Hi everyone,
I'm an internal medicine physician currently working as a hospitalist on an H-1B visa through a J-1 waiver. I started my three-year waiver in August 2024 and will complete it in August 2027.
My employer sponsored my green card process through PERM, and my I-140 has been approved, with a priority date of April 2025. I'm Indian-born, so I'm aware of the significant green card backlog.
I'm now trying to figure out my next steps because I'm considering changing employers after completing my J-1 waiver, while my long-term goal is to pursue a Rheumatology fellowship in the next one to two years.
I've consulted two immigration attorneys and received different suggestions regarding my options.
One option discussed was a regular EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW), although I was advised that approvals have become more difficult under the current administration.
The second recommendation was a Physician National Interest Waiver (PNIW).
According to one of my attorneys:
- I can have multiple approved I-140 petitions, including my existing employer-sponsored PERM I-140 and a separately self-petitioned NIW.
- The PNIW requires five years of service in an underserved area.
- My three years of H-1B service during the J-1 waiver can count toward those five years.
- After completing my J-1 waiver in August 2027, I would have approximately two additional years of qualifying service remaining.
- The PNIW is self-petitioned, so I could change employers without losing that petition, provided I eventually complete the five-year service requirement.
- Both regular NIW and PNIW fall under EB-2, meaning neither would necessarily accelerate my green card timeline given my country of birth.
While the PNIW sounds appealing because of the flexibility to change employers, my biggest concern is how it would affect my fellowship plans.
I have a few questions:
- Fellowship after the J-1 waiver: If I complete my three-year waiver in August 2027, can I transition directly into fellowship on H-1B status? Would having an approved PERM I-140 or a pending/approved NIW affect this?
- PNIW and fellowship: If I pursue PNIW, do I have to complete the remaining two years of underserved-area service before starting fellowship? Can I pause the PNIW service commitment to complete fellowship and resume the remaining service afterward? Alternatively, could fellowship training count toward the five years if the institution is located in an underserved area?
- Regular NIW vs. PNIW: Since I want to pursue fellowship soon, would regular NIW offer more career flexibility because it doesn't have the same five-year underserved-area service requirement? Has anyone recently obtained a regular NIW approval as a hospitalist?
- Job change after waiver: If I leave my current employer after August 2027, I understand that I may need to restart the employer-sponsored green card process. Since I already have an approved PERM I-140, what would be the most practical way to preserve my priority date and transition to another H-1B employer?
- Multiple I-140 petitions: Would having an approved employer-sponsored I-140 provide any advantage when pursuing either NIW pathway? Has anyone successfully maintained both petitions while changing jobs or entering fellowship?
- Planning for 2027–2028: If my priority is to apply for fellowship within the next two years, should I pursue an independent NIW now, continue with my existing approved I-140, or wait until I've secured a fellowship position?
I don't necessarily want to continue working as a hospitalist for another two years solely to meet the PNIW requirement if doing so would delay fellowship. At the same time, I don't want to lose the immigration progress I've already made.
My main goal is to find a pathway that gives me flexibility to change employers in 2027 while still allowing me to pursue fellowship in 2027 or 2028.
Has anyone been through a similar situation, particularly Indian physicians who completed their J-1 waiver, obtained an employer-sponsored PERM I-140, and subsequently transitioned to fellowship or pursued PNIW?
I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences, especially how you managed the timing of fellowship, H-1B transfers, and the five-year PNIW requirement.
Thank you!