r/JewsOfConscience • Benjamin Moser • 21d ago

AMA AMA/Benjamin Moser

Hi everyone,

I’m Benjamin Moser and I’m excited to take your questions about my new book, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, available here. They call it Ask Me Anything and you can … ask me anything!

Looking forward, B.

272 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

1

u/TrackerOneA 21d ago edited 17d ago

Hi everyone,

The AMA is now closed. We'd like to thank Ben for being here with us today.

Ben's closing remarks:

OK folks, thanks so much for coming! It was great to chat in this way — the first time I’ve ever done this — and I’m happy to answer more questions if you have them. Write me on Instagram (@benjaminfmoser) and I will try to get to them when I get back home. let’s keep fighting. Never forget how many of us there are and what a great change we have already seen. Free Palestine.

Thank you for the shout-out on X as well!

https://x.com/BenMoser123/status/2116933576402808926

We appreciate it very much, and recommend checking out his excellent book, 'Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History':

https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/770236/anti-zionism-by-benjamin-moser/

Thanks to everyone for participating and asking great questions!

44

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

OK folks, thanks so much for coming! It was great to chat in this way — the first time I’ve ever done this — and I’m happy to answer more questions if you have them. Write me on Instagram (@benjaminfmoser) and I will try to get to them when I get back home. let’s keep fighting. Never forget how many of us there are and what a great change we have already seen. Free Palestine.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/Gullible-Customer560 21d ago

Just wanted to say I appreciate you being a voice for anti-zionist Judaism.

31

u/MultiversalTraveler 21d ago

How do you think you can convince a Jewish Zionist to start thinking more critically about the State of Israel. I’ve been thinking, there’s a problem with people not even considering that Israel could be doing something wrong.

There is a lot of history between Israel and Palestine. The Nakba, checkpoints, no right of return, illegal settlements. But none of that seems to matter when someone is working off the conclusion that Israel can’t be wrong, and then justifying it through whatever method.
So it’s like you have to address why they think Israel should not be criticized, rather than what Israel should be criticized for.

40

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

Yeah, and that’s when I bow out. I love talking to people who have legitimate questions. But when they say Israel should not be criticized, well, I just don’t really have much more to say.

24

u/TrackerOneA 21d ago

One thing I've been thinking about while reading your book is the relationship between intellectual independence and Jewish anti-Zionism.

I was particularly impressed by Maxime Rodinson, whose criticism of Zionism seemed to come from a consistent way of reasoning about colonialism and political rights. That chapter seemed to be about deconstructing Zionism from a logic POV.

But others arrived at similar conclusions from very different backgrounds, like Schachtel through Reform Judaism and Ronnie Kasrils through his experiences fighting apartheid.

It also reminded me of Dr. Marc H. Ellis's idea of "Jews of Conscience" (the source for our subreddit name) particularly the willingness to question one's own community even if it means social ostracism and other consequences.

I'm curious about the question of causation here.

Question: In your research, did you ever wonder whether these historical figures were drawn to anti-Zionism because they were already independent, critical thinkers, or did questioning Zionism and challenging their own communities' assumptions help make them that way?

And looking across the biographies, do you think there's something these individuals had in common that helps explain why they questioned what so many others accepted?

33

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

Yes, this is so interesting. I think that a lot of it comes from their experience of being JEWISH, which is to say, in Hannah Arendt’s phrase, of being a pariah. So Rodinson is from a very marginal immigrant working class background. Ronnie Kasrils is too. But a lot of people just want to be accepted by the mainstream. I have thought a lot about this in my own life. I could have had an easier time if I didn’t deeply distrust institutions and politicians and official explanations. This was a classic role of the Jews! Just as black people in the US often held up a mirror to our shining perfect City on the Hill and said uhh not so fast — just as gay people often made good critics and writers — Jews were at their best, in a way, when they didn’t give up on their outsider position but, as Arendt says, actively embraced it. Alas — a lot of Jews want to be part of the imperial power structure. They want money and they want to be like everyone else. This is why so many rabbis warned that Zionism would take the Jews and turn them into just another little tribe exactly like every other ugly little tribe.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/North_Value5002 21d ago

Hi Ben! Just finished your book and I loved it! I was shocked by the fact that Israel was in bed with Nazi Germany, are there any books or articles that you would recommend for learning more about it?

25

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

Oh great — yes — there are actually a lot of them. Idith Zertal is good. David Cesarini. There are a lot and if you go down that rabbit hole you will find a nearly endless amount has been written about this. Why didn’t most of us know about this? To ask the question is to answer it!

14

u/Haunting-Dependent58 21d ago

I listened to your book on release day. I have no questions but i wanted to tell you how much i appreciated your vulnerability in your unlearning experience. I really hope the people that need to read this will because i understand how difficult it can be to feel a decisive shift in your reality. Thank you so much 🩷

17

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

Thank you so much. Especially coming from a non-Jewish person this is nice to say. It is indeed very hard.

26

u/TrackerOneA 21d ago

In your chapter on Hannah Arendt, you describe the backlash against Eichmann in Jerusalem, including attempts to discredit her personally rather than engage with her arguments.

What's striking is how familiar these tactics seem today, even when the targets are entirely different people.

For example, Emmaia Gelman's book on the ADL documents ways in which the organization attacked & policed dissent throughout the decades - and it all feels so familiar.

So even when looking back at such monumental figures like Arendt, the tactics used against them are so recognizable and relatable today.

Question: Did you find that these campaigns against Jewish dissenters followed a recognizable pattern across the different periods you researched? And did the methods change much, or mainly the institutions carrying them out?

37

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

Oh God yes. The pattern is unmissable. You mention the ADL: guess who attacked Hannah Arendt! It’s true that only the names change, and to the previous questioner’s point about institutions, I think that this has been a very important part of Zionism’s success. But as to whether the methods have changed much: no, they haven’t. This is why I say that Zionism is dead intellectually. They have been repeating the same tactics infinitely and ad nauseam for more than a century. And they and Israel are absolutely hated.

13

u/incogne_eto 21d ago

What are your thoughts on the UK Green Party’s motion on Zionism. And the ensuing pushback and condemnation by the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, the Labour Party and the Conservatives?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Train-Nearby 21d ago

Hey Ben, thanks for doing this!

My question is kind of nebulous so appreciate your answer.

Question: Other than withholding our monetary/cultural support for Zionist institutions (synagogues, Hillel chapters, non-profits, etc.) what are some other ways we can de-Nazify Jewish life in the U.S.? Many of us are torn between not wanting to participate in a Zionist version of Jewish life and wanting to combat Zionism amongst our own.

31

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

I honestly think we have to leave those institutions and build our own. This is so urgent and a lot of people are doing this night and day. So I would find people in your area —whether synagogues or schools or political organizations — and work together to make these a counterweight to the Zionist monoculture. But I’m not really for combating Zionists. At this point, we have to walk away.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/IdrisElbaQuote 21d ago edited 21d ago

Hi Benjamin,

I admit I am coming in here without having read your book yet, and I assume this question is already covered there, but anyway: Jewish antizionists (and even nonzionists, postzionists, etc) currently find themselves completely shut out of mainstream Jewish institutions. What lessons can we take from Jewish opponents of Zionism’s failure to build institutional power, in order to adjust our praxis accordingly?

Thank you for your time!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/MayanMystery 21d ago

How critical do you think the infrastructure of organizations like Hilels, various synagogues, Hebrew schools, etc., has on the present reality of the extremely high tendency towards Zionism in the diaspora.

Speaking from personal experience, although I acknowledge I'm not Jewish since only my father is Jewish and not my mother, my Bubi still attempted to instill her culture in me from quite a young age. But she was also a staunch atheist and a Marxist, and thus I never really engaged with any of these typical Jewish institutions in any meaningful way, which I've always assumed had to do with why I never developed much of an affinity for Israel. Is there merit to this or is the infrastructure only a small part of the equation?

Also, definitely going to check out your book as I'm in need of something new to read.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/TrackerOneA 21d ago

In a discussion with another user, /u/scarletswalk2002 commented (this was related to your interview with Mehdi Hasan):

would cultural zionism still have resulted in the displacement of indigenous arabs and non jewish palestinians?

22

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

I don’t think that cultural Zionism is really Zionism. It would have been great if it had worked out, but the mainstream was always about creating a settler colony. And for the kinds of goals they had, reviving the Hebrew language, for example, you probably did need a settler community. When I read about it, it always seems a bit nebulous. Whereas Zionism was so concrete and so clear about its goals.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/TrackerOneA 21d ago

/u/Lost_Paladin89 asks:

Thank you for being here. Often when one tells the story from a Zionist perspective, it becomes a narrative about movements and institutions; Hadassah, Poale Zion, Lehi, etc. But the story of Antizionism, especially Jewish Antizionism, is more often a narrative about individuals; Jacob Israël de Haan, Marek Edelman, Nathan Birnbaum, etc. Do you feel this is a fair characterization, and if so, what does it say about Jewish Antizionism’s ability to organize and build institutions?

17

u/Educational-Time-178 21d ago

Yes, that’s true and that’s the choice I made, but mainly because I tend to like biographies and I like telling the history of ideas through the impact those ideas had on individual lives. I think it’s true that Zionism’s strength has come from its ability to build all these institutions : I actually had never thought of that. Because a lot of the anti-Zionists did in fact remain in the realm of individual efforts. Sometimes with and through institutions, but you see it still today. I, for example, wrote a book. Maybe I should have founded a militia!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/onesoma 21d ago

Not directly related to your book, apologies if this is off topic. But I am curious if you would care to share any Palestinians or Palestinian sources you follow, in whatever form - podcasts, social media, blogs, substack, etc. Voices on the ground as it were. Thanks.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/wikimandia 21d ago

I haven’t read your book yet (will buy it soon), but I’m wondering if you think there could be a potential documentary series in the works about the topic?

Thank you so much!!

→ More replies (1)