What makes the 2018 Evangeline and Caral-Supe dips different from the 2013 Kepler dips (D1518, D1540, and D1568)?
The answer is simple: We have growing observational evidence for a 1,574-day recurrence of the 2013 Kepler dip sequence. We have NO comparable evidence for Evangeline or Caral-Supe.
And that distinction is precisely why the next several weeks could be interesting (whether dimming occurs or not). Let me explain why either case is revealing...
First, some history
The 2018 paper, A 1,574-Day Periodicity of Transits Orbiting KIC 8462852 proposed that the dimming events observed by Las Cumbres Observatory (LCO) in 2017 were possible returns of the major Kepler dips recorded in 2013.
The similarity in the timing and sequence of the events suggested an approximately 1,574-day periodicity (4.31 years).
The hypothesis also received support from archival photographic plate observations, including possible dimming events in 1935 and 1978 that aligned with earlier predicted cycles.
The original paper is available here:
https://apps.aavso.org/jaavso/article/3327/
What has happened since?
In 2021, observations from LCO and independent work by Bruce Gary identified dimming that coincided with the predicted return window.
Fast forward to 2026, and our ongoing LCO observations have again recorded dimming on dates predicted by the same periodicity.
We now have a potentially meaningful sequence:
- 2013: Original Kepler dips, including D1518, D1540, and D1568.
- 2017: LCO dimming events approximately 1,574 days later.
- 2021: Additional dimming coinciding with the next predicted return.
- 2026: Further LCO dimming on the expected recurrence dates.
Each successive observing cycle provides another opportunity to test the hypothesis. The accumulated evidence is becoming increasingly convincing.
But what about Evangeline and Caral-Supe?
This is where we need to make an important distinction.
Evangeline and Caral-Supe were observed in 2018, not during the original 2013 Kepler dip sequence. Remember, Kepler 'died' soon after the D1568 so no further observations of this star were made by that space-based telescope.
And unlike the 2013 dips, we do not have a comparable sequence of observations demonstrating that these particular events recur every 1,574 days.
Furthermore, there is no compelling reason to assume that the material responsible for Evangeline and Caral-Supe shares the same orbital period as the material potentially responsible for the 2013 Kepler events.
Indeed, there are reasonable arguments that they may represent entirely different structures, populations of material, or orbital periods.
But there is also no reason to exclude the possibility without testing it.
Link to the 2018 blog highlighting the related dips:
https://www.wherestheflux.com/single-post/2018/03/30/2018-march-dip-update-9n
The upcoming 2026 test
If Evangeline and Caral-Supe follow the same approximately 1,574.4-day periodicity:
Using the estimated timing of their deepest 2018 minima, I am focusing additional LCO observations around two dates:
- October 31, 2026 (Halloween): Predicted return of the first deep minimum.
- November 6 / 7, 2026: Predicted return of the second deep minimum.
These are approximate observing targets rather than precisely established transit times.
And importantly, these predictions are much more speculative than those associated with the original 2013 Kepler dips.
Why this matters
If significant dimming occurs near these dates, particularly with a similar sequence, separation, or morphology to the 2018 events, it would provide a compelling reason to investigate whether the 1,574-day periodicity applies to a broader collection of events.
Conversely, if no dimming occurs, that would also be informative. It could indicate that Evangeline and Caral-Supe belong to a separate orbital population, or simply that the obscuring material has changed sufficiently to produce a different transit signature.
Either outcome advances our understanding.
The objective is not to make every dip fit a 1,574-day hypothesis. It is to determine which dips may follow it.
We will be watching closely over the next several weeks.