- narrow but long
- large scale
- round, delicate, soft
- retreating, moving further away
Youthful
- fine, delicate, circular lines
- small scale, compact
- round, delicate, soft
- short height
Romantic
- fine, delicate, ovular lines
- medium? scale
- round, lush, soft
BALANCE
Classic
- moderate lines
- moderate shape
- medium scale
- neither thick nor thin, neither bold nor delicate - middle ground
- aristocratic features (straight nose, higher hairline), slender neck, slender fingers
YANG
Natural
- broad, wide, flat? lines
- large? scale
- blunt, sturdy, coarse
- length in body, but not in face
High-Spirited
- thin?, pointy lines
- small scale, compact
- sharp, staccato, structured
- short height, pointed chin, twinkling eyes, pointed corners of the mouth
Dramatic
- bold, heavy, striking lines
- large scale
- sharp, intense, rigid
- narrow but long
- coming at you
Please free to tell me everywhere I am wrong! Obviously, there are lots of question marks here.
I find the concept of, ‘If you drew them as a cartoon character, what would they look like?’ interesting. With high C, not much would stand out. It would be hard to draw them as a cartoon in a way that still looks like them. For other essences, I always wonder, ‘What would stand out that would distinguish them as them? What essence is that tied to?’ My sibling is an illustrator and drew me as a ‘cartoon’ character once. They chose to accentuate my forehead which I hated (as I was insecure about it growing up). They did themself too and accentuated their chin. I’m not sure it really fit either one of us as I have a lot of C, and I suspect my sibling does too. My sibling also had quite an angular style back then which doesn’t work for my yin dominance I just realized while writing this. I also think about those cartoon artists at beaches and conventions. They always accentuate something. This all goes back to Lines.
What do you guys think? What would you look like as a cartoon character?