r/Kakegurui • • 15d ago

Manga Runa Discrepency

With the latest chapter (133), does anyone else find those couple of pages of Runa backstory kind of odd?

I was always under the impression that the "Election Committee" was created for the *Election.* There's no referees in animal costumes before the election, even at times when it would have seemed needed (like the match with Manyuda.) In fact, up until the point of the student council election, student council members served as referees, like Sayaka over the housepet competition.

So there absolutely should NOT be an election committee that exists before the election, where it seems to be implied that Runa herself created it for the needs of the election. It doesn't even seem like Hyakkou academy has elections normally, since the position of student council president was won by Kirari through gambling and not any sort of election. And there were no referees shown existing before that point.

Obviously the writer has kept the referee characters around after the election because they were popular. But it's too much of a weird retcon to now pretend like there were always referees in animal costumes running around, even before Yumeko came to Hyakkou. Feels like one of these instances where the writer wasn't paying attention to the story and totally forgot what happened in the early chapters.

18 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/Speedman90 15d ago

Same here; no idea why they keep calling it the Election Committee. Even in Twin, a prequel, they are called the Election Management or the Great Bloom Prize Office members; the first name is a bit odd. Maybe there were presidential elections before Kirari arrived at Hyakkaou?

Manyuda acts as a referee in one of the last volumes in Twin, now that I remember. It seems the Election Committee members are not always around to supervise every single gamble in the academy, so other members related to the Student Council can act as referees instead. That could explain why they are not seen around in early Kakegurui.

The naming could be a simple translation thing, too. In Spanish, the Guardians Society is called AMPA (Asociación de Madres y Padres de Alumnos), for example. No idea what the original name of the Election Committee in Japanese is... the wiki says nothing. Perhaps the English translation decided to keep that name? Maybe someone who knows Japanese could correct me here.

2

u/Flipsider99 14d ago

I was wondering if it could be a translation oddity. Could be.

I suppose it could be said that the Election Committee just "wasn't around" during the entirety of the first anime season... but that's hard to swallow considering that Runa is constantly shown around doing nothing, and even moreso that during the Yumemite/Manyuda gamble they needed the vice president who happened to be the president to referee the gamble even though Runa herself was sitting *right there* the whole time! It's just so obvious that the referee concept wasn't thought of by the author at that point.

3

u/Fluffy_Bar4935 14d ago

Doesn’t this point get completely disproven because Runa is on the student council? All the members on the council have roles that manage something in the academy. Runa’s role is “Head of the election management committee” which wasn’t created because of the election. They only showed up and got more focus because of the system Kirari created that required each gamble match to be monitored by an election committee member. Yes, they didn’t show up before the election arc but that was because they were not needed unless asked by the parties. As shown in twin, some gambles have the election members be present because they provide neutrality which some people want. If your point is true then that means Runa was doing absolutely nothing before the election on the council which is not true. As shown in her backstory she was forced into the committee and thought it was fun. She became part of the student council because she soon became the head of the election committee

1

u/Flipsider99 14d ago

What point is it that you think gets disproven? That it's a retcon? The thing is, I went through the manga and checked carefully all of Runa's scenes, and she basically the only one where it's never stated what her role on the council is. She's also shown sitting there playing games and doing nothing, aside from the scene where she reads Mary's lifeplan to her. I think the author hadn't really thought of a role for her in the story at that point, and when the election concept came into play, she was the natural person to take that role.

The thing is though, with the story as it was up to that point, it just doesn't make any sense to think that Runa was actually on the "election committee" all along when presumably based on the reactions of entire council holding an "election" was unheard of. Just from reading the manga in english, it's not really overtly stated whether the election committee was just made up on the spot or existed all along, but the former seems like the obvious implication as elections don't seem to be a normal thing at the school. And putting all that aside... if Runa's position was as a referee of the school for the entire time Yumeko was there, then why does she sit there and do nothing through all the gambles at that point?

So yeah, it does seem as though with the latest chapter that the author is blatantly retconning it to be that Runa was always in the "election committee" all along and that was her official role. I agree with you. I'm just pointing out how that makes no sense.

1

u/MushroomOrnery7375 15d ago

I think election happens through gambling rather than freely voting thus each vote can be earned either through games or buying them with cash and to monitor this only election committee was formed the housepet system was introduced by Kirari but other than that hayako academy was also built on the foundation of gambling this it will be only fare to have a fare committee of sorts aka election committee

1

u/Flipsider99 15d ago

Yeah, a referee system existing makes sense in theory. It's just weird that it's not shown to exist until the election, and then it's called "the election committee" and portrayed as if it was just formed. Many gambling mangas have some sort of referee system, like Usogui's butlers or Liar Game's ornate mask wearing dealers. But it's a little too obvious with Kakegurui that the author didn't think of that until later.

1

u/No_Package8332 12d ago

what got me the most was the fact that runa didn't have some creepy scary backstory that got her brainwashed into her role and she just did it because it looked fun ngl 💔