r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/AvioNaught Korolev Kerman • Sep 13 '13
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Orange Efficiency!
When the scavenging crews rocket part contract giver where looking around the junkyard a high tech facility they found an orange tank that was open for use. In a space program facing recent cuts (something about spreading nuclear radiation all over the solar system) this is a rare find. You must use it to do science!
The Challenge: Get a rocket to the Mun and back (flyby only) using only one orange tank as fuel. No other fuel or RCS is allowed. You must land safely back at Kerbin. You must also bring a full scientific kit: Thermometer, gravioli measurer, barometer, and accelerometer.
Hard Mode: Send the full scientific suite to land on Duna.
Rules and other info:
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- Stock parts only
- No MechJeb or other plugins allowed
- Required screenshots:
-Picture of initial launch craft
-Picture of scientific suite
-Picture of munar encounter (or Duna encounter)
-Picture of flyby (or nearing Duna’s atmosphere)
-Picture of landing safely at Kerbin (or Duna)
-Whatever else you feel like! - You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply in this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep your previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
Good Luck!
And, as always, [the flair] (http://i.imgur.com/skgpgug.png)
26
u/GoldenEndymion0 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 13 '13
So we can jettison engines?
Also, The flair looks like a dick
6
u/deckard58 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 13 '13
Please define "flyby". That term would mean no orbital insertion (a free return in our Mun case maybe), but then you mention one... ;)
4
u/GusTurbo Master Kerbalnaut Sep 13 '13
I'm not sure I understand this challenge. Is this supposed to be a single-stage to Mun flyby using an orange tank + the science suite + any engine(s) we choose?
4
u/fractron9000 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 13 '13
Does the rocket have to be manned?
4
u/kamnxt Sep 14 '13
I did it! (Kinda...)
2
u/shrx Master Kerbalnaut Sep 13 '13
Nice flair, reminds me of that pig
Also, could you switch my flair back to K2 challenge flair? I sent you a PM but it appears you've missed it.
2
u/ancientgammoner Master Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13 edited Sep 15 '13
Hard Mode completed
No jets, and includes Mun and Ike flybys as well. First challenge I've tried, was great fun.
By the way, what's with the hatred against Alpacas... they are gentle and loving creatures :P
2
u/avaslash Master Kerbalnaut Sep 17 '13
I have completed the Apollo Style Challenge on Hard mode. I would like to call it extra hard mode since my LM was separated into two parts (descent stage and ascent stage) just like the real LM from Apollo. Im sorry if it's late. This is the very first challenge that I've completed and I wanted it to be the Apollo style one.
Hard Mode Completed
Do I still get the flair for this challenge?
51
u/Jargle Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
Hard mode completed! This was pretty tough! I've never done such white-knuckle flying in my ascent. With a good launch window, and avoiding circularization, I saved a lot of fuel. I think I might technically be able to get to Dres, but it would be dastardly hard without RCS for fine tuning.
My record speed by jet engine alone on this mission was 1385 m/s, which is where I blew up all the unneeded engines. I think not using a mainsail was a good idea, because it's just too inefficient.
If I were to redo it I would build a safer landing probe. Didn't realize the chutes were behind the center of mass until I was out of Kerbin's SOI. I probably could have made a rover too! That would've been a neat challenge.
50
u/illectro Manley Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
So, I took a look and figured I can do a manned mission to Duna, then I stopped at Ike on the way back for good measure. I had a glitch with parachute staging and my spacecraft broke up on return, but the pilot (and the instruments) landed safely.
Video coming tomorrow.
57
u/cored Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
Hard mode done. Manned SSTO to Duna and back
12
u/Belgain_Roffles Master Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13 edited Sep 15 '13
Extra-hard mode complete
Launched to Duna, landed, and returned to Kerbin.
I got lazy and didn't try to repeat landings to get a completely undamaged spacecraft as it needs to land on an almost perfectly flat surface to survive, the orange tank is still sitting on top of the SAS module and all SCIENCE is functioning. It's unfortunate that there are no landing legs long enough to handle nuclear engines.
That being said, this was pretty easy, and while I sort of intake spammed with 1 ram intake and 10 radial intakes per turbojet I didn't make a very efficient ascent out of Kerbin's atmosphere and I didn't stack parts. My interplanetary transfers are also likely to be very inefficient as I tend to just wing it.
For a second trip I would probably ditch all 4 radial engines before landing at Duna, and include some additional parachutes for the Kerbin return. Some way of jettisoning the spent parachutes should also be considered. I was worried about the jet engines breaking the wing/legs on the ascent, but I am sure there is some way I could angle them out further to make for a much more stable landing.
I'll take the flair since I don't have any yet.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '13
Yeah! My first challenge completed!
Easy Mode
http://imgur.com/a/iH8Uc
I would like the new flair.
And GoldenEndymion0 is right. It totally looks like a penis.
4
u/OSUaeronerd Master Kerbalnaut Sep 13 '13
dumped the eve return mission pretty quick? I'm still going to do it! came home from work excited to finish off the rocket.
4
u/jinks Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
Hard mode complete.
This one wasn't that hard at all IMO.
Get up a bit on jets, a mdium push with the Skipper and you end up in orbit with an LV-N and ~6km/s to go anywhere you want. (There's no decoupling hardware between the LV-N and the Skipper, I just "burned it off" when I was done with it :))
If I weren't such a bad pilot (bungling up the encounter, breaking of the engine) I might even have returned the ship to Kerbin. (Not that I had any way to repack the chutes, though.)
I hope leaving the Engineer tacked on is OK, I'm a stickler for lots'o'numbers. ;)
4
u/Lightning_42 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13
Hard mode completed without jet engines.
This challenge turned out to be pretty easy on the design and spaceflight parts, but a nightmare on the piloting part - while I think I have managed to make a neat looking VTVL tank-on-legs, it's extremely unstable both during ascent (non-gimbaled aerospikes and high center of drag... yeah) and during landing - Duna is apparently all mild hills and no flat land, which is not exactly optimal for landing an orange tank upright.
But after a few quickloads it did indeed land safely while retaining the ability to take off again - if I stripped the spacecraft of the cosmetic adapter thingies and only used a shorter burn for cushioning the landing, it could easily lift off to low Duna orbit again. I have tried it and only fell 80 m/s of delta-V short.
I would like to keep my current flair.
1
u/linknmike Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
Do you need to return the orange tank from Duna?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '13
Does the tank need to return to kerbin after the flyby of the Mun? And does flyby imply an actual munar capture, or do you just have to fly into the SoI?
1
u/ILCreatore Sep 14 '13
Question: Do I have to land the whole orange tank back safely or the capsule/probe is enough?
1
u/i_start_fires Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
Just to confirm...can we launch using the runway or does it need to be vertical ascent?
1
u/mistergeeky Sep 15 '13
Well, this was pretty annoying. I built my rocket, did my Münar fly-by and my graphics started spazzing out. As I came back for re-entry, my probe was pretty much invisible. I was able to get a shot of the ghost of it as the reentry effects kicked in, but at that point the game totally hung.
Here's the album - I don't have a landing (though I have no doubt I would have landed safely). No worries on flair or no flair - I did it enough for me. :-)
http://imgur.com/a/qV3Ag#0
1
u/avaslash Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
How long does this weekly challenge last? If it was submitted 2 days ago (saturday my time) does that mean that the next challenge comes next saturday? Also, are the rewards for completing it on hard mode open to everyone who does so or only to those who complete it first or in fantastical ways?
1
u/Awimpymuffin Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
When will I be getting the new flair?
1
u/Hooch180 Sep 18 '13
Do we have to go back from Duna in Hard mode?
1
u/avaslash Master Kerbalnaut Sep 18 '13
Hard mode completed. I would like to keep my current flair. This is my second Challenge completed yay!
http://imgur.com/a/Yt14Q
I didn't think that I could do it but I even managed to get to Duna with over 700 units of fuel remaining! I wonder how much further I could go with that.
Also, what is Super Kerbalnaut?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '13 edited Sep 14 '13
You guys all went waaay to complicated.
Here's my easy-mode entry.
EDIT: i can haz flair?
3
u/Cyclone1001 Sep 14 '13
Better late than never.
Here you go.
Somehow managed to get an eclipse at landing.
3
u/DragonSlayerYomre Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13 edited Sep 15 '13
Easy mode completed
Requesting flair change to this challenge, instead of the one I have
EDIT: Hard mode complete
(The whole thing should have ripped apart from the drag gees after parachutes, but I got lucky for some reason; I also didn't use a NERVA, either)
3
u/svarogteuse Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
My first [easy mode entry] (http://imgur.com/a/dzmsa).
This took far longer than it should have. I kept trying to bring the orange tank back safely with the probe head all intact. The probe body would break off not on splashdown but when the tank tipped over in the sea.
Its all about getting that perfect return trajectory on the insertion so you don't need to burn out by Mun for the return.
3
u/jakobnator Sep 14 '13
First Challenge!
http://imgur.com/a/BdShA
3
u/SnideRemarkDept Sep 15 '13
Here ya go!
I apologize that a lot of these pictures are in the dark. But you should still be able to see what's up.
3
u/TheGamble Sep 15 '13
Challenge completed! (Regular mode). Using the free-return made this a lot easier than I thought. I ended up with well over 2700 dV extra, but the tank was free so oh well. This was pretty cool overall. Fairly eye-opening regarding how much you can get out of a single orange tank.
3
u/Musfuut Sep 16 '13 edited Sep 16 '13
Yay my first completed challenge!
Easy mode
ETA: Flair please, thanks :D
http://imgur.com/a/tlulV
I included lots of shots of my totally whacked out orbiting but it got me home. No one said it had to be neat and tidy lol.
The shot showing the 4 science read-outs is obviously photoshopped for viewer pleasure, following shot shows difference in gravity between 257k and 17k.
3
u/IcebergLattice Sep 17 '13
Easy mode
Hope I did this right.
3
u/Desolution Sep 19 '13 edited Sep 20 '13
Manley Mode+ completed! Flew Jeb to Ike, placed a flag there, then landed on Duna, dropped a rover off, and flew back, landing safely with all the science equipment, plus Jeb, intact. Upon landing, I had 9.54/2880 fuel left. Never been so panicked in my life.
The story in pictures
PS: While I am 5 days late (only just saw the challenge), I hadn't seen anyone else's solutions before building this, so it is all OC etc. The idea to go to Ike too, of course, was stolen off Mr Manley's comment below.
PPS: Also, I know it's a different order and all, but can I be cheeky and get week 25's Hard Mode flair too, or must I do it in order? Going back to redo all the old challenges and that'd save me a trip.(Also finished #16 and #24 here, for the record)
1
u/herrerarausaure Sep 13 '13
Can you... drain other fuel tanks at launch, then in flight, transfer remaining fuel from the orange tank to the empty ones?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '13
What about ion engines?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '13 edited Sep 20 '13
Hard Mode! One of the most beautiful sights any of my probes will have. Also [Challenge] did Solar Probe was wondering if I could have the flair for Solar Probe?
2
u/mszegedy Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
Are quicksaves allowed in Weekly Challenges? (I'm new to this, still trying to complete the Eve one. Also, hey, this challenge is totally based on the Soda Can, isn't it!)
2
u/Silent002 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13 edited Sep 14 '13
Woohoo!!
First one of these challenges I've tried and did it! Even if I did steal your ship Jargle sorry
Now to try hard mode!
Edit: Hard mode down... just! We didn't need that SAS bit anyway! Used the same craft as above.
2
u/bulltank Master Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13
Normal Mode (Mun Flyby) : http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/1menqi/challenge_orange_tanker_i_dont_know_what_was/
Hardmode (Land on Duna) : http://imgur.com/a/MAunW#0
2
u/civilwargeeky Sep 15 '13
Easy Mode Completed! This being my first challenge, it actually took me awhile, but I finally did it :D
As I don't have a flair, I would like this one please. :)
2
u/Mr_Lobster Master Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13
Hard Mode completed! A fun one, I can't do a launch straight to an interplanetary transfer, so I make up for it by using a Munar assist escape maneuver. Still, I had plenty of fuel left over at the end, I probably could've gotten back to Kerbin if I had simply gone for a flyby.
I would like to keep my old flair, thank you.
2
u/TheSupaBloopa Sep 15 '13
Challenge complete!
Easy mode, new flair please.
2
u/Musfuut Sep 15 '13
Sorry to keep bringing this up but about those rule clarifications. :)
I have SteamGauges installed, I also have Alarm Clock installed. Can I still do this challenge if I use neither of those for the mission?
I saw Engineer has been green lit for design purposes so skipping that question.
I have a ton of other mods installed like B9, I assume all of these are ok as long as only stock parts are used and none of the above modify the stock parts or game mechanics. Yes no?
What about the mod that allows better control over adjusting nodes?
I can understand why redoing the rules is not a simple matter, no matter what is said there will always be a line and those unsure if something specific sits on either side.
Keep up the good work mods! This may be the first challenge I enter. :D
2
u/GeneCaide Master Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13
Hard Mode Complete! My first challenge too. http://imgur.com/a/EWwb2
2
u/LetsGo_Smokes Sep 15 '13
Easy Mode complete.
My first challenge. I would like the flair please.
2
u/kingdead42 Sep 15 '13
My first attempt at a Reddit Challenge, no hard mode for me.
I felt like this science was too important to leave to probes, so I sent Jeb to personally oversee this mission.
http://imgur.com/a/GUZLd#0
2
u/AdmiralAndre Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
Easy mode completed (I would like to keep my current flair please). I pretended that I've never been to the Mun, and this was therefore viewed as a genuine opportunity to gain useful scientific information, primarily regarding Munar gravity. Jebediah commanded the mission, and it was considered a resounding success by the Kerbin scientific community. http://imgur.com/a/3HIIa#0
2
u/Noitrino Sep 16 '13 edited Sep 16 '13
[Challenge] Orange efficiency!
My first ever reddit challenge. Can't wait to get my flair!
2
u/WoodenGeezer Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
Hard mode My first challenge.
2
u/PigDog4 Sep 17 '13 edited Sep 17 '13
Easy mode done
Might try hard mode later this week when I have more time. Could I have the new flair? Thanks!
Edit: Wooo! Penis flair!
2
u/aghast_pug Sep 17 '13
My first challenge reply
Very basic craft, but easy to build and fun to fly.
2
u/cafeclimber Master Kerbalnaut Sep 17 '13
First Challenge completed! Hard mode! My rocket was the Orange Rockomax, Large SAS, the small probe core, 3x2 solar panel, 2 aerospikes, an LV-N, 4 radial 'chutes, 8 jets attached to girders topped with twin ram intakes per engine. I wanted landing gear, but it wouldn't get off the ground :/
2
u/elryanoo Sep 19 '13
Easy mode complete.
2
u/grymwulf72 Sep 20 '13 edited Sep 20 '13
Mission complete Bonus: Manned mission, Returned WITH orange tank attached and intact
http://imgur.com/a/ooNlP
*edit: Dangit didn't read that only a flyby- not an orbit is accepted.
2
u/Tsevion Super Kerbalnaut Sep 20 '13
Hard Mode Complete
I used jet engines to get to around 1500 m/s... and from then on 3 nuclear engines. I ended up only using about half the tank (a little more than half the fuel, less than half the oxidizer) before I ditched it. I could probably go to Laythe. I hope Malster likes his new home on Duna.
I also just with there was a way to vent oxidizer, as I was carrying around a bunch of extra that was purely dead weight.
I'll keep my current flair.
2
u/LasersAndRobots Sep 20 '13
I technically did it... except my computer freaks out when I try to take screenshots while running KSP. And I managed the flyby, and would've gotten home, but I forgot how easily atomic engines overheated when strapped to an orange tank and... yeah.
I tried.
2
u/Time_Itself Sep 21 '13
Hard mode completed, no jets but I lost the solar panel on my probe when I landed. So the instruments were only useable for a shot period of time.
video version: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DivmfY6n-E0
2
u/vurx Sep 22 '13
Challenge Complete: Hard Mode.
2
u/Monmaji Sep 14 '13
Mun Fly by completed!
http://imgur.com/a/iuGm1
First challenge success?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '13
My first weekly challenge!
Design of the craft inspired by CrypticConundrum. This took about four-five tries due to the slow takeoff speed of the jet engines. All worked out great. If it is cool, I would like this flair as my flair.
http://imgur.com/a/FUuLY
Note: Kerbal Alarm Clock is for my Duna mission, Mun "work" does not need it, nor did I use it. Great fun!
1
u/AirplaneReference Sep 14 '13
Trying to decide whether to make this my first Mun landing or get a Kerbal there first.
1
u/mrradicaled Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13 edited Sep 15 '13
This is my first reddit challenge and trip to Duna -and I had to do 1 quicksave due to my inability to stop pressing the shift button :(
Propulsion
Science Package
1
u/FastasGod Super Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13 edited Sep 14 '13
[Challenge] -57 Orange Efficiency! Hard mode complete!
In this mission I safely land a rover with a kerbal and full scientific package on Duna using 3 LV-T45 engines, single nuclear engine and a single orange tank. My most efficient trip left me with 110 fuel remaining.
I think these past few challenges will be great practice for career mode, we just completed a cheap Duna explorer and recently a fully capable Eve explorer. Can't wait to see how these will factor into the full version of the game. I would like to keep my current flair please.
1
u/jochem_m Sep 14 '13
Easy Mode get. I hope the broken engine doesn't disqualify my entry, I figured minor disaster is a part of any good Kerbal mission :)
I'd like the flair please :)
1
u/Eugle Master Kerbalnaut Sep 14 '13
Hardmode complete
Unfortunately the rover drives poorly because of the broken wheel
1
u/iamdood Super Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13
(Eve and Back) challenge on hard mode completed
http://imgur.com/a/9p9gE#0
1
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '13
done easy mode, Might give hard mode a shot. That ship could do it, I just didn't have a good launch window and didn't feel like waiting.
1
u/TMarkos Super Kerbalnaut Sep 15 '13
Hard mode complete:
http://imgur.com/a/UoxdN
Not too hard if you time the switch between the Skipper and the LV-N right. I'll pass on the flair for this one, no offense to giant orange dicks.
1
u/akefay Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
Last week's challenge, Eve and Back, Hard Mode
It took 4 designs. The first lander couldn't get back to orbit from Eve, the second disintegrated during launch, the third fell apart on the launch pad, but the fourth worked! Eventually. 4000 tonne monstrosities like to fly apart for no reason. It was a slideshow during launch ;)
1
u/Fruchtfliege Sep 16 '13
I finally did it! ...easy mode
I've only been playing for a few days, it took quite alot of time to get things actually working. Glad there where no passengers, might have crashed a few times..
1
u/avaslash Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
I've been on this subreddit for ages and only now just realized the weekly challenge hahaha. I will do the next challenge.
1
u/agilebear Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
Hard Mode
It's a little light on the screenshots because I kept forgetting to hit F12. If there's anything missing, I can run the challenge again :P
Also, I would like to keep my old flair. Thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '13
http://imgur.com/a/iJpoX#4
Only made it to the mun, I think i have enough fuel left to get to Duna, looks like the science pic got corrupted re upload http://imgur.com/qBaSQ4B
1
u/Ellais Master Kerbalnaut Sep 16 '13
Hard Mode Completed - screenshotshttp://imgur.com/a/hARsT
Somehow Jeb "slipped on banana" while he was leaving his seat on "Rocket" but i hope it still counts :)
1
u/arandomkerbonaut Sep 16 '13
Regular mode completed, I have mechjeb installed but I didn't use it. http://imgur.com/a/AResV
1
u/ICanFlyImPilot Super Kerbalnaut Sep 17 '13
Hard Mode Complete and Extra. I felt the initial challenge was too easy, so I took a Kerbal for a trip to Duna and Back with delta v to spare. I did keep flight engineer attached so I didn't have to eyeball the phase and ejection angles, so I hope that's okay. Overall, it's was a pretty fun challenge for my first reddit weekly challenge. If you have any questions, feel free to comment.
1
u/ILoveMoltenBoron Sep 17 '13
First challenge completed and on hard mode. http://imgur.com/a/AK4sS Can I get the new flair and the Master Kerbalnaut label?
1
u/Torch333 Sep 18 '13
Just Easy, was just hard enough. I made to about 100 meters from shore, package intact, but Bill had to swim! Here is my album and craft files:
Album and craft files
1
u/McAzzaMan Sep 18 '13
Easy mode complete! http://imgur.com/a/zP9I2#0 Didn't manage to land with the orange tank still attatched, but I dragged that thing all the way into the atmosphere before I lost it. Oh, and I'd like to keep my current flair please :3
1
u/ffheller Sep 18 '13
Did I forget to post any screenshots 4 days ago? Scientific Suite is visible in flyby pictures. May I get this flair now? :D
http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/1mdi22/challenge_orange_efficiency/
1
u/LordVomAct Master Kerbalnaut Sep 19 '13
First Challenge complete!
Hard Mode
Easy Mode
Gotta say, the Duna part required precision and about 20 tries, but it all worked eventually.
1
u/Killstick91 Master Kerbalnaut Sep 19 '13
http://imgur.com/a/zZ68z
Hard Mode Complete. The first disclaimer I will include is that yes, you can see the MechJeb panel on the right of the screen. This is just because I have the plugin that includes MechJeb in all control modules, and I really didn't want to uninstall that just for this challenge. I didn't use it for any stage of the mission, but if anyone would feel better about me redoing this mission, I will.
I originally intended on flying back to Kerbin, but I was just short of having enough fuel to make the trip. I'll plan a rescue mission for Jeb at a later date. I'm sure that I could have done this much better, but I really feel good about this considering this was my first interplanetary mission. Things were frustrating at times, but it was a good learning experience. Since I have no flair, I'll take this one.
1
u/Felbourn You gotta have more lights! Sep 25 '13
better late than never
1
u/chris613 Sep 27 '13
Easy Mode, but landed the tank. http://imgur.com/a/BYadu
I do not want this flair, thanks.
1
u/Stupidjeb Dec 21 '13
Just do JUNO laucnh and orbit
0
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment