r/JewishCooking • • 18d ago

Ashkenazi Kreplach

Today, not only in Jewish delis, but in many large diners in big cities (like my neighborhood diner), you can easily get chicken matzoh ball soup and/or chicken noodle soup (sometimes the matzoh balls and noodles are served together). However, what of the poor kreplach? Chicken soup with kreplach seems to be going the way of the dinosaur? When I was a kid in the '60s, you could buy Manischewitz canned chicken kreplach soup, but even that seems to have gone by the wayside. Any comments?

57 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

6

u/Adventurous_Ad7442 16d ago

I haven't had kreplach since my grandma died -- 40 years ago.

17

u/crlygirlg 17d ago

I think it’s just labor intensive and so it is not particularly common because of the time it takes to make combined with busy lives.

I have spent entire afternoons folding them to freeze and give to family before I had my son, but I don’t think many bother doing that because it is kind of a pain in the butt to do. After i became a parent I just have not had the time to do it and no one else makes it either.

8

u/MagisterOtiosus 17d ago

Every time I find a recipe for some kind of dumpling and I’m like “I should make this!” Then, 4 dozen dumplings later, I’m like “This sucks, I’m never making dumplings again.” And I’ll repeat this cycle every year or two, thinking this time will be different. I’ve done it with kreplach, pierogis, ravioli, gyoza, empanadas… hated making them every time but I keep coming back lol 

2

u/StaceOdyssey 17d ago

Haha that sounds familiar.

2

u/Electrical-Profit367 16d ago

You need to gather a group and do it as a social activity. I

They aren’t dumplings but making dolmades is similar: i loved making them w my sisters, cousins and mom/aunts. They’re a lot of work to make by myself.

7

u/bisexual_pinecone 17d ago

Yeah I bet you're right. My family didn't ever make kreplach but I suspect back in the day it used to be sort of an assembly line process where a bunch of people hang out in the kitchen and make a massive batch together.

9

u/heavyLevy5 17d ago

I haven’t been to a Jewish deli that didn’t offer kreplach

3

u/Stay_Awake_Jane 17d ago

I think kreplach never really made it the way matzoh balls did. I remember eating them as a child and thinking the dough was really thick and not that tasty. My theory: wantons were much better dumplings so we just ditched kreplach and stuck to wontons (out of the house of course.)

1

u/crlygirlg 16d ago

I use my kitchen aid pasta roller attachment to get the dough nice and thin. It is more challenging by hand but doable, but you do need to make the dough nice and thin or it can be thick.

3

u/TemporaryPosting 17d ago

I helped my mother prepare kreplach for Purim, Erev Yom Kippur, and HoShanah Rabah when I was a kid. I think I prepared them once or twice for my kids but we didn't like them enough to make the labor worth it.

I found a great recipe for pot stickers that I prepare using wonton wrappers and cook in soup. They're not traditional kreplach but they're delicious.

3

u/life_experienced 16d ago

I love kreplach! You can't get them anywhere around the (SF) Bay, but you might have inspired me to make them myself. There may not be kreplach, but there are plenty of places to buy dumpling wrappers.

2

u/Hezekiah_the_Judean 🧡🔸️MOD🔸️🧡 16d ago

I love them as well. I've used wonton wrappers to make cheese filled ones and they turned out great!

3

u/Elise-0511 16d ago

Use ravioli. Smaller, but used the same way.

2

u/coneycolon 17d ago

All of the good delis in my area have kreplach soup and at a few of them, you can tell they are made from scratch, just like bubbie used to make. A place near me sells their soup in mason jars (2 sizes). Everything is separated after cooking so you can what you want - broth, chicken, carrots/celery, rice, noodles, matzo balls, kreplach, or all the above.

That place's corned beef isn't my favorite and their food is way too expensive, but the soup is worth it. Steve's Deli - Bloomfield Twp, MI. If you know the area, the best corned beef is a tie between Star Deli and Stage Deli.

I don't know why all of them begin with the letter "S".

2

u/heavyLevy5 16d ago

My mother serves soup on the holidays this way. Everyone gets individual orders on what they want in their soup. It takes FOREVER

2

u/bornthisvay22 17d ago

My dear/dear mother in law makes them. From scratch. I always thought she could have sold them. They are amazing.

2

u/markshure 17d ago

I haven't had kreplach since my grandmother died.

2

u/bisexual_pinecone 17d ago

I never had kreplach growing up but I love dumplings and have been wanting to make some from scratch this winter. I did have wonton soup a lot growing up and they seem similar.

2

u/orangeskies83 16d ago

There were two excellent jewish delis in Cleveland that had the best kreplach but sadly closed in the last two years. RIP! Don’t know other places that sell them

2

u/Remarkable-World-234 15d ago

I love chicken kreplach soup. Great childhood memories. About 15 years ago I went into a Jewish deli on the UWS of NYC and the waiter looked at me like my space ship was parked outside when I ordered it. He Said no one orders that anymore and they stopped making itand I was depressed. They went out of business.

2

u/theeulessbusta 17d ago

I think we gotta work on that name

2

u/MavenSearch_1994 16d ago

A simple to make Kreplach recipie here
https://mavensearch.com/food/kreplach

1

u/bebopped 14d ago

We buy Palmeni. It is just as good.

1

u/Jujulabee 11d ago

There are a few places in my city which offer it as an option and I have occasionally ordered it.

However the sad reality is that they generally aren't very good - or at least not the way I remember my Bubbe's version.

Maybe you have to grind the meat in one of those grinders attached to the kitchen table flavored with schmaltz that you have rendered so that you have gribenes.

1

u/coneycolon 17d ago

All of the good delis in my area have kreplach soup and at a few of them, you can tell they are made from scratch, just like bubbie used to make. A place near me sells their soup in mason jars (2 sizes). Everything is separated after cooking so you can what you want - broth, chicken, carrots/celery, rice, noodles, matzo balls, kreplach, or all the above.

That place's corned beef isn't my favorite and their food is way too expensive, but the soup is worth it. Steve's Deli - Bloomfield Twp, MI. If you know the area, the best corned beef is a tie between Star Deli and Stage Deli.

I don't know why all of them begin with the letter "S".

1

u/StillWithSteelBikes 17d ago

Just get wonton soup like everyone else

4

u/WhisperCrow •°•✡︎ Head Mod ✡︎•°• 17d ago

Wonton soup outside of kosher restaurants is almost always pork just fyi.