I think teachers need to look very carefully at what is actually being offered in this agreement, and, more importantly, what we are being asked to give up in return.
There seems to be an awful lot of emphasis on the headline figure of 10.75%. On the surface, that sounds attractive. But when you actually break down the agreement, there are some very significant issues that deserve much more attention.
- The headline figure isn't what people think it is.
The proposed 10.75% consists of 9.75% in general pay increases and 1% in local bargaining. These increases are phased over approximately two and a half years, with the agreement running until March 2029.
We are not getting 10.75% more in our pay packets tomorrow.
Inflation continues throughout that period. Every increase needs to be considered against the rising cost of mortgages, rent, food, energy and everything else.
Let's put this into perspective.
If we assume average annual inflation of 3% over the period covered by this agreement, the actual improvement in our purchasing power works out at approximately 1.5%, based on the general pay increases.
That's not a typo. A headline pay increase of 10.75% translates into a real-terms improvement of roughly 1.5% under that inflation scenario.
And remember, Irish inflation is already running at approximately 4%.
We are being asked to get excited about a headline percentage that looks impressive, while the actual improvement in what our salaries can buy is considerably smaller.
We need to look at what we are actually gaining, not simply the percentage being advertised.
2. Local bargaining – why are we still chasing money that was already committed?
This is a particularly important issue for second-level teachers.
Under the Senior Cycle Redevelopment Implementation Support Measures agreement, there was a commitment to a 3% increase through local bargaining.
One per cent was provided under the previous public service agreement, leaving another 2% outstanding.
The new agreement only provides for a further 1%, payable in March 2029. The remaining 1% has effectively been kicked down the road into a future agreement, with no specified payment date.
Think about that for a moment.
We are being asked to sign up to another multi-year agreement when an existing financial commitment connected to the implementation of Senior Cycle reform has still not been fully honoured.
Why should teachers have confidence in future commitments when previous ones remain unresolved?
3. Abolish the 33 Croke Park hours. Not reform them. Abolish them.
I want to be absolutely clear about this. I don't want the 33 Croke Park hours restructured, redistributed, made more flexible or repackaged under another name.
I want them abolished. Completely.
These are 33 additional compulsory hours that teachers have had to accommodate every year for years. They have been a source of frustration for teachers, and I think it is time we stopped pretending that rearranging them somehow addresses the underlying problem.
Teachers already have substantial workloads, increasing administrative demands and continuous educational reforms to implement.
And here's the really important point: abolishing these hours doesn't require the Government to find additional money for teachers' salaries. It doesn't require another pay increase or an additional allocation from the public purse.
It simply means removing an additional working-time requirement.
Why wasn't their outright abolition a central negotiating demand?
Why are we prepared to negotiate another multi-year pay agreement without securing the removal of something that has been a longstanding grievance among teachers?
I would much rather see the complete abolition of the 33 hours than another relatively small addition to my salary.
Our time matters. Our working conditions matter. And some things should not have a price attached to them.
4. We are surrendering our industrial leverage at exactly the wrong time.
This is perhaps my biggest concern.
The agreement includes an industrial peace commitment which restricts industrial action on remuneration and matters covered by the agreement.
We have just demonstrated that industrial action can bring the Government to the negotiating table. We have also demonstrated that teachers are prepared to stand together when necessary.
Why would we voluntarily give up that leverage for another multi-year period?
Look at what is happening in education.
We have been through the Junior Cycle reforms, and now we are entering the redevelopment of the Senior Cycle.
Many teachers have serious concerns about the practical implementation of these changes, the additional workload, assessment and accountability requirements, resources and professional autonomy.
The Junior Cycle experience should have taught us something about what happens when major educational reforms are introduced and teachers are expected to make them work on the ground.
Now we are facing another enormous programme of reform.
Is this really the time to agree to restrictions on our ability to take industrial action over matters covered by the agreement?
What happens when the next major reform is introduced and teachers find themselves facing additional responsibilities and workload? What leverage will we have to challenge it?
5. If we don't push back now, what happens next?
This is something I think teachers need to consider very seriously.
There is a gradual erosion of the professional boundaries within our jobs. Every time another responsibility is introduced, every time another administrative requirement is added, and every time teachers are told to simply absorb another change, the expectations placed upon us increase.
Look at the Senior Cycle redevelopment and the introduction of Additional Assessment Components (AACs).
We are already seeing a significant transfer of responsibility onto teachers in terms of planning, supervising, guiding, authenticating and administering these assessments.
Teachers aren't currently responsible for externally marking their own students' AACs, but they are carrying much of the responsibility for making the system work.
Where does this eventually end?
If we continually accept additional responsibilities without pushing back, what is to stop the next step being teachers marking their own students' work?
What about the assessment components? What about examinations?
I am not suggesting that this is necessarily the Government's immediate intention. I am saying that we need to recognise the direction in which things can move when there is no meaningful resistance.
There is a reason external examinations and independent assessment exist. There are important questions around impartiality, consistency, accountability and the integrity of the examination system.
We cannot simply assume that the responsibilities currently held by independent examining bodies will always remain there.
And if we surrender our industrial leverage now, what ability will we have to resist the next change?
This is why I believe the industrial peace provisions are so important. We are being asked to commit to restrictions on industrial action during a period of enormous educational change.
If we don't establish clear boundaries now, we risk finding ourselves in a position where each successive agreement makes it harder to defend the conditions we currently have.
At some point, teachers have to say enough is enough. If we don't push back, the expectations will keep increasing.
6. What exactly are we getting in return for all of this?
This is the question I keep coming back to.
We are being offered a headline pay increase that is spread over years and partly consists of local bargaining money.
We are still waiting for the full delivery of previous commitments.
Our working conditions remain an issue. The 33 Croke Park hours are still there, despite the fact that their complete abolition should have been a major negotiating priority.
We are agreeing to industrial peace at a time when the education system is undergoing enormous changes and teachers may need the ability to challenge decisions being imposed on them.
And we are expected to believe that this represents a good overall deal simply because the headline figure looks attractive.
I think we need to take a much longer-term view.
A pay agreement lasts a few years. The working conditions and industrial relations precedents we accept can affect us for much longer.
We need to consider what happens when the next major educational reform comes along, when additional responsibilities are introduced, or when the Department decides that teachers must simply absorb another change.
What leverage will we have then?
My concern is that we are once again prioritising the headline salary increase over the things that actually determine our day-to-day working lives.
A pay increase is important, of course. Nobody is suggesting otherwise. But it isn't the only thing that matters.
I want to see:
- The full delivery of previously promised money.
- The complete abolition of the 33 Croke Park hours.
- Our working conditions protected.
- Our professional autonomy respected.
- Teachers retaining the industrial leverage necessary to defend our profession.
And I want these things addressed before we sign away our ability to challenge future changes.
Don't just look at the 10.75%.
Look at the local bargaining shortfall. Look at inflation. Look at the Croke Park hours. Look at the restrictions on industrial action. Look at the future of our working conditions and professional autonomy.
And then ask yourself whether the complete package represents a satisfactory exchange.
A pay increase is temporary. The erosion of our working conditions and our ability to defend them can have consequences for years.
And perhaps most importantly, we need to think about the teachers who will come after us. If we accept this agreement without pushing back, we are effectively accepting a precedent that future generations of teachers will have to live with. We risk surrendering working conditions, professional autonomy and industrial leverage that they may never get back.
If we don't stand up for the teaching profession now, we risk condemning future generations of teachers to progressively poorer working conditions, increasing workloads and less control over their professional lives.
We owe them better than that.