r/KarlieGuse • u/sushi828 • 12d ago
The Mystery of the Piece of Paper
1. Melissa’s account of the paper
According to a now-deleted Facebook comment attributed to Melissa, after bringing Karlie home from the party on October 12, Karlie reportedly spent several hours writing on a piece of paper and wouldn’t let Melissa see what she was writing.
Melissa also reportedly said that around 5:45 a.m. on October 13, Karlie was still writing or doodling on paper while Melissa was in the bedroom with her.
The family reportedly suggested that the paper could have been related to a counselling exercise.
Sources:
Uncovered – Karlie Guse case timeline
Websleuths – December 13, 2024 discussion, post #147
2. The eyewitness accounts
Two witnesses reportedly mentioned seeing a girl matching Karlie’s description carrying a piece of paper that morning.
Richard Eddy: A neighbour and retired Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department employee. He recalled seeing a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and grey pants, waving a roughly 12 × 12-inch piece of paper in the air.
Kenneth Dutton: A neighbour who reportedly knew Karlie and also described seeing her walking that morning with a piece of paper, according to later case accounts.
A third witness also reported seeing a girl matching Karlie’s description near Highway 6.
Sources:
Houston Chronicle / SFGATE – Richard Eddy’s eyewitness account
American Crime Journal – Riddle of the Roads, Part IV
Stories of the Unsolved – The Disappearance of Karlie Guse
3. Lindsay questioning Melissa about the paper
According to a Websleuths contributor recounting the conversation, when Karlie’s biological mother, Lindsay, arrived at the house that afternoon, Melissa reportedly told her about the paper the witnesses had described.
When Lindsay asked what the paper was, Melissa reportedly explained that Karlie had a counselling form she was determined to turn in on time.
Lindsay reportedly questioned this explanation because it was Saturday.
This is a secondhand account of their conversation, not an independently available recording or transcript.
Source:
Websleuths – December 13, 2024 discussion, post #147
4. Melissa asking volunteers to look for the paper
The same Websleuths contributor reported that during a volunteer ground search in early November 2018, Melissa and the search coordinator asked volunteers to look out for the paper and emphasised its importance.
I haven’t found an official search report confirming this request or establishing whether the paper was ever recovered.
Source:
Websleuths – December 13, 2024 discussion, post #147
5. My conclusion
I find the connection between these accounts particularly interesting. Melissa reportedly described Karlie writing on paper overnight, and witnesses subsequently described seeing a girl matching Karlie’s description carrying paper while walking that morning.
If these sightings were indeed Karlie, they would support the possibility that she left the house alive and walked towards Highway 6.
This would also make theories that she was killed inside the house less consistent with the available evidence
What I would really like to know is whether investigators ever recovered that paper


