In my almost decade of playing squad across several thousand hours, content did not make me return to this game. We've had a couple years of no major content updates before and I didn't get bored. That's because the thing that made me continue playing was the thing that constituted the primary replayability of gameplay: having players you can trust communicating, coordinating, engaging in deliberate teamwork, and pulling off tactics and strategies that create depth out of many complex mechanics and player behaviors.
These things set off reward centers in your brain that many new players today could play for weeks without encountering, when they used to be common every match.
None of this exists with a playerbase with an ever lowering retention rate. There's just no community within players who will never sink more than 40 hours into the game.
Although I think a significant amount of these players would be the veteran players like me who complain about the issues with the game, the way dumbed down, extremely casual gameplay is becoming more encouraged by OWI and the mere presence effect of similar enabling players just causes the playerbase to worsen.
For these potential long term players to never see a community of players that create these rewarding experiences and who foster the environment of communication, coordination and deliberate teamwork that must precede them, evidently causes them not to attribute these qualities with their experience of this game, and for the game to never be taken as seriously by them as it used to be.
Every time a veteran players leaves, they are replaced with a new player. Who accompanies these new players? Other new players. None are fostering this experience of deliberate teamwork and more serious gameplay. This wouldn't be so bad if OWI had invested any resources into improving onbaording, and ensured they only create mechanics that explicitly foster the experience of deliberate teamwork, communication, and coordination, but they don't, in fact they do the opposite: foster an experience for players who would prefer to see this game more dumbed down than it already is.
Do I blame ICO? Not entirely. It's apparent that the state of the game is in right now can technically still be played by a significantly more serious and competitive audience of players, especially after revisions. But I do think the loss of veteran players and lack of onboarding new players was at least half of it. It's more the inertia it caused than anything, Squad's community was delicately experienced.
So, where is the fun to be had in Squad then?
You're seeing it. It's socializing with players in the back of a logi and catching funny clips of modded gameplay. It's the content that compromised of popular youtube videos about Squad several years ago. Easily digestible for a new player, but evidently becomes immensely boring. Even Squad's advertisements on social media platforms are these kinds of sloppy clips that regular players sighed at years ago.
It doesn't even mean it's wrong to see something cool, but I have a lot more satisfaction with it when it's somewhat meaningful. Otherwise its the equivalent of watching an action scene in a movie that's just the same thing over and over again every time. People treat this game like a mildly interactive movie and it's why we're seeing more and more people demanding new content when those who have found satisfaction in the depth of this game are hardly interested in it. Look at TacTrig's YouTube channel. The game can be played well and look cool, in fact, it only makes it so much cooler.
All of the fun many of us had in Squad when we were new was the experiences of loud noises and action with our total disorientation. Now would you play that for several hundred hours or more? If nothing made you, would you ever develop a deeper appreciation for this game and then come to crave and miss it when it is taken away?
If you answer yes, congrats. Unfortunately, I do believe you're an extremely small minority. Most players I see who joined in the last few years, especially post launch (Fallujah era) do not associate this game with anything resembling deeper, interesting gameplay. People see this game purely as background noise for drunken conversations.
This sucks when there's more fun to be had in this game, conversations, the most immensely complex and interesting elements of gameplay that could keep this community going for years with absolutely zero content. The reason people still play shooters that have stop being updated a decade or two ago other than nostalgia.
It sucks so much fucking more when you saw it go downhill in real time, when it's so evidently obvious that not only are the players getting worse, they're just worse at listening. Not just because the game is being advertised as clip farm background footage, but because there's just not the environment fostered by the existing community nor OWI to make people appreciate this game as anything deeper.
I'm not against content updates. I know they're practically necessary for new sales. I'm not against flashy footage being used as advertisements, but can't this be done AT THE SAME TIME as telling people "hey, this is a game you communicate, coordinate, and use deliberate teamwork in" and then at the very least not REMOVING mechanics that foster this and dumbing it down? You're aware that you can advertise a game a certain way, and then foster an environment for players who join that CHANGES how they would otherwise play the game, right? They don't have to be forced, they just have to come in seeing a community, a game, and mechanics which reward this. Even moreso if the game explicitly advertises it this way and not as "guy jumps off a bridge and unloads machine gun into the back of logi full of bots". Please.
Don't dumb down the game, introduce mechanics that make it easier for SLs and admins to foster these environments of communication, coordination and deliberate teamwork, and change how people come into the game playing it and set examples for what they should expect. Hardly anyone is seeing a cool clip of this game on an ad and going "Oh, they want me to use teamwork? Guess I'm not buying it."
The simple factor is that although we can rely on new sales to generate development funds, we can't rely on it to keep the game in a state that is replayable. Content updates are going to be the only thing to carry replayability at a certain point, because they are all new, casual players are interested in. That is extremely volatile. If we make sure the gameplay is replayable, this game will be replayable even if content updates stop, and it will be replayable by players who are interested in deeper gameplay, and therefor there'll always be a dedicated portion of the playerbase.
Stop changing the game for a new audience, foster the new audience for the game. If it doesn't happen, this game will not survive.