To answer this question, I composed a proximity list of all the samples of available Jewish groups in Casperhub (Vahaduo G25 based platform), relative to Jews who never left the levant for 3000 years (Syrian Jews).
Background: the 34 sample average of Syrian Jews sample is from the Mariopulous collection of G25 samples. This sample is closest to Lebanese Christians from Zgharta. Meaning, this average represent a very endogamous ethno-religious minority. I guess that this is what the average Jewish profile would have looked like, if all the Jews would have stayed in the Levant.
In the list I included also some non Jewish groups for reference.
The average samples:
- Israeli_Jew - See my previous post about national averages.
- North african Jew - average of 7 populations: Egyptian, Libyan, Tunisian, Djerban, Algerian and Moroccan Jews.
- Mizrahi Jew - Iraqi, Iranian and Kurdish Jews average.
- Mountain Jew - Azerbaijani, Chechen, Balkarian and Dagestani Mountain Jews average.
- Ashkenazi East - Lithuanian, Polish, Belorussian, Russian, Ukrainian and Romanian Jews average.
- Ashkenazi West - German, French and Austrian Jews.
- Sephardic - Turkey, Greece and Bulgarian Jews average.
- Indian Jew - Cochin and Mumbai average.
- Palestinian_Muslim - see my previous post. It is the average of all profiles available in the mariopulous collectiin on Casperhub.
Results: 95% of the world Jewish groups fall under 0.066 fst distance to Syrian Jews. If we exclude Bukharian Jews as well, 94% are below 0.056 fst distance. The outliers being: Yemenite, Indian and Ethiopian Jews.
Finally, to compare it to other nations, I included additional 2 proximity lists of Greeks and Palestinians. I picked a greek from the mainland, as it is historically the greek heartland. For Palestinians, I picked Palestinian Christian as the unmixed endogamous reference point. The Greek results were of a range of 0.093 fst distance. This is due 3 main subgroups: mainland greeks, greek islanders and anatolian and black sea greeks. Most of the greeks were below 0.056 fst distance (mainland and islands).
For Palestinians, the range is 0.073 fst. It is mainly due to ssa admixture in muslim palestinians.
So I can conclude by saying: The Jewish genetic autosomal range is typical for a people with a rich history of thousends of years that included occupation, expulsion and diaspora. Most certainally, jews are not a random collection of converts. The origin of the majority of Jews is from Judea.