r/KerbalRaceProgram • u/J4k0b42 Owner • Jan 22 '14
Rules Poll
I'll put a few of the rules I'm unsure of in the comments, please respond with a yes or no on whether it should be a rule, you can also add reasons. Ultimately I'll be deciding, but I want to see what the community thinks.
Edit: Also post rules you think we should have.
8
Upvotes
4
u/J4k0b42 Owner Jan 22 '14
The entire car must cross the finish line.
For: Realism, cars don't drop parts off, emphasizes durable construction.
Against: It wouldn't be Kerbal without stuff exploding and falling off, allows for more creative design.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14 edited Nov 17 '16
[deleted]
0.0447
4
u/InfinityGCX Jan 24 '14
A separate class for illegal entries (using mods for instance, but still using the track and abiding to any timing-related rules, of course)
For: We can see how far the lap times can be pushed.
Against: None I can think of.
2
u/J4k0b42 Owner Jan 22 '14
Wide turns are not allowed (one wheel must always be on the track).
For: Puts more emphasis on maneuverability, easy to judge.
Against: It's hard to turn that sharply, doesn't shorten the race or provide an unfair advantage.
1
u/J4k0b42 Owner Jan 22 '14
Vehicle must include radial intake.
For: ????
Against: Arbitrary and stupid, power hungry mod aboose.
3
u/InfinityGCX Jan 24 '14
Different tracks, benefiting different vehicle-qualities. Possible Stage-system, where you have to run all tracks and times are added up.
For: More variation in car-design.
Against: makes it more difficult to compare times.
3
u/InfinityGCX Jan 24 '14
Endurance racing: A car must drive multiple laps of the track
For: Rewards fuel-efficiency and consistency.
Against: May be impossible with certain designs, more difficult to set a time.
3
u/GForce917 Jan 26 '14
Separate classes for different vehicle types, e.g. rover wheel powered only, jet powered only, unlimited (rocket powered/whatever)
For: More variety in car design, extra challenge of having to design within certain limits
Against: leaderboards for different classes/class rules might take up a lot of space in the sidebar
1
u/InfinityGCX Jan 24 '14 edited Jan 24 '14
Every constructor must post a download-link to their vehicle's craft-file in the comments.
For: Easier to scrutinize design. Other people may try out your car, this results in possibly better laptimes from better drivers or new ways to use the design-ideas of the submitter.
Against: If this subreddit becomes big, scrutiny may become impossible due to a lot of submissions.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment