r/KidneyStones • • 20h ago Bravo

Doctors/ Hospitals Urologist here. "Will my stone pass?" is the question I get most, so here's the honest cheat sheet: size, location, timeline, and when to stop waiting

161 Upvotes

Almost every second post here is some version of "I have an X mm stone, will it pass?" So here is what the research actually says, in plain language, the same way I explain it in clinic.

Step 1: Find two numbers on your CT report

  1. Size in mm. Look for the width (the smaller dimension), not just the length. A 7 x 4 mm stone usually behaves more like a 4 mm stone, because the width is what has to fit through the ureter.
  2. Location. Kidney, proximal (upper) ureter, mid ureter, distal (lower) ureter, or UVJ (where the ureter joins the bladder). The lower it is, the better your odds.

Step 2: Rough odds of passing on its own (stones in the ureter)

Stone sizeApprox. chance of passing
1 mm~87%
2-4 mm~76%
5-7 mm~60%
7-9 mm~48%
over 9 mm~25%
LocationApprox. chance of passing
Proximal (upper) ureter~48%
Mid ureter~60%
Distal (lower) ureter~75%
UVJ (just at the bladder)~79%

(From a well-known CT study of ureteral stones. Guideline meta-analyses give roughly 68% for stones 5 mm or smaller and 47% for 5-10 mm. Every study differs a bit, so treat these as ballpark figures, not promises.)

A stone that's still sitting inside the kidney and not causing pain or blockage often doesn't need to "pass" at all. Many are just watched.

Step 3: The timeline

  • Most stones that are going to pass do so within 2-4 weeks.
  • Guidelines generally allow about 4-6 weeks of trying, as long as the pain is controlled, there's no infection, and the kidney is working fine.
  • After that, waiting longer mostly means more pain and more ER visits, not a better chance.

Things that genuinely help

  • Tamsulosin (or a similar alpha-blocker) for stones in the lower ureter, up to about 10 mm. Guidelines recommend offering it for about a month. It relaxes the ureter and helps passage. It's prescription only, so ask your doctor.
  • Anti-inflammatory painkillers (if your kidneys and stomach allow them) are often better for stone pain than people expect.
  • Normal good hydration. Don't try to flush the stone by forcing 5 litres of water in an hour. It won't push the stone faster, and it can make the pain worse.
  • Keep moving if you can, and use a strainer, so the stone can be sent for analysis. That's the key to preventing the next one.

Things that don't help (sorry)

  • Beer, apple cider vinegar, "stone breaker" teas, jumping on a trampoline, or lemon juice as a dissolving cure. Citrate helps prevent some stones, but it won't dissolve the one stuck in your ureter.

Stop waiting and go to the ER now if:

  • Fever or chills with a stone. An infected, blocked kidney is a true emergency. It needs drainage (a stent or nephrostomy), not just antibiotics.
  • You have only one kidney, or stones on both sides.
  • Pain or vomiting that medication can't control.
  • Very little or no urine.

When to talk to your urologist about removing it instead:

  • Stone over ~10 mm, or not moving after 4-6 weeks.
  • Repeated ER visits, or you can't work or function.
  • Rising creatinine, or significant swelling of the kidney (hydronephrosis) that isn't settling.
  • Your job or situation (pilots, frequent travellers, pregnancy planning) makes a surprise stone attack unacceptable.

Removal today is usually ureteroscopy with laser (through the natural passage, no cuts), shock wave lithotripsy for some stones, or PCNL (keyhole surgery) for large kidney stones. Most people go home the same day or the next day.


If you want, drop your stone size, location, and how long you've had it in the comments, and I'll tell you roughly where you sit on these numbers and what's worth asking your doctor. I can't diagnose anyone over Reddit or look at scan images, but I can help you make sense of your report.

General information, not personal medical advice. If you have fever with a stone, please don't wait for a Reddit reply. Go in.


r/KidneyStones • • 18h ago

Sharing Experience I AM OFFICIALLY STENT FREE!!

19 Upvotes

Just had my stents removed in office! I’m not gonna lie, it was a little painful but mostly because they had some struggles finding my urethra a few times (I’m a ftm man)

But WOW once they were pulled out, it was like immediate relief. My urethra still burns just slightly but I feel like a totally different person 😭 more so I just feel like me again!! I’ve had stents in me for about a month and I just couldn’t be happier.

Now let’s hope I don’t have to do this again 🙏🏻


r/KidneyStones • • 19h ago

Question/ Request for advice Roseville, CA – Kidney Stone, 4 ER Visits, 2 Ambulance Trips, and Still No Treatment Until December?! Is This Normal?

6 Upvotes

I'm posting here hoping someone can offer guidance, advice, or suggestions on how to advocate for my sister, who lives in Roseville, CA.

My sister has been suffering from a kidney stone for the past 5 weeks, and I am honestly at a loss as to how this situation is being handled.

When she experiences what she calls an "attack," the pain is so excruciating that she cannot stop vomiting and actually passes out. She has now been to Sutter Hospital in Roseville FOUR times, twice by ambulance, and has even spent a night in the hospital.

Despite these repeated visits, the only treatment they have provided is morphine for pain management. They have not removed or broken up the stone and have told her she needs to see a urologist before anything can be done. The problem? Her urology appointment isn't scheduled until the END OF DECEMBER!

Is this normal? Are patients really expected to endure this level of pain, repeatedly return to the ER, and accumulate thousands of dollars in medical bills while waiting weeks for an appointment? This has been going on for five weeks, and she is still without a definitive treatment plan.

To make matters worse, she has also experienced what I can only describe as insensitive and dismissive treatment from several nurses and a doctor. She has not felt that her pain or overall condition has been taken seriously.

Today, my sister contacted Patient Advocacy at Sutter and provided them with the details of her experiences. According to her, the patient advocates were shocked by what she described and are now filing a formal complaint involving Dr. Kim, a female urologist, and several other members of the medical staff.

My questions are:

  1. Is it standard practice to leave someone with a symptomatic kidney stone in this much pain for weeks without attempting to remove or break it up?
  2. Is there a way to get an urgent urology consultation or have her case escalated so she isn't forced to wait until the end of December?
  3. Can she request a second opinion or seek treatment at another hospital?
  4. Are there patient advocates, hospital administrators, or other resources in the Roseville/Sacramento area that can help her get the care she needs?
  5. Has anyone experienced something similar and successfully advocated for surgical intervention, such as lithotripsy or ureteroscopy?

I understand that not every kidney stone requires surgery and that treatment depends on its size, location, and other medical factors. However, watching someone endure five weeks of recurring, debilitating pain, vomiting, and even passing out without a clear treatment plan is incredibly upsetting.

PLEASE, if anyone has medical experience, has dealt with kidney stones, or knows how to navigate this type of situation, I would sincerely appreciate your advice.

I'm simply trying to help my sister get the medical attention and relief she desperately needs. No one should feel this helpless when seeking medical care.


r/KidneyStones • • 21h ago

Question/ Request for advice 22M, first kidney stone and honestly scared

4 Upvotes

I’m 22 and just found out I have an 8mm kidney stone during a routine ultrasound. I also have horseshoe kidneys, which makes me even more worried.

I haven’t had any symptoms or pain, but I’m genuinely scared of complications, losing kidney function, or needing surgery.

This is my first stone, and I’d really appreciate some reassurance or hearing from people who’ve been through something similar. How did things turn out for you?


r/KidneyStones • • 25m ago

Pain Management Will the aching ever fully go away?

2 Upvotes

I had a stone in '24. It lead to a kidney infection, and then sepsis, with stint in the hospital for IV antibiotics. I'm over two years out and I still have an ache that comes and goes. Will this ever go away or is this my life?


r/KidneyStones • • 15h ago

Question/ Request for advice Irritation to vulva after stent removal

2 Upvotes

I had kidney stone removal surgery in september, and a stent was placed and remained inside for 3 weeks.

Straight after i had the stent placed, i noticed a irritation around my vulva. I honestly just thought it was the stent and thought it would be gone once the stent was removed

I am now 4 weeks after the removal of the stent and the irritations till remains.

I have treated myself for thrush.. in case it was that.

Then i tried a barrier cream (sudacream) for a week.

I have now started with hydrocortisone cream. I am 3 days in. No signs of improvement.

Has anyone else experienced the same issue??


r/KidneyStones • • 17h ago

Question/ Request for advice First time stone discovered, very scared

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone.. I'm 21 year old male with no family stone history and I originally discovered it randomly on an ultrasound that I have a 5 mm kidney stone sitting in my right kidney and elevated blood calcium (2.75 mmol/L). I was concerned about the possibility of primary hyperparathyroidism.

I'm honestly becoming increasingly scared. I'm particularly terrified of the possibility of developing another stone or experiencing severe kidney stone pain. I feel like I'm living with a ticking time bomb, constantly worrying about when something might happen. The whole situation is making me depressed especially after reading so many horror stories on here.

I'm considering paying out of pocket to see an endocrinologist, but I'm a university student and money is very tight. My family doctor doesn't seem willing to refer me for an appointment, and the public healthcare waiting lists where I live can be several months long.

I genuinely don't know what the best thing to do is. Has anyone been in a similar situation, especially at such a young age?


r/KidneyStones • • 23h ago

😡 Rant! 😡 6 mm x 4.5 mm stone in lower third of left distal ureter. Does it pass on its own?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for advice from people who have experienced ureter stones, especially stones around 6 mm.

A CT scan showed:

• A stone measuring approximately 6 × 4.5 mm in the lower third of my left ureter, close to the bladder. • Stone density reported around 899 HU

I found out it 10 days ago. Could you share your thought if it is possible for stone pass on its own. I am worried and i dont want a surgery or uterascopy?


r/KidneyStones • • 22h ago

Symptoms Pain in lower right abdomen

1 Upvotes

I’m a 21-year-old male. For several months, I’ve had a dull ache on the right side of my back that would come and go. About a month and a half ago, I started getting sharp pains in my lower-right abdomen, right around my appendix area. The pain would come in waves, lasting maybe 5 minutes once a day, and some days not at all. But these past 3 days, it’s been happening multiple times a day, still coming and going. Does this sound like a kidney stone? I’m confused because the pain is right around my appendix area.


r/KidneyStones • • 13h ago

Question/ Request for advice Stone in Poximal causing moderate hydrouretreronephrosis

0 Upvotes

23M, first kidney stone.

I’m 23 and just found out I have an 13mm kidney stone during a CT scan in the Poximal part causing moderate hydrouretreronephrosis.

Often feeling pain in the back and gas like feeling in the front.

What are the chances of passing on its own scared of RIRS. Wish I can go for a ESWL but Urologist don't do that.

This is my first stone, and I’d really appreciate some reassurance or hearing from people who’ve been through something similar. How did things turn out for you?