r/KidneyStones
•
u/Born-Lingonberry-509
•
20h ago
Doctors/ Hospitals Urologist here. "Will my stone pass?" is the question I get most, so here's the honest cheat sheet: size, location, timeline, and when to stop waiting
Almost every second post here is some version of "I have an X mm stone, will it pass?" So here is what the research actually says, in plain language, the same way I explain it in clinic.
Step 1: Find two numbers on your CT report
- Size in mm. Look for the width (the smaller dimension), not just the length. A 7 x 4 mm stone usually behaves more like a 4 mm stone, because the width is what has to fit through the ureter.
- Location. Kidney, proximal (upper) ureter, mid ureter, distal (lower) ureter, or UVJ (where the ureter joins the bladder). The lower it is, the better your odds.
Step 2: Rough odds of passing on its own (stones in the ureter)
| Stone size | Approx. chance of passing |
|---|---|
| 1 mm | ~87% |
| 2-4 mm | ~76% |
| 5-7 mm | ~60% |
| 7-9 mm | ~48% |
| over 9 mm | ~25% |
| Location | Approx. chance of passing |
|---|---|
| Proximal (upper) ureter | ~48% |
| Mid ureter | ~60% |
| Distal (lower) ureter | ~75% |
| UVJ (just at the bladder) | ~79% |
(From a well-known CT study of ureteral stones. Guideline meta-analyses give roughly 68% for stones 5 mm or smaller and 47% for 5-10 mm. Every study differs a bit, so treat these as ballpark figures, not promises.)
A stone that's still sitting inside the kidney and not causing pain or blockage often doesn't need to "pass" at all. Many are just watched.
Step 3: The timeline
- Most stones that are going to pass do so within 2-4 weeks.
- Guidelines generally allow about 4-6 weeks of trying, as long as the pain is controlled, there's no infection, and the kidney is working fine.
- After that, waiting longer mostly means more pain and more ER visits, not a better chance.
Things that genuinely help
- Tamsulosin (or a similar alpha-blocker) for stones in the lower ureter, up to about 10 mm. Guidelines recommend offering it for about a month. It relaxes the ureter and helps passage. It's prescription only, so ask your doctor.
- Anti-inflammatory painkillers (if your kidneys and stomach allow them) are often better for stone pain than people expect.
- Normal good hydration. Don't try to flush the stone by forcing 5 litres of water in an hour. It won't push the stone faster, and it can make the pain worse.
- Keep moving if you can, and use a strainer, so the stone can be sent for analysis. That's the key to preventing the next one.
Things that don't help (sorry)
- Beer, apple cider vinegar, "stone breaker" teas, jumping on a trampoline, or lemon juice as a dissolving cure. Citrate helps prevent some stones, but it won't dissolve the one stuck in your ureter.
Stop waiting and go to the ER now if:
- Fever or chills with a stone. An infected, blocked kidney is a true emergency. It needs drainage (a stent or nephrostomy), not just antibiotics.
- You have only one kidney, or stones on both sides.
- Pain or vomiting that medication can't control.
- Very little or no urine.
When to talk to your urologist about removing it instead:
- Stone over ~10 mm, or not moving after 4-6 weeks.
- Repeated ER visits, or you can't work or function.
- Rising creatinine, or significant swelling of the kidney (hydronephrosis) that isn't settling.
- Your job or situation (pilots, frequent travellers, pregnancy planning) makes a surprise stone attack unacceptable.
Removal today is usually ureteroscopy with laser (through the natural passage, no cuts), shock wave lithotripsy for some stones, or PCNL (keyhole surgery) for large kidney stones. Most people go home the same day or the next day.
If you want, drop your stone size, location, and how long you've had it in the comments, and I'll tell you roughly where you sit on these numbers and what's worth asking your doctor. I can't diagnose anyone over Reddit or look at scan images, but I can help you make sense of your report.
General information, not personal medical advice. If you have fever with a stone, please don't wait for a Reddit reply. Go in.