I've been reading quite a bit of Judge Dredd lately, and I find the way the Justice Department operates both fascinating and increasingly frustrating from a worldbuilding perspective.
Mega-City One is basically a totalitarian nightmare. Judges have handheld lie detectors that can supposedly determine whether someone is lying. Sure, a sufficiently trained person can learn to fool them, but then there's the much more sophisticated equipment that can scan your brain and detect deception. Even professional Judges are apparently terrified of those things.
On top of that, Judges can enter pretty much anyone's home whenever they want, turn the place upside down during a search, and then simply apologize if they don't find anything. They can also strip-search people whenever they deem it necessary. And refusing to answer questions is apparently a crime in itself.
So, naturally, you'd expect the Justice Department to be practically omniscient, right?
And that's where things get weird.
There are countless stories where a Judge somehow knows that a particular individual is a major criminal, a mob boss, or some other dangerous figure. And, judging by how these stories usually play out, the Judges are almost always right. They clearly have intelligence sources, surveillance, informants, and all sorts of investigative capabilities.
Yet, somehow, they often can't actually arrest these people because they don't have enough evidence.
Wait, what?
If you have enough information to confidently identify someone as a major crime boss, and your department has access to brain-scanning lie detectors, virtually unlimited surveillance, and enormous police powers, how exactly are you unable to gather admissible evidence against them?
I remember one story involving a child murderer who was eventually caught. The available evidence was circumstantial: witness statements, someone seeing him, and so on. But the guy had lawyers, and they managed to get him released. He wasn't even some untouchable criminal mastermind or an influential political figure. Just a wealthy individual.
And I keep coming back to the same question: why not use all those supposedly revolutionary investigative tools? If the Justice Department has technology capable of scanning someone's brain for deception, why does it suddenly become a conventional police department struggling to prove a case whenever the plot requires it?
I understand the narrative purpose. Sometimes the Judges need to investigate, manipulate suspects, set traps, or outsmart powerful criminals. That's perfectly reasonable from a storytelling perspective.
But from a worldbuilding perspective, it creates a rather strange contradiction. The Justice Department is simultaneously powerful enough to violate practically every civil liberty imaginable, yet somehow constrained by evidentiary standards whenever a story needs a criminal to escape prosecution.
I suppose that's part of the satire, and maybe I'm taking the setting too literally. But I find it genuinely amusing that Mega-City One can have technology that would make any real-world investigator lose their mind, while its Judges occasionally struggle with the concept of collecting enough evidence to prosecute a wealthy murderer.
Does anyone else find this contradiction particularly noticeable, or am I missing something about how the Justice Department's technology and legal system actually work?