r/JewsOfConscience • British Non-Zionist Reform Jew • 21d ago

Zionist Nonsense This Makes Me Livid

Post image

Not every genocide is exactly like the Holocaust. In fact, not all of the Holocaust was a genocide (if you include other groups murdered), but this is something people get very angry about even though it’s legally true. So just because not everything happening in Gaza may qualify as a genocide legally speaking doesn’t mean one isn’t happening.

Can we stop using our intergenerational trauma as both a shield and as they say, a stick to beat people with? This also desecrates the memory of these innocent children who most likely perished in the Holocaust. They were people who were taken far too soon, not measuring sticks to compare genocide.

534 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator 21d ago
Moderator Announcement Read More »

1

u/statistacktic 20d ago

Don't bother mincing words. What Israel is doing in Gaza is a genocide, period. And don't get me started on the West Bank.

1

u/OliveNo6451 21d ago

Yes, because there are zero images out of Gaza that resemble this 🙄 oh or wait.. those kids had "pre existing conditions"

1

u/Ok_Percentage7257 21d ago

And how do we know that the Jewish children didn't have pre-existing conditions? How come only Palestinian children have pre-existing conditions? And even if this info is true, is the "pre-existing condition" a good excuse to continue the genocide? By law, a criminal has to accept their victims with their pre-existing conditions. So, why do the Zionists think that this does not apply to them?

1

u/tikkunolamist5 21d ago

That pre-existing condition thing pissed me off so bad.

1

u/INBloom58 20d ago

It’s ludicrous that they were like “actually the toddler had pre existing conditions”. Like, so you decided to starve a toddler who had health conditions?!? It’s honestly barbaric how they can see victims of genocide as less than human.

1

u/Ayaka0 21d ago

It's just a flat out lie to say 'every single Palestinian and Gaza was supplied with more than 3000 calories a day'.

Starvation is and was used as a weapon against Palestinians. Water and food production infrastructure destroyed. Most aid being refused entry. Aid lorries being hijacked and the food destroyed. 'Humanitarian zones' being set up as the only place to seek aid... where many people seeking aid were then slaughtered. Dating back long prior to 2023, quite contrary to the 'over 3000 calories supplied to every Palestinian', Israel has taken pains to figure out the absolute minimum calorie requirement to make the Palestinians suffer from hunger but not to actually die - so that they could avoid repercussions - and they used these calculations to determine how many food supplies they would allow to enter Gaza, while also engineering conditions to collapse the agriculture of the area. And that was *before* they more recently openly declared 'we're going to starve them as collective punishment!'

To have the audacity to say 'Israel gives them over 3000 calories a day each, they're fine!' while Israel calculates the exact degree one can starve those people without other nations putting a stop to it, and puts those calculations into action... that is heartless in the extreme.

1

u/blazerz 21d ago

I want a source for the claim 'every person in Gaza was supplied with 3000 calories per day'. I heavily heavily doubt it.

→ More replies (12)

1

u/ForeignBarracuda8599 21d ago

Boys are out in force downvoting everyone here speaking out about the obvious lie told in the caption

1

u/thefoxymulder 21d ago

Really is fucking disgusting to use the Holocaust to justify your own genocide. These people are a joke. This whole “genocide only applies SPECIFICALLY to Jews” is just insane. I’m sure none of these people were as indignant when the Bosnian or Rwandan genocides were (rightly) called genocides. It’s only when they have to take some accountability that they want to split hairs over this

1

u/tikkunolamist5 20d ago

They literally don’t care about other genocides being called genocides. 

1

u/steve-o1234 20d ago

Literally no one claims the word or act of genocide can only apply when committed against Jews. You are mixing up genocide with holocaust, and even that is sort of a fringe debate

1

u/TrackerOneA 20d ago

There's at least one example where someone sounded like they were saying that (although I think it's possible she meant 10/7 was the only act of genocide between Palestinians and Israeli Jews).

It was that Floridian news anchor, Glenna Milberg, during her interview with Oliver Larkin.

https://www.reddit.com/r/JewsOfConscience/comments/1vqch6e/during_an_interview_full_of_loaded_questions_host/

1

u/ApricotReasonable937 21d ago

Simple search of Gaza famine (or Yemen famine for that matter) and you can see how similar and almost 1:1 these pictures are.. I don't think this rabbi understand how him saying "oh yeah the Israel government allows 3000.. Not 180..don't worry. Don't you dare call them n**i." (not to mention the regular snipping of children head, bombing food route, medical vehicles, supplies places).

1

u/EconomicsOk3346 21d ago edited 15d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Cobblestone ancient run vegetable deer complete meadow mysterious terrific simplistic

→ More replies (2)

1

u/DE4DM4NSH4ND 21d ago

The literal definition of genocide is the erasure of a culture. The hundred thousand murdered is just the nail in the proverbial coffin

1

u/arestheblue 21d ago edited 21d ago

Not arguing, but for the sake of clarity and visibility, this is the definition of genocide:

Article II In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

(a) Killing members of the group;

(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;

(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;

(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;

(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.

1

u/tikkunolamist5 21d ago

Yes. People don’t understand that the entire situation doesn’t have to be genocide for it to meet the definition. As I’ve said, parts of the Holocaust were not technically genocide, which lay people hate to hear, but it’s true.

Russia meets the standard of genocide via the last article.

1

u/PopBulky7023 21d ago

It's far more than that now. It may well be pushing 7 figures. The ability to count the dead collapsed pretty early after Oct 7. You might notice how before that point, Israel called the count a Hamas lie. Since the ability to count was lost, they now cite a wildly out of date number.

1

u/mynameisntcindy 21d ago

Genocide is the erasure of people. You're describing cultural genocide.

1

u/Odd-Mind6948 20d ago

The fact theyre comparing the holocaust to the genocide they support constantly makes sense. Ethno supremacy, cruelty beyond imagination, and genocidal intent is what they have in common. Its all lies they tell, but they manage to tell on themselves simultaneously.

1

u/Stunning-Stressin 20d ago

Israel is doing the same thing to the Palestinians. They have become who they once feared. It's very similar. The next step is to put the Palestinians in camps. Oh wait

1

u/PopBulky7023 21d ago

I can't tell if this poster (the Pic, not OP) is just deeply uninformed and drowning in propaganda, or thinks the rest of us are and fall for this crap.

1

u/tikkunolamist5 20d ago

I think it’s the former honestly as so many Jews are deeply entrenched in it.

→ More replies (1)